My fiancee and I finally decided to splurge and go...
My fiancee and I finally decided to splurge and go to Alinea for dinner. The reservation system is really nice because, even though it's pricy, you've already pre-paid for your dinner and thus feel less stressed about the money part once you're there. The only thing you add on when you're there is drink pairings.
The entire experience is simply phenomenal, and it's really a place where you should think of it as an event rather than just a dinner. What I loved most is that it wasn't super pretentious. Yes, you dress nicely and it's a fancy restaurant. But, it's not stuffy. There are comfortable chairs and nice wood tables. But there aren't white tablecloths and dim lighting. I would describe it as having a modern flair with a very clean look. There are also very few tables in the room, so it feels more private.
For the drink pairings, I really liked that you could split a pairing between yourselves and thus only pay for one pairing. That way, you can both taste the drinks that they recommend with your food but not feel like you're breaking the bank (for people that are more money conscious).
As for the food, it was simply spectacular! With so many small dishes, the worry is that you'll leave here still hungry. But, that's anything but the truth. The dishes are spaced out perfectly and timed to your eating style, so it's great because you are never waiting too long, and you end up leaving stuffed. Each dish is also its own little experience, so make sure to savor every moment. If at all possible, don't pay attention to the other tables! That way, you can have each dish be a little surprise. :)
Overall, I was definitely not disappointed by Alinea and would highly recommend everyone goes at least once to experience it.