Haven't used Heartbeet Kitchen yet?
Ask Trustburn

What reviewers say about Heartbeet Kitchen

Based on 200 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers consistently praise the products for being moist, delicious, and easy to prepare, often highlighting the adaptability of the mixes and the quality of the flavor profiles.
What is Heartbeet Kitchen?

Heartbeet Kitchen is a Wisconsin-based food blog and recipe site founded by Amanda Paa in 2011, specializing in homemade gluten-free recipes and traditional sourdough baking. The business is for home cooks looking for seasonal vegetable dishes, whole grain breads, and canning guides. Visitors can get started by browsing the recipe index or signing up for the email list to receive exclusive recipes and giveaways.

Where is the business located and what physical services does it offer?

The business is located in Hudson, Wisconsin, and operates out of a 1908 home that Amanda renovates and shares on the site. While it is primarily an online recipe resource, Amanda also teaches in-person beginner sourdough classes at her home for groups of 5 to 6 people.

How can a visitor book a class or learn more about the teaching services?

Amanda Paa teaches in-person beginner sourdough classes at her home in Hudson, Wisconsin. These workshops are casual 2-hour sessions that teach starter maintenance and the four main bread-making techniques: stretch and folds, shaping, scoring, and baking. Participants take home their own personal starter and eat a finished loaf together.

What specific products or recipe categories are available on the website?

The site offers a wide variety of recipes including sourdough breads, discard recipes, side dishes, soups, and desserts. Specific popular items include Everyday Sourdough Bread, Spelt Sourdough Bread, and Savory Butternut Squash Casserole with Gruyere. The platform also features a dedicated recipe search tool and an index for easy navigation.

What is the current rating and what do reviewers praise most?

The business has a 5 out of 5 rating from 200 reviews on Trustburn. Reviewers consistently praise the moisture, adaptability, and flavor of the recipes, particularly noting how well the pumpkin spice blends and sourdough textures perform. Many users mention that the instructions are spot-on and the recipes are simple enough for beginners to succeed.

What specific themes do multiple reviewers share about the food quality?

Some reviewers on Trustburn mention that the recipes are incredibly adaptable, allowing bakers to bake as loaves or muffins with perfect results. Others note that the pumpkin flavor is perfectly balanced and the scones melt in your mouth. A common theme is that the cooking process is a breeze and the food is moist and delicious.

What do Reddit users say about the baking techniques and results?

Some users on Reddit say that being able to properly track bulk fermentation was a game changer for their sourdough bakes. Others mention that the recipe for savory miso oatmeal with a jammy egg was a total game changer for their regular rotation. The community also highlights the success of using the float test to ensure the starter is ready before baking.

What are the stated ingredients and dietary focuses of the recipes?

The website states that the recipes are tested and perfected before publishing, based around seasonal vegetables, whole grains, eggs, and dairy from happy animals. Many recipes are vegetarian, and all but the sourdough recipes are gluten-free. The philosophy emphasizes fresh, simple ingredients and local sourcing when possible.

What unique features or additional content does the website include?

The site mentions that the sourdough starter has been lovingly cared for and fed for over 10 years. Amanda also shares renovations of her 1908 Wisconsin home and travel adventures on the blog. The business is an exclusive member of Mediavine and uses cookies to provide the best user experience.

How long has the business existed and what is Amanda's professional background?

The business has existed since 2011 and published a cookbook titled Smitten with Squash in 2014. Amanda also works as a freelance photographer and food stylist, helping brands make products come to life. Her background includes a career in the pharmaceutical industry before finding relaxation and creativity in the kitchen.

What is the stated philosophy behind the food and recipes?

The website says that the best meals are made with fresh, simple ingredients, local if possible, and always what’s in season. Amanda believes that good meals become great meals when you know the story behind them and that food is joy.

What specific questions have reviewers asked about adapting the recipes?

Some reviewers ask about adapting recipes, such as substituting sugar with granulated Monkfruit sweetener in the canned apple butter recipe. Others inquire about the maximum recommended time for cold fermenting dough in the fridge or why salt is added later in the process.

