Anthony's Hearthfire Review

Food, service, ambience... Everything was top notch!

Great experience here tonight. Service was top notch for a big party, and the food and drinks were excellent. Will definitely go again.

Wonderful food and fun with family. Watching ducks, seals. Eating seafood.

Nice Anthony's location, good service, nice wine. Menu focus wasn't what we thought it was going to be however.

This location is amazing. Happy Hour until 7pm and the deck makes you feel like you are on a boat heading north into the Puget Sound. The food at Anthony's. Is always great!

I have been here more times than I can count and was shocked to find I have never given it a review on Yelp. It is my one of my favorite happy hour locations in my local area - especially in the summer. This is an upscale restaurant that sits right on the water, and the normal menu is a bit beyond what I like to pay on a regular basis, so I don't eat here often for regular meals. But their daily happy hour 4-7 can't be beat! The drinks range from beers to martinis, and I usually have a fruity martini. The lemon drops, cosmopolitans, elderberry, and apple martinis are my favorites and are only $6.50. The food on happy hour ranges from pizzas, dips, salmon sliders, wings, etc. On this trip I had a BBQ chicken pizza ($7) and the Crab and Shrimp Dip ($8). All the snacks I have ever tried were very yummy! The best part of this place is in the summer you can get happy hour on the deck which has the best view and is literally right over the water. The only negatives are that the bar area fills very fast so unless you get there early you likely won't get a seat. And as a result of being crowded, the service is slow. But, it is well worth the wait! This is a must visit.... especially on a warm summer afternoon!

Can't say enough about the great food here. The service is equally outstanding. The filet is amazing and the huckleberry slump dessert is to die for. A very fine restaurant.

Great view of Sound, clean, social distancing in place, expect to spend some $$$.

Always a Great Place to meet with Friends and Family. Staff is amazing and the food absolutely YUMMY.

Always great food. Waiter was wonderful. I know it is Anthony's, but it would be even better if the prices were a tad bit lower.

Our server wasn't having a good day. The food was okay.

Went in 3 nights ago and when we got sat it took 20 min for a server to get us drinks then our glasses were dirty my glass had red lipstick stain on the outside of it you could feel it dirty my alcoholic beverage had a red hair in the whip cream. The food overall was good. But the server didnt really come to see if we needed anything else or if we enjoyed our food it wasnt busy so I would understand if it was busy and that's why the server didnt check on us.

My favorite place to go for great food and atmosphere.

Made a Reservation, got seated & got water... Then waited for 20 minutes and still no one came to take our drink order. The place was not busy at all. Walked out and we were wished a great evening... We drove from the Portland area for date night. Ended up 5 minutes down the road at the other Anthony's... Great service!

Fabulous restaurant food exquisite staff customer friendly...Gentlemen a nice hidden place to propose to your love

Always great seafood, good service, and beautiful views.

Delicious food & cocktails, beautiful view, quiet and romantic setting without the pressure of *needing* to be dressed up. Friendly, happy staff who make sure your experience is great. Perfect date night restaurant, year after year =)

Overpriced, small plates but tasty, nice view on a harbor

The food is always delicious! Service can sometimes be iffy but overall great place

Stunning views, upscale restaurant, very good service, delicious food.

Our favorite place for dinner together! Food has wonderful taste with excellent presentation! Service was friendly and professional! Views were outrageous!

What a beautiful experience! The view is awesome. The food is exquisite. The service is exceptional.

Great service. Delicious food. If you're there before 6pm ask for the special 4 course meal.

Great service and food. Happy hour food and drink specials. Kinda hard to find but worth the effort. Fantastic views in clear weather.

We had a coupon for a deep discount . Good thing since the experience matched the value of the cost. I had rotisserie garlic Chicken . Over cooked and dry, but I could eat it. The food was okay, but the service was not. Much was promiised, but little delivered as we were left sitting for 10 minutes waiting for water and bread. Twice we had to wait for too long for refills .

Found myself pleasantly surprised by an accidental arrival of their corn chowder. Delicate and sweet pieces of Dungeness crab are found swimming with a few pieces of corn in a silky cream sauce.

I have enjoyed this restaurant since it was opened, and highly recommend a visit for the atmosphere and faire. They take reservations, and are on the water for a nice view of the Puget Sound at Budd Inlet.

Wonderful atmosphere and the best view around. Swell service and good food

The food was good. My steak was over cooked to my requested specifications. But it was still pretty good. Our sever though was not good. He was to preoccupied with a larger group. He came over filled half of the waters at the table said he was going to get more, then never returned.

There for business meeting. Draft beer choices ok. Very limited seafood selection which I thought weird for a Anthony's. Looks like it's got a choice location for outdoor dining but weather did not accommodate. Standard Anthony's setting of nautical theme, light but lots of wood wall coverings. Service good.

Delicious salad and the view is amazing. Not many people at lunch. Service was great.

Expensive. Food was not that great for the money. Service was ok
I woul not recommend

We celebrate birthdays and good weather over great food and service.

