Rolling Stonebaker Reviews

Great little place awesome servers and incredible great pizza. Ive had the Purple Pig and the Cubano..cant wait to go back. Hoping to try the Eggman..

This is an awesome pizza spot! I've lived in Valpo for a while, but I didn't realize it was here. It's pretty small, and tucked in the back of another building. I am glad I found it, though! The pizzas were excellent, and the menu had lots of unique options to choose from. The drink menu was equally as appealing. There are only a few tables inside, so I think I will get take out most often, but I highly recommend coming here!

Pizza was good except crispy at the one end of crust.

Super unique and always awesome. Never had anything bad here

A guy was quoting a meme i m coming back. and everyone was super polite and it was a comfortable environment

Really, REALLY great thin-crust pizza! Small, cozy atmosphere. Staff were very friendly. Time from order to table was about 15 minutes.

Great pizza perfectly cooked. Though sometimes you can't tell how good the pizza is because it is covered in raw spinach or arugula. This place has a very small dine in area, so heads up, it's not somewhere to bring your family, order takeout instead. Besides the mountain of greens on the pizza, it's still the best in town, followed by the tomato bar.

This is a little hole in the wall artisan wood fired pizza place with great and imaginative flavor combos and awesome drinks! There are a few tables inside and you can order from the window and eat outside as well. Of course you can always carry out and bring it home. The staff were friendly and cheerful. I think this will become a regular spot for us!

I keep trying the new breed of high heat oven pizza places and am always disappointed. After visiting this place, the streak continues.

Friendly staff and delicious pizza!! So yummy and wonderful atmosphere

Really fun. Eat in, or take it out on the plaza. I go here for a Gluten Free crust, and with the wood smoke oven, it tastes awesome. Beer, wine and cocktails too.

Stopped by during one of the many festivals in downtown Valpo. Extremely delicious and very friendly and attentive staff. We will absolutely come back and highly recommend visiting.

Food was okay, but the woman working the register was rather unpleasant. Everyone has a bad day, so I don t know, maybe It was one for her. It did rub me the wrong way though, and the food wasn t good enough for me to consider going back any time soon. Maybe I ll try again someday. Seems like a lot of people have had a pleasant experience.

Super creative zzas and killer cocktails! Best looking staff in Valpo, and I love how the wood fired oven makes them sweat!

Great food and yes they serve drinks! Bit small on the dine in area but that's part of the charm.

Great pizza and drinks. Love the atmosphere and employees.

Small place with excellent pizzas, a good craft beer selection, and a small list of mixed drinks. I highly recommend.

This little hole in the wall Pizza Joint was great! No, let me make that really great! I ordered the meatballs an appetizer which came smothered in their own homemade sauce. Wow! Where these excellent!! I could have ordered them as my main meal and gone home Happy. Not to miss are their garlic bites which are scrumptious perfectly done bite-size garlic rolls smothered in garlic oil. Very yummy! Their pizzas were also great. As far as I know, they come in one size roughly 12 in across personal sized & priced right. You can get just about anything on it. I don't know if you can get a thick and chewy pizza here, maybe.. but I like thin and crispy and these little pizzas did not disappoint!
I had originally intended to take some home for lunch the next day but I just kept eating and eating and there was eventually nothing to take home... if you are visiting Valparaiso and will be on the lookout for lunch or dinner while they're, this is simply a can't miss little pizza place!

Wood fired pizza is fantastic. Craft cocktails are on point as well. Service is great and everyone is super friendly. Small space and they offer take out. Some vegan options if that's your thing.

Great thin crust pizza, the dates were delicious. Not much eating area made for outdoor eating when weather permits of course.

Pizza crust looks like a tortilla ,no flavor. Place could be really good but falls short. Hopefully they improve their food.

I definitely will recommend this place to anyone who wants to experience so many flavors in one bite .. so amazing!!

Pizza is delicious and the staff is mostly polite. Though the restaurant is quite small, in the summer there is a lot more space outside. Overall, it's great if you want some pizza. But, these pizzas arent exactly just normal cheese or pepperoni (they still do serve pepperoni), these pizzas have different ingredients like mushroom and artichoke (my favorite), or a fried egg! 10/10 would choose again

Holla back poppers were the best! We loved everything we had. Can't wait to come here again.

Pizza is spectacular. I have tried the eggman, the Greek, the purple pig, and the Cuban. All of them are amazing. Pizzas are made with natural ingredients. A must try if you are in the area. Definitely going back soon

Cool oven, delicious pizza. Not a lot of seating, but there's benches nearby to sit on outside.

Food and drinks are very unique and delicious!! Service was great also.

Really cool small place with wood fired pizza oven. Good food. Great staff and service.

Always great! Can have a nice cocktail while you wait for your order.

On the smaller size but well worth the trip the food was super delicious and original and like nothing you have ever had, plus there peach whiskey drink was super delicious!!! Totally worth the trip. Just be patient.

Great pizza and salad. The best, most creative flavor combinations! This is a favorite wether I dine from one of the trucks or now downtown. Excellent job Andrea and staff!

Delicious combinations, not your average pizza. Pizzas are thin and they feature a variety of fresh ingredients that make these pizzas unique and delicious.

Love the pizza here. Pretty much anything you get will be pretty good. I wish they had a pizza for carnivores. I'd be all over that.

Absolutely AMAZING pizza! Stone baked right there while you wait. The meatball and the garlic dough bites appetizers are simply delicious. Highly recommend the Cubano pizza. Theres a walk up window for customers that want to order a quick bite from the sidewalk. Definitely a new personal favorite place to eat.

Revisit: You still can't go wrong grabbing a delicious slice from this pizza joint! Cheesiest cheese pizza around, great vegetarian options and vegan specials. Wonderful owner and staff. Always a favorite!

Love there pizza and the stoner bites are really good. Crispyness and light crust is always wonderful!!

This place is a great home made pizza eatery. The environment is low key and fun. The food is amazing and the options are endless! This is a go to place when we are in town!

The food is beyond Amazing I highly recommend this place

So I was watching barstool reviews and that guy goes to so many pizza places , after watching that I was craving a brick oven pizza , not many places around here have those kinds of ovens , after a few ppl on fb said to go to your place . Well we did and let me tell you by far is one of the best places I have ate at I just wish that the pizzas could be as big as the pizza cutter on your wall ,,, will definitely be back,

Each pizza and appetizer we've had have been delicious.