I wish there was a 4.5 star option. I've had bett...

I wish there was a 4.5 star option. I've had better, but only from a true 5 star restaurant!

Pros: Good atmosphere. Great service and staff. Good prices (for the quality. It's a little on the pricey side, but for the quality and service it's worth it!)
Cons: Could have more local beers on tap.

This is the top of the line for it's category. Great atmosphere, fantastic service, great food. Staff was welcoming, friendly, funny, talkative, and attentive. Atmosphere is a high end tavern with a welcoming feel. Beer list was good, not extensive, and could feature more local brews. I had the salmon, which was expertly cooked, the sides were good, not great. Portions were good, not wanting, but not small.

Note: This was a hard review. I've had better, but only because the quality was bordering on a true 5 star restaurant. This is not a black tie experience, but the food could easily be comparable. Rusty bucket straddles the line between high end bar and a dining experience.

Overall would highly recommend.