Login or sign up
For business

Casey's Hallmark

4.3· 10 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.3/ 5

Based on 10 reviews

580%
40%
30%
210%
110%
Ask AI

Questions about Casey's Hallmark

Based on 10 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 3 days ago

What is Casey's Hallmark?

Casey's Hallmark is a privately owned business that has been a go-to place for over 20 years for greeting cards, gifts, and gift cards. It is known for carrying hard-to-find items like Sweetest Day cards and cards in different languages, as well as collectables such as Studio 56 ornaments and recordable books. The store serves customers who need assistance finding unusual event cards or unique holiday selections.

What are some specific pricing details and product examples mentioned by customers?

The store is privately owned, which reviewers note is a reason to support the business. It offers a wide variety of items including Signature Paper Wonder cards that cost $12.99 each, and outdoor sales are occasionally held. Customers appreciate the reasonable pricing and the ability to find one-stop shopping for gifts and cards.

How long has the business existed and what does its history suggest?

The business has been operating for over 20 years, making it a long-standing local option. It is located in an area where customers have found it to be a reliable spot for holiday shopping and special occasions. The store's history includes a reputation for having the best selection of cards and accessories.

What is the current rating and how recent are the reviews?

The Trustburn rating is 4.3 out of 5 based on 10 reviews, with the most recent review dated 2020-09-28. The rating split shows a majority of 5-star reviews, though there are outliers like a 1-star and a 2-star review. The reviews range from early 2020 to late 2020.

What specific products or services are highlighted in the reviews?

The store features specific products like recordable Hallmark books where grandchildren enjoyed hearing Grandma's voice reading to them. It also offers Sweetest Day cards and Signature Paper Wonder cards as distinct product lines. These items are part of the unique gifts available especially during the holidays.

What common doubts might a visitor have before choosing this store?

A common doubt visitors might have is whether the selection is large enough for unusual events, but the store states they will help search for it or find something that works. Another concern is the price of premium items like the $12.99 Signature Paper Wonder cards, which some find expensive for a single card.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Gail Brown
Reviews 1

Our go to place for over 20 years for cards and gifts. Always a good selection of both, or a gift card. If you need an unusual event card they will help you search for it or find something that will work. I love the Hallmark ornaments!!! and have purchased them for myself, my children, and my 9 grandchildren. They have a nice selection of Studio 56, along with many other collectables. My grandchildren enjoyed the recordable Hallmark books, having Grandma's voice reading to them. I love this place and miss it since moving out of state!

Linda Bella
Reviews 1

I found Casey's Hallmark several months ago and fell in love with their selection.I had always shopped Plunkett's which is also good.Being the holidays I made several trips to Casey's and spent up words of $300.I was very pleased.One of the items I purchased was 4 Signature Paper Wonder cards to send to my son as decoration in his room.I sent 1 card a week.I went to send the last card today and it only had an envelope in it.It is a $12.99 card.Not a cheap item.And now I don't have the finale for my son.I called the store to try to get a new one.I was told without a receipt they would not do anything.I could show a cc bill with totals but I don't have a receipt from several weeks ago.I explained that I spent a large amount of money there recently, we couldn't just get a new card.The sales person said I could talk to the manager.She spoke to the manager without covering the phone.Her explanation to the manager was very condescending and rude.I hung up.I have shopped at Plunketts for about 15 years.Have had a few items to return and not always with a receipt.They have never treated a customer like Casey's did.

Todd Fedoruk
Reviews 1

As a Gold Crown store, Casey s carries hard-to-find cards for the less well known holidays and special occasions. Sweetest Day cards for example, can never be found in grocery stores. I also enjoy sending birthday cards to friends and family, written in different languages. These too can be found at Casey s shop.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Casey's Hallmark

No details yet.