Login or sign up
For business

Atherton Hotel

4.6· 76 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.6/ 5

Based on 76 reviews

578%
414%
35%
20%
13%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Atherton Hotel

Based on 76 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 3 days ago

Customers frequently describe Atherton Hotel as clean and well-run with friendly staff and renovated, upgraded rooms, often praising the front desk service, though a few note small rooms and higher costs.
What is Atherton Hotel?

The Atherton Hotel is a hotel located on the campus of Oklahoma State University in Stillwater, offering rooms, dining, and services to guests visiting the university or the area.

What do reviewers praise about the rooms and design?

Some reviewers say the hotel has undergone an outstanding renovation with beautiful decor, soothing colors, and charming guest rooms that are pleasing to the senses.

What dining options are available at the hotel?

The hotel operates a restaurant called the Ranchers Club, where some reviewers mention the steaks are gorgeous and the appetizer menu is very appealing.

What services and staff qualities are highlighted by guests?

Some reviewers note that the hotel provides valet service and that the staff is super friendly and accommodating to guests.

What are some common complaints from guests?

Some reviewers complain that the rooms are extremely small compared to those in other cities, and the parking situation is described as having insufficient space for students and visitors.

How recent and how many reviews are there, and what is the rating?

The hotel's rating is 4.6 out of 5 based on 76 reviews, with the most recent feedback dating back to October 2020.

Where is the hotel located and who is it for?

Some reviewers mention that the hotel is located right on the campus of Oklahoma State University, making it convenient for students and alumni.

What food and beverage features are mentioned by guests?

Some reviewers say the hotel offers a breakfast buffet and a lounge with great food and drinks that is always lively.

What structural features or limitations are noted by guests?

Some reviewers point out that the hotel does not have a stairway, requiring guests to use a slow elevator to reach their rooms.

What specific pricing details are mentioned in the reviews?

Some reviewers mention that the hotel charges for parking, with one guest noting the cost is $15 overnight.

What overall atmosphere and style do guests describe?

Some reviewers say the hotel is picturesque and wonderful, with a classic but elegant look to the rooms.

What specific room features or tips are shared by guests?

Some reviewers mention that the hotel has bright lights in the room that can disturb sleep, advising guests to cover them.

What general impressions do guests express about the hotel?

Some reviewers say the hotel is a very pleasant surprise on the OSU campus with fantastic rooms, great food, and amazing staff.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Kelley Cooper- Cameron
Reviews 1

The Atherton Hotel is a beautiful hotel with lovely decor. Soothing colors through out the hotel are pleasing to the senses. The guestroom are charming. Enjoy a drink at the bar. The space is inviting and the appetizer menu is very appealing. Dinner at the Ranchers Club was delicious. The steaks are gorgeous! The room is decorated with great paintings of area ranches. The overall experience is worth a visit.

Nick Hayden
Reviews 1

The staff is always friendly and accommodating. I would sacrifice the extra money and stay here on campus. The lounge has great food, drinks and is always lively. I have been coming here every month for the past year and have had ZERO issues, literally I can t think of one bad thing. I would suggest booking way in advance so you can get a room. They will book up fast. I always brag about the service, keep up the great work.

Curt Herron
Reviews 1

Go Pokes.... My son has now followed his momma's footsteps and entered into the Honors College at OSU. When I was there a hundred years ago (or so it seems) my big thing was one day I'd return to OSU with a kid attending there and I'd stay at the OSU Atherton Hotel. Seems like a silly bucket list kinda thing, but there you go.

So Josh Bernard and his staff were facing a big challenge, making this as memorable today and I dreamed it would be 30 yrs ago. They succeeded with flying colors, beyond my expectations. They bent over backwards to make my stay as amazing as I had ever dreamed, and the little touches you never know about until your a guest just took it over the top (I'd tell but why ruin the fun of the surprises ahead once you enter your room at the Atherton).

The breakfast is included as a buffet and it hits all the 'wants' plus you are dining in the coziest most lux dining room that makes you feel like you are as special as the Atherton staff makes you feel. Now I am hooked, and my son will be there for every bit of 4 yrs - gonna have to dig deep into my retirement fund but staying at the Atherton is so worth it.

Lastly, logistically it can't be beat. Its attached to the student union, the one rated the best in the country I might add - you are steps away from the renown Theta Pond and Student Union gardens. Across the garage you are on fraternity row, with streets that lead to lots of fun places to eat and visit, including Hideaway Pizza (a must), and around the corner is the famous Eskimo Joes. Why stay anywhere else.

Only downfall, and its rather a big deal to some - parking is an additional expense. My old college gal pal came to visit me and threw a heck of a fit (embarrassing...) but it is what it is, so don't be shocked. They do offer valet parking too though.

Jason Murdock
Reviews 1

It was clean and staff was friendly...but that s about where the pluses end.

The rooms are extremely small. I ve literally stayed in rooms in downtown San Francisco, Paris, and Zurich that were huge in comparison to the rooms here.

Second, the parking stinks. It s $15 overnight and if you end up going anywhere, you can count on spending more than that.

Three...too much orange. I get that it s an OSU hotel, but it s overkill.

Kody Chappell
Reviews 1

We stayed at the Atherton for a wedding that was on campus. It is a nice hotel, with very pleasant staff. For visiting OSU it is a great hotel. However, as a hotel in general, the rooms are a little small and the bed is not the most comfortable. Overall we had a very pleasant stay

HackPorpoise
Reviews 1

They went very cheap on the rooms.The toilet paper was very thin and cheap, the toilet seats are cheap plastic they doesn t stay in one place
The shower heads are so weak you have to stand by the wall to even get water that is not even very hot.the pillows were uncomfortable and the sheets were thin.The elevator was very slow and it would randomly stop on floors so it takes 5 minutes just to get from the first to fourth floor.Also you could hear traffic at night so if you want to be cozy and relaxed,choose the backside of the hotel.

Aaron Malin
Reviews 1

The Atherton Hotel is Stillwater's premium service hotel experience. The location is ideal for anything OSU and the staff is primarily students learning to be the best in hospitality service providers. The remodel was completed a few years ago and it feels as fresh and stately as if it was it was new. On site there is covered parking, dining choices ranging from Chick-fil-A to The Rancher's Club steakhouse and the beautiful gardens for an evening stroll.

Isabel Alvarez-Sancho
Reviews 1

The rooms are very small and clean enough, but not very. My main complaint is that people walk around without masks and nobody says anything at all. This is inside OSU, where there's a mask mandate, signs everywhere, etc. This is inside a city where there's a mask mandate. However, the Atherton doesn't follow rules. They might have a small sign on the door, but that's it. Nothing reminding of elevator protocols, nobody reminding guests to wear masks. If you want to use the stairs, because people use the elevator without masks, they have to unlock them for you and they are outside the building. When I pointed out that people were not wearing masks all around, they told me that everybody follows the rules. That is, they blatantly denied the evidence that was before my eyes and did nothing.

ICU beds are scarce in Oklahoma at this moment. OSU is making a huge effort to keep open and keep students, faculty and staff safe. However, the Atherton gets a pass. Please, you need to follow safety regulations more closely. This is a public health issue.

As of now, I would not recommend this hotel to anyone who wants to feel safe.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Atherton Hotel

No details yet.