Login or sign up
For business

SF Eagle Tavern

4.5· 134 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.5/ 5

Based on 134 reviews

568%
423%
34%
22%
13%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about SF Eagle Tavern

Based on 134 reviews on Trustburn · updated 38 days ago

Customers generally describe SF Eagle Tavern in positive terms, citing fun events, great people and drinks, and a welcoming patio, though a smaller share of reviewers found it underwhelming or were unhappy with specific policies and staff.
What are the most common complaints about SF Eagle Tavern?

The critical reviewers most often describe a disappointing or underwhelming experience, with complaints about the cover charge, cash-only policy, poor management, and a lack of atmosphere on weekday nights.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Alexis Debord
Reviews 1

Definitely not what I expected, but it could ve been the night. NYC - Eagle is usually popping on a Thursday night and I thought the same would apply. This was nowhere near it [and other Eagles (nationwide) I ve had the pleasure of visiting]. Hopefully, I ll be able to return and experience its true potential. I know you could do better.

S. Todd Colletti
Reviews 1

A great South of Market bar and generally a staple gathering spot for the local Leather community. The SF Eagle has been host to a number of up and coming bands, especially for Thursday Night Live.

Beer Bust on Sunday is also a treat, as long as you like beer and/or good conversation with people you ve known for awhile, and sometimes, those you ve just met.

Leona Larson
Reviews 1

To begin this place says they open at 12 but I went once and they don't...it was closed and a person that was standing outside that frequented the place said they actually open at 6 idk if that has changed...If so, this yelp time is wrong. Second, prepare to be standing the entire time. This place is super tiny and super crowded it's hard to even move in there. The food is pretty amazing and there is no cover charge to go in. The micheladas are bomb. They seem pricey at $12 but they're huge and come with a couple pieces of shrimp, cucumber, celery and a tamarindo stick which you can use as your straw. Delicious. They only have valet parking, which is complimentary but still tip the poor guys...they're running around like crazy! I gave it three stars because they don't have enough sitting room and their parking sucks if you don't valet...they do have awesome food and drinks though.

Roman Maximilian
Reviews 1

A event that I have gone to for years in San Francisco moved "recently" to the SF eagle. If you are there on a good night, the bartenders and the patrons are solid. More than a few times we get a aggressive bar back that's trying to dictate how the bar is operated, which ruins the vibe a little bit. I do not advise parking within the block or two of the eagle, I've been broken into twice. It's not the best area. The street outside is currently going underneath intense construction, as soon as that's done, I'm sure the area will be even better. they do not like doing tabs or taking card during large events, be prepared to have cash on hand. They do have an ATM, but you know they all have horrible fees. If you are there not during a event, they probably will be able to take your card no problem. something I wish they would change, cuz I would buy a lot more drinks if I didn't have to have cash on hand. Enjoy yourself, have fun, be silly.

Jesse Mendez
Reviews 1

My personal favorite smoking patio. Forget that Z bar. Easy going old school leather/bear/daddy hangout, this iconic bar has featured live music and a mixed crowd for most of its existence. Now refurbished and jazzed up, it's a great spot for a quiet drink if you show up early.

Steven Chu
Reviews 1

Easy going, no attitude or frills. If you're musically inclined (and don't want to listen to bad top 40/hiphop), this Eagle has a really great selection of DJs playing!

Loved the inside area, the outside covered dance patio, and the open outdoor space.

Also loved the number of men that come in full gear! I'm from NYC and I think my experience here won out! Great job!

Danielle Waters
Reviews 1

This place is chill as hell, the happy hour is AMAZING as in lots and lots of options, and they have TouchTunes juxebox so yeah SOLD, take my money!!!! Also, the bartender with dyed hair and alternative style was nice and on it, despite him probably hating our music choices haha! There are no windows so it's dark as hell but I mean...kinda like it! They have loads of seating and spots for your drinks on pillars even when standing. Good spot, in fact don't come here I wanna keep it for myself! Hollywood gem!

Kewl Froeinweizer
Reviews 1

I like going to this place because everyone is welcomed. However I'm still getting used to the presence of security... this is literally the first Eagle I've been too which had outside security. It weirds me out sometimes, which is kinda an oxymoron the more I think about

Stephen Kling
Reviews 1

The SF Eagle doesn t have a little, it has a LOT of something for EVERYONE! Whether it s hanging with the leather community, meeting a new pup , dancing to disco on a Sunday after its famous beer bust of course, karaoke Wednesdays, the make out party, so many events happen at the SF eagle that their truly is something for everyone. Everyone is welcome and everyone is respectful. Make sure you are too! Love this place, they treat you like family! Pictures taken by myself.

Ferman Smith
Reviews 1

This was a really disappointing experience. I had never been to SFO before and had a pretty short layover. I decided seeing this eagle would be a great way to spend it.

First off, there's a cover. The only eagle in this world that has a cover. London didn't even have one. I can understand having one if there's entertainment or a show but there wasn't. I arrived just past midnight. I had to hit the ATM for a $20 to pay it.

Once I went up to the bar and ordered my drinks, I was informed they were cash only instead of just telling me at the door or even having a notice posted of it. I had to hit the ATM again.

I went to the patio, and there were a wide variety of people. It was an interesting crowd but felt too many stares that caught me off guard, I don't think they were admiring. Not much leather being worn that evening.

Come 1:25 I went to take a leak, when I tried to go back out to talk to some guys I met I was refused entry back to the patio by security because it was "closing." Which was probably the most infuriating thing of the evening. They were kicking everyone inside.

I'm glad I paid a $10 cover for no show or entertainment, overpriced drinks, Fireball that didn't quite taste like Fireball, and to be kept from enjoying the whole bar.

What a bummer.

Lizardo McFly
Reviews 1

I love attending events here! The staff are all really cordial, the courtyard is HUGE and we'll-decorated, the drinks are strong, and they always have something fun going on.

I only knocked off a star because they have ONE bathroom with ONE toilet, which becomes problematic during a show or on a crowded night. I have had to go take care of business al fresco because the line to he commode was insanely long. Not cute.

Jim Jowdy
Reviews 1

This bar is a bit of a throwback to earlier times in SF, but with a few updates and a decent beer selection, all of which help make it a real gem. They always seem to play great rock or indie music, always at the right volume for me, and the outside patio has to be the best in the city (note: outside on the patio smoking is allowed, including cigars, but there's plenty of space that it's unlikely to bother you as it might at some smaller Castro area bar patios). The bartenders have always been really friendly and happy to talk which makes me even happier to support this place.

(It is a little bit leathery, with some Tom of Finland art around the place, so be forewarned, but it's a very welcoming space.)

Luis Hernandez
Reviews 1

A must see in the nightlife of San Francisco. If it is your first time, go with an open mind and with the idea that you will see things that you do not see in other places, especially if you visit from other countries. It has a DJ on the terrace and pop music inside. They do "show" sado from time to time. The day I went I got a $ 15 cover although I don't know if that's always the case.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About SF Eagle Tavern

Address
12th Street 398
Categories
Restaurants