Five Star Fish

4.6 · 368 reviews
starfishcompany.com Write a review
M
M. K.
Reviews 1
2020-10-27 12:05

Life's good on the dock, with off-the-boat fresh s...

Life's good on the dock, with off-the-boat fresh seafood. Most outstanding scallops, shrimp and hush puppies. This is the stuff dreams are made of between summer vacations.
***CASH ONLY*** is the only minor, minor drawback, but of absolutely no importance once you've eaten here. Come hungry! This ...

Read full review

A
Adrian Harris
Reviews 1
2020-10-26 21:22

Rude staff. The cashier was rude to myself and my...

Rude staff. The cashier was rude to myself and my guest. No were on Starfish s website does it say cash only! Usually when I go to the beach I don t carry a lot of cash. I was directed to Cortez market. The cashier expected me to know where it was. I live about 55 minutes away. I found th...

Read full review

C
Christine McKelvey
Reviews 1
2020-10-21 13:06

Don't go if you're in a rush... or particularly hu...

Don't go if you're in a rush... or particularly hungry. We should have realized after reading all the kitschy signs that say "you're on Cortez time" and "what's your hurry" that we were in for it. The kitchen is *impossibly* slow. Honestly, I could have gone back there and made the meals faster. We...

Read full review

D
David Lint
Reviews 1
2020-10-20 09:58

I ate here twice while in Longboat. First time was...

I ate here twice while in Longboat. First time was takeout: grilled grouper sandwiches, conch fritters, and calamari. The conch was okay, but the calamari and the grouper rocked.

Our second visit we came for lunch. Right on the water, shade and sunlight, bumping atmosphere with a good mix of old ...

Read full review

S
Stuart Smith
Reviews 1
2020-10-18 00:31

I visited in April 2018.

I visited in April 2018.
Nice location, although parking can be a little difficult at busy times. Watch out for the large lorries which also take a lot of space for the various fish factories next door.

Food (fish) is fairly fresh of course and mostly fried but as you can see from the many photo...

Read full review

T
Tim Zavitz
Reviews 1
2020-10-17 23:31

Fancy? No. Authentic, fresh, delicious seafood s...

Fancy? No. Authentic, fresh, delicious seafood served right on the warf. Not expensive. Depending on your timing you may have to wait awhile... there are lots of customers - locals and tourists because it's such a great, iconic spot! Boats and ocean smells -- for sure. Pelicans and egrets and...

Read full review

J
Julian Grumley
Reviews 1
2020-10-13 10:18

We've been coming to Star Fish for years, but not ...

We've been coming to Star Fish for years, but not on a consistent basis, it's been a bit hit and miss. After supper today I'm wondering why? This is, hands down, the best place to experience the freshest fish, deliciously crunchy hush puppies, your grandma's cheesy grits and super friendly bar staff...

Read full review

S
Stephanie Niczypor
Reviews 1
2020-09-27 09:47

Cozy, quaint and very welcoming.

Cozy, quaint and very welcoming.
The food is absolutely fantastic. The freshest you can get . Their price point is spot on and the serving size portions are very generous . I will always visit while in town.

Read full review

B
Bill Donahue
Reviews 1
2020-09-24 10:02

The food was outstanding at Star Fish Co. The seaf...

The food was outstanding at Star Fish Co. The seafood was the best we've had in a very long time. The weather was great while we ate outside at a picnic table. The staff we dealt with were friendly. The only problem we encountered was customers not being prepared to order when it was their turn. Thi...

Read full review

J
James Halay
Reviews 1
2020-09-24 03:35

We had oyster po boy, fried calamara and smoked mu...

We had oyster po boy, fried calamara and smoked mullet dinner, pefect in every way. Good selection of beer and situated amongst real mullet boats. This is the real thing. Long waits? Yes sometime but worth it. Outside with flies? Yes but authentic and they don't eat much.

Read full review

R
Ro
Reviews 1
2020-09-23 07:29

Outdoor seating on the dock where fishing & shrimp...

Outdoor seating on the dock where fishing & shrimp boats are moored. Food is fresh, delicious and plentiful. Very low key with dining selections served in a box with plastic utensils. Hubby ordered crab cake with fried shrimp and he enjoyed every morsel. Served with hushpuppies, slaw and either frie...