Is Heartbeet Kitchen on social media?

Heartbeet Kitchen has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram.

Based on reviews, listing data and the company's website. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Lauralee R
Reviews 1

I followed the Heartbeet Kitchen recipe by letting the dough ferment in the fridge overnight before baking. Instead of the suggested glaze, I brushed on some cream and added a sprinkle of sugar for a nice crunch. The scones turned out absolutely delicious. Thanks for another wonderful recipe!

Sara
Reviews 1

I am completely blown away by Heartbeet Kitchen! Their pumpkin bars are incredibly soft and literally melt in your mouth. They taste even better when served chilled straight from the fridge. You’ve really nailed the recipe with these treats!

Jessica Sollenberger
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen has truly nailed the pumpkin flavor. These scones taste just like a slice of pumpkin pie! My 15-year-old baker made them last night, and we couldn’t stop eating them. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe!

Sommer Clemenson
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s pumpkin bread mix is absolutely top-notch. The spice blend is perfectly balanced, resulting in a wonderfully moist, velvety texture. I tried it with the maple glaze instead of the usual cream cheese topping, and it was a delightful twist. I’m already planning to make it again with the sugar topping to bring to my fall book club gathering.

Jude Laurie
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really nailed it with this one. The instructions were spot-on, just like you promised. I’m definitely keeping this in my rotation for the current spring weather—it’s going to be a regular staple in my kitchen! 🌻

Dede
Reviews 1

I’m a big fan of Heartbeet Kitchen’s sourdough creations, especially the rhubarb cake, which has become a staple at our family gatherings. I was wondering if the canned apple butter recipe can be adapted by substituting the sugar with granulated Monkfruit sweetener?

Amber
Reviews 1

I’m usually not one to leave feedback on recipes, but this one deserves a shoutout. I adjusted the liquid slightly to achieve a lighter consistency, and it turned out great. Even my most picky eaters loved them, and my husband was so impressed he practically demanded I make them again soon. It’s going to be a regular weeknight staple in our home now. Thanks for the simple, tasty treat! I’m definitely interested in experimenting with the water ratios to see how else it affects the texture, but as it is, this recipe is a total winner.

Krista
Reviews 1

I’m a huge fan of Heartbeet Kitchen’s recipes and have baked this one around ten times with consistently great results. Recently, I scaled the recipe up by 50% to bake a larger loaf, and it ended up being the best bread I’ve ever made! I bulk fermented for 5.5 hours in my 72-degree kitchen and then cold fermented overnight. I’m curious if you’ve ever tried a 24-hour fridge fermentation, or what the maximum recommended time is for cold fermenting?

Michelle
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s cookies are truly exceptional! I even tried a variation for a friend by swapping half the flour for oats, and the result was just as incredible. With a fundraiser bake sale coming up, I’m definitely baking these again! 🩷

Desi
Reviews 1

I’ve had great success baking at Heartbeet Kitchen! Just place a bowl of water in the oven for about 15 minutes to create steam, then remove it and continue baking. Don’t forget to score the loaf after six minutes, and occasionally I add a second scoring after another three minutes of baking. My bread always turns out stunning!

Rachel
Reviews 1

I recently tried a recipe from Heartbeet Kitchen and it was a total breeze to make. I already had everything I needed in my pantry, using almond milk as a substitute for regular milk with no issues at all. It was the perfect morning for some fall baking. The thinly sliced apples blend right into the batter, giving the cake a wonderful moisture. Definitely give this a try; it pairs wonderfully with a fresh cup of coffee.

Suzannah
Reviews 1

A quick heads-up on your steam canning question: it works perfectly! At Heartbeet Kitchen, we’ve seen that if you stick to the manufacturer’s instructions, you can process almost everything that’s suitable for a water bath in a steam canner. It’s a reliable method when done right!

