Worst meal we had on the island and the service wa...

Worst meal we had on the island and the service was no better. We wanted to love Bennie's as it had good reviews and were in the mood for a good steak after a week of seafood. Worst filet I've had in some time. Mine WAS cooked to my liking but I had to salt it! No flavor at all. The waiter rushed us the entire meal and mentioned that he had gotten called in so he wasn't supposed to be working (and you could tell he didn't want to be). My boyfriend's steak (ordered medium rare like mine) was medium well at best and not good.

The oysters were the grossest thing I've ever seen/had. My sister ordered raw oysters for her meal and ate only one. They were already shucked - never seen that before - and literally all sitting in a bowl of water over shredded lettuce. Disgusting.

We left and went to the village for snacks and desserts. Please up your standards. I visited Bennie's 10+ years ago and DO NOT remember an experience like this. Bennie's was packed that night so we may be the anomaly and I hope we are, because we would like to find good steak at SSI.