Read full review

J
justin williams
Reviews 1
2020-09-19 02:53

Waiting 2 hours after ordering was not a selling p...

Waiting 2 hours after ordering was not a selling point for me. Nor was the sign that let me know my new wait time after standing in line 45 minutes to order.

Let's start with some pros: the food overall tasted great. You get a seaside view. You get live Pelicans. You even occasionally get a wiff...

Read full review

G
Gordon Heimann
Reviews 1
2020-09-19 01:14

Somebody told us that they have the best Grouper a...

Somebody told us that they have the best Grouper around. And what can I say: They were right. Excellent taste in a special athmosphere. But expect a long waiting time, because many other people like the place too and you are on "Cortez Time" here.

Read full review

M
Mike Wright
Reviews 1
2020-09-09 21:09

When typing address into Garmin GPS, must use Brad...

When typing address into Garmin GPS, must use Bradenton as the city. Depending on when you go here, you may have to wait a while for your food. People are friendly, food is very good, very colorful place with great scenery of the bay. Much of the artwork & painting is done by local artist Rhonda K. ...

Read full review

U
UBetcha
Reviews 1
2020-09-01 10:15

Quaint local and tourist spot, a bit hidden within...

Quaint local and tourist spot, a bit hidden within Cortez section of our Paradise. Once you find it you've gotten a step closer to Heaven. Everything on the menu is FRESH made to order. The view is Cortez Bay at it's best, plenty of only outdoor dock side seating, pet friendly and ICE COLD beer! Wha...

Read full review

S
Stephen M
Reviews 1
2020-08-26 10:16

What an amazing place to have dinner. This is how...

What an amazing place to have dinner. This is how i remember Florida in the 60's and 70's. Fresh seafood, no frills. You will not be disappointed! I had the shrimp and it was fantastic. The hush puppies and cole slaw were also very good. Do not change a thing. I wanted to do a Corona commerci...

Read full review

T
Tia Davis
Reviews 1
2020-08-26 05:39

Loved the fresh grilled grouper! Highly recommend...

Loved the fresh grilled grouper! Highly recommend it. The staff was friendly and service was good. Love the simplicity of old Cortez Florida! A side note ....We came by boat, there is limited docking and bring CASH no cards accepted.

Read full review

S
Susan Pease
Reviews 1
2020-08-24 17:41

The fried grouper was AMAZINGLY FRESH! Hands down...

The fried grouper was AMAZINGLY FRESH! Hands down, some of the best I have had. Tasted just off the boat. I also was amazed at their coleslaw. Delicious!!! I loved it and wish I would have gotten the dinner portions instead. Will definitely be back.

Read full review

H
Hector Rodriguez
Reviews 1
2020-08-22 08:01

No better place for local seafood and the best Sto...

No better place for local seafood and the best Stonecrab claws, east of the Mississippi. If you are ever in Sarasota or Cortez, there's no reason why you shouldn't be stopping here for lunch or dinner. Fair warning: it is a slower dining experience, so please plan accordingly. It is truly worth the ...

Read full review

M
Melissa Jenkins MJ Hilligoss
Reviews 1
2020-08-21 20:22

Almost hate posting a review because I want to kee...

Almost hate posting a review because I want to keep this our hidden gem one of our absolute favorite places for seafood. Don't come in a hurry it is island time and relaxation. Bring cash...no plastic allowed.
The scallops and mullet are simply the best dishes, so fresh!

Read full review

K
Kimry Gardner
Reviews 1
2020-08-11 16:13

What could have been a very enjoyable visit was sp...

What could have been a very enjoyable visit was spoiled by too many dogs. While looking at the menu, enjoying a drink, at the outdoor bar, enjoying a beautiful day on the bay, we first witnessed a dog urinate on the floor under a table in the dining area. The owner was aware but watched as it just s...

Read full review

C
Christian Jones
Reviews 1
2020-08-10 14:04

This place is a rare gem. Freshest seafood we had...

This place is a rare gem. Freshest seafood we had during our entire trip and the prices are very reasonable. Nice selection of beers (local and regular) and other drinks. Outdoor seating right on the water, but there's a limited number of tables so you'll want to come early. You should be aware ...

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn
AMP version. View on Trustburn