First let me say that Benny's has some great steak...

First let me say that Benny's has some great steaks, and the red wine mushrooms are amazing. Having said that, don't order anything else. The shrimp was okay, and crab legs are hard to screw up but every other piece of seafood was just outright terrible. Scallops were not cooked properly, salmon was tough and overdone, and the fish was a total disaster. I was literally picking scales out of my mouth. They also need to work on what they call blackened. Inexcusable for an island restaurant.

The service was impeccable and atmosphere always pleasant though. Just... wow, that was bad seafood, particularly for the price tag.