Good food good experience good atmosphere recommend to all well be back to enjoy again
Thanks to a great staff of people providing excellent service ! )
Dale & Eva

Got married on the beach here as the waters receded during sunset while the clams squirted in joy. Then had a wonderful dinner as the night came down. Planned it here for this reason, as you can watch God move over the water through the massive windows.

Great place! Food was wonderful - they have a great early dinner special. Staff is very friendly.

Great service flavors of the food were awesome and the mixed drinks are great

VERY limited lunch menu. No appetizers is kind of a bummer. Although you can get complimentary flat bread on request.

Our server was the Best! The menu selection and food not so good. Kitchen was very slow and food was fair in taste and preparation. Think they need a new Chef.

Steak and lobster portions very small for the prices. The 1/2 chicken with ribs was great. The desserts were awesome (burnt creme and chocolate dulce de luce).

We brought our 95 year mother with us and she was greeted and treated royally! All of our meals were exceptionally delicious! We saw a beautiful sunset as we relaxed after dinner. Mike A. was our delightful waiter, he was so thoughtful and looked after us the entire time we were at Anthony's Firehearth! Thank you Mike! We'll be back! The Robert Ohman Family

Great view, over priced menu for what you get, mediocre wait staff. Also very willing to make up for mistakes.

Awesome view, courteous staff and tasty food. A little pricey but I think that s the going rate near Seattle.

Good Happy Hour choices and very tasty. We laughed & joked with Bar Staff as I looked up Bloody Mary's containing things like 2 roasted chickens in them from a Blake Shelton post.

Nice place but you can't order off the happy hour menu in the dining room.

It was a good experience. Good service. You can watch the chefs cook and there is a great view of the Puget Sound. Is pricy but worth it for the price. Would recommend.

Superb dining experience! Delicious, perfect food!! Love this place.

Menu hasn't changed much in the last few years. Good food. Expect a wait and slow service so you can check out the view.

In addition to excellent food and service, Hearthfire has an amazing view! Menus are always updated to feature seasonal food. Pro tip: get the Huckleberry Slump.

Best views, best happy hour. For guests from out of town, this is a must stop at least once. The views on the waterfront are the best. The happy hour is a great value and if you want to stay for dinner it's just fabulous food but a little pricey

4 of us enjoyed a nice meal, a good wine and the Christmas boats sailing by all lighted up. It was a lovely evening.

Hearthfire is easily one of my favorite restaurants in Oly. The food and service are always good and the view at sunset is stellar. The only negative I can add is that both of our steaks were undercooked. Our server actually noticed while checking on us and corrected it. (He told us that we weren't the first that day so perhaps someone new was on the grill?) The remainder of our meal was excellent as usual.

Delicious food and great drinks. Gorgeous views too!

Excellent food. Good early bird value menu. Highly recommended. Nice place to take your family.

Great corner table with 270 degree view. Excellent service and great value on early bird menu.

Update - 6.16.2018

We requested patio seating when booking and again when restaurant called to confirm. Then we got there they sat us inside and when I asked about our patio reservation I was suddenly told it was first come first serve on the patio. This should have been our first red flag.. But the poor service continued. 15 minutes for cocktails. Appetizer and salad were great, then ordered another round of drinks for dinner, another 15-20 minute wait and they were not in the correct glass and half the size as first round. Steaks both came out well done even though we ordered medium rare and medium, another 15 minutes for new steaks, they did remake whole plates, but two bites into steak and I was full from eating the side items off the first plate. We were grateful for them comping most of the bill, but sadly we won't be back. It took us a year to come back after the first time we had poor service. Additional bartenders & chefs are a must. No reason for 2 people to have a 1 hour and 50 minute dining experience.

Delicious food! Service was lacking, but the views made up for it!

Great view and food. Was a little louder than expected and lights were flickering.

Had a great visit and tasty meal while enjoying the fantastic view.

The views are great.. food is good too. Wish the menu had more selections.

Great food the hostess when we arrived was very disinterested in her job.

Very overpriced and bland, but had an excellent view (the only reason I gave 2 stars) the chowder was very sweet not a local traditional chowder and they didnt have ranch dressing when requested. Burger was mediocre at best. Chicken was slightly dry and not seasoned well. Definitely will not be returning and was embarrassed bringing a family member here from out of town for local cousine for the first time.

My husband is a yacht broker. We stopped there for lunch as my husband had business there. He ordered a pizza which was good and I ordered the Crab & Shrimp toast. The toast was good, but when I went to take a bite of the coleslaw the dish it was put in was really dirty. I told the waitress and she explained to me they fixed other things in those dishes, WHAT!!!! That doesn't matter to me what they fixed in them, a dirty dish is a dirty dish. At that time she took my coleslaw away and told me she told her manager. No apology, no adjusting the food bill, nothing. Shame on you Anthony's restaurant for allowing this to happen and shame on the manager if she even told him. We will never go back or suggest this restaurant as a good place to eat. Susan

Food is terrible. 2nd time this month and not another. Used to be good food. Fish and chips, hardly any fish, then today steak tacos of which the tortillas tasted like shoe leather and the steak very salty

The happy hour food was fabulous! Salmon, pizza & artichoke dip, So good!

Amazing steakhouse, probably the best steak I've ever had