We visited for a friend's wedding and overall real...

We visited for a friend's wedding and overall really enjoyed our experience. I just question the 4 star rating. I'll break it down in "the good", the ok" and the "this is not 4 star".

THE GOOD:
Super friendly and fun staff
Really comfortable bed
Quick response whenever we called the front desk for anything
Adults only Preferred Club pool/lounge was a relaxing and quiet place to hang out
The wedding itself was beautiful and really fun

THE OK:
Food, though accessible, is not great.
Our "ocean view" room - yes, we could see the ocean if we looked past the family friendly pool and restaurants. No exactly the tranquil sounds of the ocean we were hoping for.
The "stocked mini bar" is just soda and waters.
Pretty property, but a little worn

THIS IS NOT 4 STAR:
The huge rust stain in our tub
The frayed robe in the closet
The staff constantly speaking to each other in Spanish in front of guests
We were twice served drinks in broken glasses
The band aids and cigarette butts we found surrounding our chairs on the beach (granted, not on the preferred beach)

All in all, we enjoyed our trip. It was a nice place to stay, just know this is not a super luxury resort!