Login or sign up
For business

Sidle insurance

4.4· 21 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.4/ 5

Based on 21 reviews

562%
414%
324%
20%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Sidle insurance

Based on 21 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 7 days ago

Customers describe the agency as friendly, knowledgeable, and professional, noting that their rates are affordable and their coverage is comprehensive.
What is Sidle insurance?

Sidle Insurance operates as an independent agency serving the Montour Falls, New York community. The business is part of Marshall+Sterling, a national firm headquartered in New York that has been securing success since 1864. They provide comprehensive services including business insurance, personal insurance, employee health and benefits, and wealth management.

What specific services does Marshall+Sterling offer through this agency?

The agency provides a wide array of choices for cost-competitive programs throughout the insurance industry. They specialize in business insurance, personal insurance for homes and autos, employee health and benefits, and retirement and wealth management. Additionally, they offer specialized automotive services insurance for members of SSDGNY.

How long has this agency been operating in the community?

The business has been serving its community for decades, with its parent company, Marshall+Sterling, having a history dating back to 1864. The firm has built a long-standing reputation for securing success for clients over the years, evolving alongside changing marketplace needs.

What is the current Trustburn rating and review activity?

Sidle Insurance holds a Trustburn rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars from 21 reviews. The feedback includes recent comments from November 2023, alongside older reviews from as far back as 2016, showing sustained engagement over time.

What do multiple reviewers consistently praise about the service?

Reviewers frequently highlight the staff's knowledge, professionalism, and friendly demeanor. Many customers note that the policies are tailored to individual needs and that the customer service is exceptional, often exceeding expectations.

What are the specific pricing details mentioned for equine insurance?

For Full Mortality coverage, rates for typical performance or pleasure horses aged 2-14 generally run from 2.9% to 4% of the insured value. For example, a 10-year-old horse insured at $10,000 could have a premium as low as $290-$300 a year, depending on breed and use.

What specific coverage options are available for horses?

A Full Mortality policy acts as life insurance in the event the horse dies due to a covered illness, injury, accident, or disease. It typically includes some coverage for theft and a free Emergency Colic Surgery endorsement for horses without a colic history, helping reimburse surgery expenses up to a limit determined by the insurance company.

How does the agency determine the current market value for a horse?

For a recently purchased horse, the price paid sets the current market value and is the maximum amount the insurance company will allow. If the horse has been owned for more than 6 months to a year, underwriters consider spending on training and show records to determine a higher insured value.

What specific partnership exists for automotive services insurance?

The Service Station Dealers & Automotive Service of Greater New York (SSDGNY) has partnered with Marshall+Sterling to offer comprehensive insurance coverage plans. These plans are exclusively available to SSDGNY members and help manage risks unique to service station and garage owners.

What is the address and phone number for the Montour Falls office?

The office is located at 219 S Catherine Street, Montour Falls, NY 14865. The local phone number listed for the location is 607-535-6501, while a toll-free number of 800-333-3766 is also provided for broader inquiries.

What are the licensing and operational scope of the parent company?

Marshall+Sterling is licensed in all states and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The firm is regularly recognized among the top 50 of privately held insurance brokers in the United States and operates as a national independent agency.

What specific endorsements are commonly added to horse policies?

About 90% of clients add some type of Medical and/or Surgical Endorsement to their Mortality policy. These endorsements help reimburse for covered veterinary expenses, including various diagnostics and treatments, varying based on the horse's age, breed, use, and insured value.

How do reviewers describe the claims process and overall satisfaction?

Several reviewers mention that the claims process was hassle-free and that the agency provides competitive pricing. Customers who switched providers report being very satisfied with the services and the ability to save money while maintaining comprehensive coverage.

What historical context is given regarding the founding of the agency?

The firm's history traces back to 1864 when Joseph H. Marshall expanded his carriage manufacturing business into selling insurance. In the late 1890s, he formed a partnership with Graham L. Sterling to engage in the business of insurance and real estate.

What specific industries or business types are targeted by the agency?

The agency targets businesses needing property and casualty insurance, as well as those requiring workers' compensation and fleet policies. They also serve individual clients seeking home, auto, RV, life, and health insurance solutions.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Tim O'Hearn | Schuyler County Administrator
Reviews 1

Working with David L. Sidle Agency, Inc. has been a game-changer for our county’s property and casualty needs. They truly act as a partner rather than just another vendor, aligning their efforts with our goal of safeguarding our assets efficiently. Their team conducted a meticulous audit of our existing policies and provided recommendations that significantly boosted our coverage limits without driving up the cost. It is genuinely refreshing to work with an independent agency that takes the time to find the right balance between comprehensive protection and competitive rates.

Connie Fieno | Beauregard's Bakery
Reviews 1

Having dealt with Sidle Insurance Agency for a while, I’ve never felt like just another number. They really embody that classic, personal touch in their service—always polite, helpful, and genuinely ready to do what it takes for their clients. I’d gladly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable coverage.

Debbie R. Thomas - Executive Director | Association of Camps Farthest Out, Inc.
Reviews 1

As the admin office for over 70 Christian retreats across North America, we have diverse insurance requirements. Sidle Insurance, a trusted independent agency with decades of experience, stepped up to cover our office, liability, and medical needs at a fair price. The team’s friendly and quick service makes handling our insurance worries a breeze.