Corinne
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen truly nailed it with these chocolate chip cookies. They easily beat out all the other recipes I’ve tried over the years. I sprinkled a bit of flaky finishing salt on top, and it took the flavor to a whole new level. Absolutely delicious!

Jim
Reviews 1

Amanda, I’ve baked your loaves multiple times over the past couple of years, and they’ve always turned out well. Today I tried this specific recipe from Heartbeet Kitchen after studying the instructions closely, and it was another success. The loaf had a beautiful color, a chewy crust, and a moist, open crumb with great flavor. I found the dough quite wet and sticky after the bulk rise—specifically 4 1/2 hours after autolyse in my 75+ degree kitchen—but the timing worked out perfectly. It baked up beautifully after resting overnight in the refrigerator.

Ellen B
Reviews 1

I’ve already tried this Heartbeet Kitchen recipe twice because it’s so simple to make. I swapped out the regular spices for cardamom, and everyone who tasted it loved it. I can’t wait to serve it on a toasted bagel on a chilly winter day.

Justcindy
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s recipe is a definite keeper. As someone who has been on a long, winding sourdough journey and is finally getting better at reading the dough, this one turned out beautifully. I did need to add a bit more water to accommodate the flour blend I used—specifically dark rye, stone-ground wheat, and King Arthur APF—along with a very active starter. But honestly, the egg salad just won me over from the start.

Dani
Reviews 1

We just prepared a batch of this recipe today at Heartbeet Kitchen, and the flavor was absolutely divine straight from the pot. I’m really looking forward to seeing how the taste develops once the jars have processed and the flavors have fully melded together.

Shawn Bruner
Reviews 1

I had to sample the batch I made today right away! I went with a green pepper and five small Serranos for the kick. It was intense straight after the boil, but simmering it down and folding in the cilantro balanced the heat perfectly—the flavor is now all about that fresh cilantro. Really delicious, and I’m already planning to brew another batch in a few weeks. I’ve entered it into the local Fall Fest, and it’ll be judged by a local Hispanic restaurant here in the community. Fingers crossed!

Laura E
Reviews 1

We absolutely loved this dip at Heartbeet Kitchen! We followed the classic Ball recipe proportions using 4 ½ cups of bell peppers and just half a cup of jalapenos, and it turned out to be the perfect amount of heat for us. We’re already planning to bring it to our next potluck, served alongside crackers and a block of cream cheese.

Shirley Malove, PhD
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really nailed it with these! We have recreated this recipe several times now and the results are consistently impressive. Everyone who tastes them is totally blown away by how good they are. Big thanks to the team!

Dave Rogers
Reviews 1

I’ve dabbled in sourdough for a while now, and while my loaves are decent, I was on the hunt for inspiration to add cheese and jalapeños. That’s how I stumbled upon Heartbeet Kitchen. The process here is genuinely simpler than what I’ve tried before. Yesterday, I paired a slice of this warm, toasted bread with butter, a fried egg, and iced coffee—it was absolute perfection. I’m already planning to use it as the base for avocado toast this Saturday. Honestly, this might be the best bread I’ve ever had. Thanks for keeping your recipes so accessible and easy to follow.

Ellen Mumford
Reviews 1

I cooked this Heartbeet Kitchen recipe last week and actually forgot to try it until now. The flavor is incredible—I’m completely sold! It’s my first time using tomatillas for a green salsa, so I weighed everything to get the measurements just right. Thanks for sharing such a great recipe.

Karen
Reviews 1

I baked the Heartbeet Kitchen sourdough rye recipe exactly as written for my first attempt. Although I skipped the overnight fridge step, the result was spot on—it looked just like the photo and had that perfect light, tangy taste. I’m making it again today to test out adding caraway seeds and doing the overnight refrigeration for comparison. Thanks for the great instructions!

Caley Block
Reviews 1

Big shoutout to Heartbeet Kitchen for being such a great source of inspiration! Your baking tips really helped me level up my sourdough game, and I still go back to your recipes often. Really excited to try out your cookies next. Hope you’re doing well—keep up the great content!

