Caffe Milano

4.4 · 792 reviews
caffemilano.com Write a review
K
Kristyn Braley
Reviews 1
2020-12-27 11:22

Is everyone working at this restaurant Italian?! I...

Is everyone working at this restaurant Italian?! It really sets the tone for a fabulous experience. My boyfriend and I were visiting from Michigan and didn't make reservations on Friday night. We waited 10 minutes at the bar before being seated outside. All of the food was amazing, from the olives a...

Read full review

A
Antonio Mainolfi
Reviews 1
2020-12-19 09:55

I can safely say that it is one of the best Italia...

I can safely say that it is one of the best Italian restaurants you can find in the city, run entirely by Italians like half the staff who work there, both in the kitchen and in the dining room.
The menu is full of characteristic Italian dishes, from snacks and appetizers to desserts and all with a...

Read full review

A
Aishe Pacuku
Reviews 1
2020-12-13 23:30

Food was average, not something crazy to brag abou...

Food was average, not something crazy to brag about on 5th ave. The two hostess girls were really immature. We sat down to eat outside & all we heard was their conversation about them getting their cramps And it being that time of the month. Waiter was a nice young girl but she didn t know the men...

Read full review

D
Derek W
Reviews 1
2020-12-13 11:09

This place always has such great food and always s...

This place always has such great food and always seems to be busy. Our server outside though was taking quite a while to get us anything and I think two other people had to get us our drinks because she was so in the weeds. We ended up having to take everything to go so we could see the sunset, but ...

Read full review

P
Pauli Pendleton
Reviews 1
2020-12-12 18:37

Early specials a great buy. My steak and brussel s...

Early specials a great buy. My steak and brussel sprouts were perfect. Pasta was overcooked and sauce tasted like Chef Boyardee - little flavor - though chicken parm serving generous and chicken quite good. The cannolis were excellent.

Read full review

A
Ally
Reviews 1
2020-12-08 05:27

We have been here several times before and the foo...

We have been here several times before and the food has been good. Yesterday however was not a good experience, staff were not friendly and a bit grumpy, and they had difficulty understanding due to a language barrier and rhe staff had limited english.and had to ask 3 times for our drinks and then ...

Read full review

G
George Andreozzi
Reviews 1
2020-12-05 15:00

Great food, Great service. Go for dinner early 4-6...

Great food, Great service. Go for dinner early 4-6 Dinner and drinks are half price. The dishes taste like my Italian Grandmother's cooking. Caffe Milano has authentic Italian food. You can't go wrong eating here.I know I'm an Italian from Brooklyn.

Read full review

M
Mitchell Myers
Reviews 1
2020-12-05 11:09

Loved this place, the food was amazing and the wai...

Loved this place, the food was amazing and the wait staff were amazing and understanding of our small children!
The dress is nice but casual. The atmosphere is modern rustic Italian, very updated space.
Happy Hour is half off the food and drink drink menu!!!!

Read full review

T
Ted K.
Reviews 1
2020-12-01 14:33

Was there for our anniversary May 18. we both had ...

Was there for our anniversary May 18. we both had the risotto funghi and it was fantastic. Until I found a hair in it and yes it was someone else s hair not mine. I don t have black short hair and neither does my wife. If there s anything that turns me off its a foreign object in my food. I let my w...

Read full review

J
Jacqueline Rothe
Reviews 1
2020-11-28 22:37

Very disappointed and will not be back. Last nigh...

Very disappointed and will not be back. Last night went there for happy hour dinner. The service was average at best. It took 10 minutes for anyone to approach the table. Bread was brought to the table but no oil or butter. We asked twice for butter before we received it. "Calamari and shrimp...

Read full review

M
Magan Farmer
Reviews 1
2020-11-28 14:28

Food was served warm and was very fragrant. We had...

Food was served warm and was very fragrant. We had the grilled octopus and roasted chicken. Also, the wine was delicious and a good price. We did not love the size of our table though. We barely had room for our plates, but all in all it was a wonderful dining experience.

Read full review

E
Elise Sherron
Reviews 1
2020-11-26 00:31

This place really surprised me. I often find that ...

This place really surprised me. I often find that the restaurants on 5th ave are overpriced for the quality of the food, but Caffe Milano was really worth every penny. As vegetarians, our go-tos were the cheese board, gnocchi, truffle goat cheese pizza, and tiramisu. All very delicious.Another plus,...

Read full review

M
Meej Xyooj
Reviews 1
2020-11-23 09:21

Greetings from MN! My wife and I took a mini getaw...

Greetings from MN! My wife and I took a mini getaway to Naples and I can t tell you how much we enjoyed this place. The food is great, the cocktails are excellent, and the service is beyond perfect. My wife asked for a bandaid and because they ran out, the manager took the liberty and went to a near...

Read full review

B
Barbara Sabran
Reviews 1
2020-11-22 04:43

We ordered our Mother's Day dinner take out style,...

We ordered our Mother's Day dinner take out style, and even though it was our first time ordering food at this restaurant, we spent over $200, and the seafood was inedible because of being overcooked. The lamb and veal were also overcooked, and both risotto dishes tasted like mush. The calamari was ...

Read full review

P
Patrick-Julian Q. Fulgado
Reviews 1
2020-11-22 02:33

Went here for the high ratings and it lived up to ...

Went here for the high ratings and it lived up to it. Very nice place with very good service. Had a lunch special, Croque Monsieur. I always describe it as a fancy ham and cheese sandwich, which it is, but it's always worth it. It was a pretty good deal coming with a decent size shoestring french fr...

Read full review

J
jessie johnson
Reviews 1
2020-11-19 16:41

The food was beyond delicious the atmosphere was g...

The food was beyond delicious the atmosphere was great even the coffee was good I would give this place 10 s Matt was our server and he did an amazing job especially singing our daughter happy bday if is your birthday you want to come here they play the birthday song over the speaker and everyone ...

Read full review

S
Suzanne Calia
Reviews 1
2020-11-18 10:38

We went to this restaurant twice. First time we s...

We went to this restaurant twice. First time we sat at the bar and ate dinner. Bartenders were pleasant and accommodating. Food was good but not great. Sauces lacked any personality. Our 2nd visit was on a weekday after the Easter crowds had thinned. We ate indoors and got the bums rush from a...

Read full review

A
alphagamer047
Reviews 1
2020-11-15 22:24

Stayed here 2 weeks ago and to be honest, I've bee...

Stayed here 2 weeks ago and to be honest, I've been to so many italian restaurants over the years but this one really is in my Top 3.
The appetizer were amazing and so was the Skizza (!) absolutely delicious with thin crust, really worth a visit and great service as well!

Read full review

V
Valeria K
Reviews 1
2020-11-08 17:16

Totally money driven place with no regard to clien...

Totally money driven place with no regard to client needs. We made a reservation for outside. We were sitted but once we told that we came in for deserts and cofe we were told we have to go inside and sit at the bar as outside area is for diners only. The fact that we had an elderly person with us a...

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn
AMP version. View on Trustburn