Patricia Frasier - President | George A. Tanner, Inc.
Reviews 1

Sidle Insurance stepped up for my father’s small trucking company when other carriers weren’t willing to take a risk. They did the heavy lifting to secure the right workers’ compensation and fleet policies. We’ve been with them since incorporating as George A Tanner Inc. in 1997, and we still rely on Dave and his team for expert guidance. The entire staff is incredibly welcoming and truly knows their clients by name. It feels like they are part of our extended family—we’ve celebrated school events, 4H activities, and more together. Sidle Insurance is a genuine pillar of our local community.

Missy Rittenhouse - President | Philip James Inc.
Reviews 1

Having partnered with David L. Sidle Agency for a few years now, I’ve been consistently struck by their dedication to client care. Whether we communicate face-to-face, by phone, or when they’re actively resolving an issue for me, the service is always top-notch. Dave and his team do a great job of proactively presenting clear, cost-effective insurance options that make total sense for my business.

Dorothy Elizabeth | Fitzsimmons Law Firm
Reviews 1

Clients of Fitzsimmons Law Firm often ask us where to go for reliable coverage, and we consistently point them to David L. Sidle Agency. We’ve built our trust in them over years of seeing how they handle both our firm’s and personal home policies with genuine care. It’s comforting to know that when we send a referral their way, the clients are in the capable hands of the Sidle family. Their deep, generational experience shines through in the personalized attention they give to every client, making them the obvious choice for anyone looking for solid insurance solutions.

James P. Coleman, J.D. | Attorney at Law
Reviews 1

Having worked closely with David L. Sidle Agency, Inc. through my practice in Schuyler County, I have seen firsthand how Dave and his father have consistently supported both public and private clients over the years. What truly sets this independent agency apart is their rapid responsiveness and deep expertise. They have repeatedly gone above and beyond to ensure their clients are properly covered, proving they are a reliable partner who genuinely understands their community’s needs.

Kelsey Jones - Executive Director | SCOPED
Reviews 1

David L. Sidle Agency has been a reliable partner for our business for years. They initially won our trust by delivering better coverage at a lower cost, and they’ve maintained that high standard ever since. Their team handles every project with professionalism and a friendly attitude, making it easy to rely on their expertise whenever we need support.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Sidle insurance

Sidle Insurance is an independent insurance agency that has been serving it's community for decades. Learn how we can serve you.

Sidle Insurance: Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency

Sidle Insurance is a well-established independent insurance agency that has been serving its community for decades. The company prides itself on providing personalized and comprehensive insurance solutions to individuals, families, and businesses in the area.

As an independent agency, Sidle Insurance works with multiple insurance carriers to offer a wide range of coverage options at competitive rates. This means that clients can choose from various policies and customize their coverage according to their unique needs and budget.

The company's team of experienced agents is committed to helping clients navigate the complex world of insurance. They take the time to understand each client's situation, assess their risks, and recommend appropriate coverage options. Whether it's auto, home, life, health or business insurance - Sidle Insurance has got you covered.

Auto Insurance

Driving without proper auto insurance can be risky and costly. That's why Sidle Insurance offers comprehensive auto insurance policies that protect drivers against accidents, thefts or damages caused by natural disasters. The company also provides liability coverage that pays for damages or injuries caused by the driver to others on the road.

Homeowners' Insurance

Owning a home is one of life's biggest investments - but it comes with its own set of risks. Sidle Insurance offers homeowners' insurance policies that protect homes against damage from fire, thefts or natural disasters like floods or earthquakes. The company also provides liability coverage that protects homeowners against lawsuits filed by visitors who get injured on their property.

Life & Health Insurance

Life is unpredictable - but having proper life & health insurance can provide peace of mind for you and your loved ones in case something unexpected happens. Sidle Insurance offers various life & health policies such as term life insurance which provides financial protection for a specific period; whole life which covers policyholders throughout their lifetime; disability income which replaces lost income due to illness or injury; long-term care which covers expenses related to nursing homes or assisted living facilities.

Business Insurance

Running a business comes with its own set of risks - but having proper business insurance can protect your company against financial losses. Sidle Insurance offers various business insurance policies such as general liability which covers damages caused by the company to others; property insurance which protects the company's assets against damage or theft; workers' compensation which provides benefits to employees who get injured on the job.

Why Choose Sidle Insurance?

Sidle Insurance is more than just an insurance agency - it's a trusted partner that puts clients' needs first. The company's commitment to providing personalized and comprehensive coverage options has earned them a reputation for excellence in the industry. Here are some reasons why you should choose Sidle Insurance:

- Experienced agents who understand your unique needs

- Multiple carriers and coverage options to choose from

- Competitive rates that fit your budget

- Personalized service that goes beyond just selling policies

- Convenient online tools and resources for managing your policy

Conclusion

In conclusion, Sidle Insurance is an independent insurance agency that has been serving its community for decades. The company offers comprehensive coverage options for auto, home, life & health, and business insurance at competitive rates. With experienced agents who understand clients' unique needs and multiple carriers to choose from - Sidle Insurance is a trusted partner in protecting what matters most. Contact them today to learn how they can serve you!

Address
219 south catherine street
Categories
Insurance