Alexandra Crilly

Review of Reynolds Tavern

I made the mistake of having my birthday and brida...

I made the mistake of having my birthday and bridal shower here. My order was forgotten and then late and made poorly. The fries were overdone and greasy and the tomatoes were missing from the blt. I requested that the small 10$ sandwich be removed from the check since it was late and not good and I didn't get to eat with my guests. Please keep in mind, it was a large group and order. The owner/manager, Westin came out and was extremely rude and said he refused to remove it. He stated that he didn't care it was my birthday or bridal shower. The manager speaking with the group caused quite a large argument and a scene. Me and my guests were very shocked at how the manager was treating us and how rude he was acting. It was a horrible experience! I don't have the words to even describe how bad this all went down. One of the guests brought a small cake and the manager/owner said he would charge us to eat the cake at the place. We declined and he yelled at us saying that we were just mad about the cake which we were not. One of my friends face was red and was giggling because she was uncomfortable and he yelled, "you can sit there giggling all you want". In the conversation, some guests mentioned that we would not be recommending this place and he urged us to do that. I was surprised but decided to follow his advice so I'm here writing this review.
I cannot recommend this place and I will never ever return.
So, in the end, nothing was resolved. We left unhappy and we ate the small cake outside in the cold December weather.