Adriatico’s Pizza and Sports Bar Reviews

Went here on the suggestions of locals and yelp. Was not impressed at all by the food. I was really let down. The service was great though.

New location, same great tasting pizza and pasta! I love the new look of the inside!

Looking for New York style pie? This is your place. The pizza here is phenomenal and this is arguably my favorite pizza spot in Columbus. You cant go wrong with Adriatico's, Mmmm.......

Our server was nice but the beer list was small and my pizza was burnt.

Tried while in town because of the reviews. The person taking my order was very nice and polite, and the location is very cool. I ordered a pepperoni sicilian style as that was their "famous one". That comes with one large pepperoni in the center of each square shaped slice. If it was covered in pepperoni's that would have been a plus but the crust was very bland. Greasy but I expected that and dont care, got the twisted breadsticks which is made with the same dough as the crust, so again very bland. They have a good garlic butter though. I'm not being mean just honest, I cant understand how they won best pizza in Columbus. Better than Pizza Hut, but not Papa Johns, Cassanos (personal favorite), or Donatos.

TL DR: Bland dough and breadsticks, excellent pepperoni but not enough, good garlic butter, employees and restaurant were awesome.

Nice pizza place in the center of Columbus. The hours are great and they're affordable. The only knock I'd have is that their regular crust pizzas with multiple toppings are a bit top heavy. It's a negligible complaint. I'd still recommend checking them out. Their staff are pretty friendly.

I do prefer their New York Style pizza, but that's not actually what they were originally known for, or what they sell the most of. They sell the thick crust (Chicago style) more frequently than the most delicious fold over New York Style pizza in this city. If they don't win number one pizza, somthing is definitely wrong with the voters! :) Longtime love with Adriatico's! I used to buy a pizza so big for $6 that would fee me and two other neighbors for a week! Of course prices have risen but it's still possible! Highly recommend! Parking is a nightmare, and it's a small establishment, but IT IS WORTH IT!

My room mates favorite. Class of 79. Lol. Got one for his birthday today. Happy birthday #95 alumni Larry Phillips.

I called to place an order, but the girl who took my order was very rude. I was disappointed by how she talked to her customer.

Good service, but the pizza was terrible. Crust was very doughy and sauce was tasteless. Not good pizza , and definitely not New York style.

Best pizza in Columbus! Has been for years. Reasonably priced and the new spot is very nice and clean.

Get 6 friends and go order a Buckeye with pepperoni and sausage. You're welcome.

Man, This truly is a Five Stars Pizza! I'm not gonna talk about their pizza quality, because you prolly already know how good it is.

One time I was studying so hard at Thompson Library and decided to get Adriatico's. Delivery came in like 10 minutes. But, what's crazy about Adriatico's is that, the delivery dude went ABOVE & BEYOND! Dude called me asked me which floor I sat and I told him "hmm, 2nd floor, but no worries I'll meet you down". But man, he insisted to deliver my pizza to my table.

This definitely is one of my memorable OSU moments, it was also my last Final at OSU.

Five Stars for Adriatico's!

Nice place with good pizza and good selection of beers. Great to sit at the bar on a date. Can order custom cans of beer to go from anything on tap and watch it be canned on the spot.

Loved every bit ... With Food this good it's hard to think about a diet lololol.. great food n.y. style hot n fresh

Best pizza I have ever eaten!!! It's been three years since I had it and can't get it out of my head!

Still delicious! And thanks to Adriana for the great service

Where do I start..... this place is great. Of your in Columbus you have to try their pizza. The thick crust buckeye pizza is enough to feed an army and it's delicious!

The new location is amazing. Loved the food as always.

Excellent pizza. The service was very good. One of the best pizzas in town.

Pizza was good. Server wasn't very personable, that is why I am not giving 5 stars.

The pizza is good, but not great in my opinion, however they have the best calzones I've ever had -- very large and a great value for $8. The new location is very clean and the staff are very nice. If you can get a table in the lower section, it's a great place to watch a game.

Great pizza and gelato is delicious. Fantastic staff.

We enjoyed the food very much. Excellent pizza, salad and breadsticks. Our server Ryan's was wonderful. Very helpful and informative. We enjoyed getting to know her. We'll be back if in the area again.

I used to eat here a lot when I lived on campus. I decided to make the venture again. I ordered the Meaty, thick crust. It came out excesivley greasy. It even got on my clothes on the way out to the car. Maybe just a classic pepperoni would have been a better choice. Giving 4 stars since it was still pretty good once i dabbed the pizza with some paper towels.

Love the pizza! Bread with the garlic butter is awesome too.

Love the italian sub with italian dressing on the side

Our go to pizza place in Columbus. Love the sicilian pizza. Great service and atmosphere.

One of the best pizzas in central Ohio, pricey though.

Excellent pizza and sub's. They deliver to the hospital for free.

