Paul Colacicco

Review of Reynolds Tavern

The food is always like 70% of what you really wan...

The food is always like 70% of what you really want, sort of hard to describe the constant near misses you will experience here. Ordered a salad and the waiter guessed they had ranch dressing and told me he thought that might be the only option (it wasn't). They can't split a check to save their lives so don't count in that. Service is often slow or inattentive and the cocktails leave you wanting more. HOWEVER, the atmosphere is great on the back patio and no one can mess up a beer. If you want to have a drink and a chat and want to pay too much for food that will only remind you of something better you had somewhere else, this is a good choice.