Court
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen delivered exactly what I needed. As a baker at 4,500 feet, I followed the cold start method at 450°F for 50 minutes and the result was spot on. I might bump it to 55 minutes next time for that extra touch. Perfect solution for anyone trying to craft great bread on a tight budget without the hassle of preheating a Dutch oven.

Elise
Reviews 1

Absolutely blown away by Heartbeet Kitchen! I’d easily give this a six-star rating. The dough is incredibly soft and airy, making it a breeze to work with. I swapped the bread flour for 00 flour and scaled down to two larger pies instead of five medium ones. Following their baking instructions to the letter—preheating cast iron for an hour at 500 degrees and baking for nine minutes—yielded perfect results. The only minor hiccup was getting the parchment paper off, but that didn’t detract from the amazing outcome at all. I’ll definitely be making these again!

B
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen makes a tasty drink, but don't expect the final result to look exactly like their photos. While the syrup starts as a vibrant red, the flavor profile shines when you mix in the lime, orange, and tequila. Just be aware that adding those citrus elements shifts the hue to a much paler orange rather than the bright red shown online.

Sara
Reviews 1

Just tried the Smash Burger Tacos at Heartbeet Kitchen tonight and they were a huge hit! The best part? My daughter’s boyfriend, who hangs out here often, was so impressed he told my daughter he had to play it cool so I wouldn’t think he was overreacting. He literally said it was the best thing he’s eaten in months. I love getting my kids to pick recipes from social media to keep our menu fresh, but since he’s around so much, I’m making him choose our new go-tos. Now we have a funny dilemma: I told the girls we won’t repeat recipes, so he had to compromise on his choice—ordering the smash burger tacos again but asking for a different cheese next time! 🤣

Fallon
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really nailed the flavor on this one! I swapped in a gluten-free tortilla to keep things flour-free, and it worked perfectly. We loaded up all the fixings, and even my kids loved the vibe—it turned into a fun family meal that they completely devoured.

Carol
Reviews 1

I recently tried a dish from Heartbeet Kitchen, and my 16-year-old son declared it one of the best meals he’s ever had. Honestly, I think he might be right. I added some Thousand Island dressing on top, which really tied it together. Thanks for the great food!

Amanda
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen hit the spot for our smash burger craving! We usually find those heavy patties a bit much, but wrapping them in these tortillas was a game-changer. It’s become a new staple in our house. The smaller size was much easier for our 4 and 6-year-olds to handle compared to a giant bun. It’s also great that we can opt for lower-carb versions, making the meal feel a bit lighter and healthier. We’ll definitely be making these from Heartbeet Kitchen on a regular basis.

Meg
Reviews 1

We absolutely love the meatballs from Heartbeet Kitchen! I made enough for two dinners for my husband and me. After the first batch, I decided to invest in a burger press—great timing with Prime Day—and it really improved the texture. I still haven’t quite mastered getting crispy edges, but the flavor was outstanding either way. We topped them with cheese, pickles, onions, tomatoes, and Kinder’s burger sauce. This dish has officially earned a spot in our regular dinner rotation.

kim
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s smash burger tacos are a fantastic and simple choice. I love that they are so easy to make, and it’s great to see a focus on healthier ingredients like using a sauce made from sour cream and Greek yogurt instead of mayo and seed oils.

Rebecca
Reviews 1

I’m chilling the dough in the fridge tonight for Heartbeet Kitchen so I can bake them fresh in the morning. I’m curious if the dough freezes well? It would be great to roll them into balls and stash them in the freezer for those spontaneous moments when I need a quick treat. Can’t wait to try them!

Rachel Clark
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really knows how to deliver quality. I picked up this chocolate chip recipe from their site and ended up learning a ton about the process. The cookies turned out fantastic—definitely my new go-to choice from now on.

Leah Bryson
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s recipes are Instagram-worthy for a reason. We finally got around to firing up the griddle to make them, and the process was surprisingly straightforward. The result was absolutely delicious—my husband and kids, who are usually picky about their burgers, actually preferred these over their usual favorites. That’s high praise from our burger-loving crew!