New location is SO clean! Pizza is still phenomenal

Good pizza, on the more expensive side but great place to go out with friends

One of the two greatest pizza places on OSU campus in my opinion! Great place to grab take-out on your way off campus and a popular lunch spot. Waitresses here are nice and speedy, though remember that you have to bring your check up to the front counter to pay (otherwise you will be waiting a long time). Their personal size pizzas make a delicious/filling/affordable meal if you are on your own or just don't like what everyone else in your party wants.

Great food. Takeout is good since the place is small.

Spicy sauce, lots of cheese, best thick crust in Columbus

Pizza is DELICIOUS. I'm not from Columbus and I was disappointed with all the super thin crust pizza here but this is definitely the best pizza in Columbus. The staff was very friendly and our server Adriana was AWESOME. Restaurant has a cool vibe and was clean. They also serve beer & wine.

i forgot to do a review and it was before the new store opened but deep dish pizza is top notch,i'll be back

Wow! Great pizza. A must have whenever I'm in Columbus. They also just got a new location that is very upscale looking. They also now serve Gelato, which is interesting.

The big deal about their pizza is the crust, dough, and cheese. They put on so much cheese. The dough is nice and soft and thick, and the crust is thick and crunchy. The sauce isn't sweet like a lot of pizzas are, which is nice.

You can also order take home and bake pizzas here as well. We did, and it came out perfect.

The pizza and the wings are really great! I expected much less when I ordered the first time because they were cheap and so close to campus, but I was very impressed, and I have continued to go to Adriatico's for all of my pizza cravings.

This has gotta be the best thick-crust pizza I've ever had. Nothing comes close to this place. Try it, you'll love it.

I'm very picky about all parts of pizza separately for different reasons. This pizza was perfect on all counts.

If you're having a party or just dinner they got the size for you with good quilty.

Not bad, not great. Two out of three things we ordered were not right. My Hawaiian pizza was just ok.

The establishment itself is relatively small, with approximately 10 tables. Its strength is not in decor, but in the comfort of the atmosphere and quality of the food. Adriatico's serves two styles of pizza, but their thick-square variety is the most popular. Their style is thick, greasy, seasoned squares with a large slice of pepperoni on each piece. It has been a frequent winner of "Best Pizza in Columbus" for good reason! This is not cheap cardboard pizza and this is not pizza that piles on exotic toppings to be "interesting"- this is just a solid, filling pizza with a lot of flavor.Their "Monday & Tuesday Night Madness" deals offer significant discounts on their pizzas. Their enormous "Buckeye" pizza can almost cover a small tabletop. College students looking for cheap and filling food options to last for several days might want to consider Adriatico's on Mondays and Tuesdays.

Usually get this late at night after a skate session downtown. Always hot and tasty. Fast delivery.

Small quaint place near the OSU Wexner Medical Center (walking distance 0.3 miles). While my wife is getting cancer treatment, this is a nice place to go and sit down and enjoy one of the many beers they have on tap. The selection is nice and the food is good. Pizza is the way it is suppose to be and other like wings are a nice change when you've had too much pizza. The staff is courteous and will defiantly go again and again.

Thought the thin crust was really good, enjoyed the big peps and sausage wasn't generic kind you normally get. I recommend eating it at the restaurant as you get the crust crispy.

Very good pizza. A little skimpy on the toppings but great flavor :)

Delicious food, right next to South campus. Sometimes this place is busy, but the prices are very reasonable. Would recommend!

I've loved the pizza here since college! Always recommend! Wish their delivery area was bigger.

Very thick crust pizza that's excellent. Place is small and atmosphere is cozy, service is good.

Best pie in town if they just delivered to my place

Our favorite deep dish in the city, and the bread sticks can't be beat!

If you want "real" New York Style go to Late Night Slice at Short North...

I thought I would try this restaurant out after during a Postmates order a couple of months back and seeing how busy it was so I ordered my pizza it came out hot I did have to wait a few minutes for them to finish preparing it but upon getting home and tasting the pizza it has no flavor no type of seasoning on it Pizza taste very Bland and I will not be back to this

Very good pizza!!! The wait was a little long on a Sunday afternoon, but for the quality of pizza it was worth it

Best pizza in Columbus IMO. Easily best campus pizza. Tastes as good now as 20yrs ago when I was in school.

First time eating here and I loved this pizza!!! The Pepperoni is great!!!

Not a bad place, just not for me. The food is nothing special, overpriced, and the place is crowded with TVs and sports channels.

The pizza is top notch and the service was as well. I will be making the cross town trip for the place.

Get it big, get it thick crust, and get the best pizza around! An OSU tradition!

High quality pizza. The chicken bacon ranch is my favorite.

Best deep dish pizza in Columbus. All their food is way above par.

Excellent Pizza. Fresh ingredients. Really good sauce. Friendly staff.