Rachael
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen nailed it with this sandwich. It’s become a quick go-to for us. I made a batch to share with neighbors, and everyone was impressed by the refreshing mix of creamy cheese, tangy dill pickles, and cool cucumber slices. It really captures the spirit of summer.

Kari
Reviews 1

Amanda from Heartbeet Kitchen really outdid herself with this one. The pesto recipe is incredibly quick to make, and the garlic scape flavor is top-notch. I actually doubled the batch and froze the extra portion in ice cube trays so I can have a taste of summer all year round.

Dan
Reviews 1

Living in a city with limited garden space, I was out of fresh jalapeños for my Heartbeet Kitchen recipe and had to improvise with frozen habaneros from last year’s stash. I thawed four of them, chopped them up, and tossed them in. While they obviously lost that fresh crisp texture, they held up fine since they were going to be cooked anyway. The result? A fantastic spicy kick that really elevated the dish. Pro tip: chop them up and drain them well before adding to avoid excess moisture.

Bea
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s banana muffins are absolutely divine! I decided to bake these spontaneously using very ripe bananas and just 40g each of the sugars from my starter discard. The result was incredibly satisfying, with a fluffy texture and rich flavor.

Rissa
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s sourdough recipe is a consistent winner in my kitchen. I’ve whipped it up multiple times, and it’s always a crowd-pleaser. Now, I’m planning to share it with a friend who avoids sourdough—does anyone know how I might tweak the recipe to omit the discard?

Maritza
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen looks promising! My gas pizza oven has been tricky so far, but I’m hopeful your recipes will help master the learning curve. I currently stock Caputo 00 flour for pizzeria style crusts. Is it safe to substitute that for the all-purpose flour in your recipe?

KS
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen has a fantastic bread recipe that’s become my absolute favorite. I usually adjust the flour blend to suit my preference for less bread flour, but the instructions are incredibly straightforward and user-friendly. Thanks for sharing!

Winnie M.
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen nailed it with this recipe! I baked it for my colleagues, and the bread was still getting compliments two days later. I’m curious if you could use the exact same formula for bagels? Is there a specific technique involved, or would I just need to shape the dough differently? Would love to try it out!

Bettina
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s blueberry muffin mix is absolutely top-tier! I had a bit of trouble because my batter turned out too runny and I wasn’t sure if US buttermilk was thick enough compared to sour cream, but it worked out. Great news for sourdough fans too—the recipe works perfectly with rye starter. Delicious results every time!

Cherri
Reviews 1

I finally gave Heartbeet Kitchen’s recipe a try, with just one small twist, and it came out absolutely delicious! I’ll definitely be making it again and sharing it often. I skipped the jalapenos this time since my can had expired, but I plan to add them next time—I’m sure it’ll be even better. Thanks for another fantastic recipe and those super clear, easy-to-follow tutorials!

Sandra
Reviews 1

I’m really enjoying the granola from Heartbeet Kitchen. I customized my batch by swapping in pecans instead of walnuts and mixing in some chia seeds and unsweetened coconut. The texture came out wonderfully crunchy and the flavor is fantastic. It’s become our go-to topping for homemade yogurt.

Marie-Claude
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed the recipe from Heartbeet Kitchen! It was flavorful and straightforward to prepare. However, I did notice a small issue during baking: instead of rising straight up, my scones spread outwards and ended up looking a bit lopsided. Has anyone else experienced this, and do you have any tips for keeping them more uniform in shape?

Sydney
Reviews 1

I baked these treats today and they turned out delicious! Even though I had to swap out a few ingredients, the result was spot on. I substituted hazelnut flour for almond, used olive oil in place of sunflower, and replaced both brown and white sugars with date sugar. The outcome was still perfect, so I’m definitely making them again once I’ve restocked my pantry with the original ingredients. Thanks for sharing this great recipe with Heartbeet Kitchen!

Jenn
Reviews 1

I absolutely love the jalapeño cheddar loaf from Heartbeet Kitchen! It is incredibly tasty and a breeze to prepare. Amanda’s clear writing style makes her recipes so simple to follow, and I’ve never had a bad experience with them. You really should try baking this bread yourself!

Michelle R
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really nailed it with this one. It’s already become a weekly favorite in my house after I tried it twice in just two weeks. I made a few tweaks—using pecans and pumpkin seeds, plus swapping honey for maple syrup—and the result was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend!

Anna
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen has nailed the sourdough game. I’ve tried countless recipes over the years, but this one keeps me coming back as my go-to. It’s genuinely delicious, which is why I’ve happily gifted it to friends and family who always love it. My son absolutely raves about the jalapeno cheddar sourdough—it might be his favorite meal right now.

Jill
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s granola is truly delicious. I swapped the coconut sugar for brown sugar and used pecans instead of walnuts. Since I’m in Michigan, I added dried cherries in the final ten minutes of baking. My husband declared it the best granola I’ve ever made, and I have to agree. This recipe is definitely a keeper.

Pam S
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s sourdough recipe is a fantastic find, whether you are just starting out or you are an experienced baker. I am relatively new to the world of sourdough and decided to give this one a shot. It has been such a success that I am already on my fourth loaf, and it is a huge hit with my family.

Sandra
Reviews 1

Hands down the best sourdough choco banana muffins I’ve tried! I’ve been searching for a recipe that delivers this exact texture for ages, and this one hits the mark. They’re incredibly moist and fluffy with the perfect level of sweetness, plus they bake up so tall and beautiful. I’ll definitely be making these on repeat. Big thanks to the team at Heartbeet Kitchen! 🙌🥰

taozi
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen has made my sourdough journey so much easier! As someone relatively new to baking, I’m thrilled to say this is hands down the best loaf I’ve produced this year. Even when I had to substitute with all-purpose bread flour instead of whole wheat, the result was still absolutely fantastic. The only real challenge was the anticipation after pulling it out of the oven, but the taste made every second of waiting worth it. Truly a great recipe—thank you!

Rachelle Schwartz
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen really nailed these recipes. I whipped them up for the kids, but honestly, the whole family wiped the plate clean. I made a swap using coconut sugar and maple syrup instead of regular sugar, and the result was absolutely delicious. I’m already planning to make them again soon.

Alejandro Romagosa
Reviews 1

If you are looking for the best sourdough discard granola, look no further than Heartbeet Kitchen. This product has quickly become a weekly staple in our household. The texture is spot on—the discard binder holds everything together perfectly without falling apart. On top of that, the flavor profile is fantastic. We are huge fans and highly recommend giving it a try.

Stephanie
Reviews 1

As a huge fan of mint and chocolate, I was eager to see if Heartbeet Kitchen’s cookies could deliver. They definitely lived up to the promise of being moist and chewy rather than dry or cakey. While the packaging notes that the higher brown sugar content helps them stay fresh for days, these were simply too good to last that long! I’ll definitely be keeping them in my rotation, whether for gluten-free friends or just for myself.

Deborah
Reviews 1

I am loving this bread from Heartbeet Kitchen! It was absolutely delicious and vanished from our table the same day. Honestly, I should have baked two loaves at once because it’s becoming a staple in my kitchen. We enjoyed it toasted, and it was fantastic. Highly recommend!

Megan A
Reviews 1

Heartbeet Kitchen’s sourdough loaf recipe is simply outstanding. After testing numerous variations, I’ve found this to be the definitive guide I recommend to friends and family. It’s a staple in my baking routine now. Thanks for sharing such reliable instructions!

Questions & Answers

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

News & Press

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying widget on your website — its a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Embed code

<script src="https://trustburn.com/widgets/index.js"></script>
<div class="trustburn-widget" data-trustburn-protocol="https:" data-trustburn-domain="trustburn.com" data-trustburn-widget="score" data-company-path="heartbeetkitchen-com" data-lang="en"></div>
More widgets

About Heartbeet Kitchen