Riley's Street Station Reviews

Now talk about the place to be in East Aurora. Wonderful food, great service and modest prices.

Good lunch spot, I liked the interior decor, and the menu was reasonably diverse as well. Also a good selection of beer - I had the fish tacos, and was mildly disappointed in that there was too much fish for the amount of cabbage and pineapple relish. Colleague had the beef burrito, and really liked that.

Cool place. Wish it would have been warmer, they have a nice patio with outdoor seating. Reasonable prices, good service and great atmosphere. Walking distance to downtown. I had the beef on weck and it was very good. Burgers looked good. The corn dogs got a luke warm reaction.

My husband and I walked in and looked for the ppl we were meeting, didn't find them so we waited are the hostess station to be seated.
And waited
And waited
Nobody came over, nobody even walked by letting us know someone would be with us.
We left.

Historic train station turned into a lively restaurant and bar. Perfect for watching the game, or enjoying a family meal! In warmer months eating outside on the patio is relaxing and delicious!

What an over priced restaurant seriously $13.00 for four chicken tenders $11.00 for two hot peppers that were not cooked must be a East Aurora thing will not go back. WAY to pricey they have a 8 oz strip steak sandwich for $25.00 Really......Oh well

Place wasn't busy but service was extremely slow. Waitress was friendly but aloof and a horrible waitress. Food was just OK, definitely not worth the wait or experience.

The only good part was our French onion soup. The rest of the experience was awful. It wasn't busy but our waiter was nowhere to be found. My husband got the beef on weck which wasn't bad but the fries were disgusting. I got the poutine fries which I couldn't even eat. The gravy was so bland and the fries were so gross that I took two bites and couldn't even make myself eat anymore. We will never go back.

We put our names on the list at 6pm and we were told that we would have a table by 6:30. After that, Groups of 2, 3, 4, and even 5 came in behind us and were seated IMMEDIATELY. We waited a full HOUR AND 45 MINUTES for a table that we were promised we would have within 30 minutes. After watching about 10 groups come in after us and be seated almost instantly I started to lose my patience. When we finally sat down at 7:45 (AN HOUR AND 15 MINUTES LONGER THAN OUR "3O MINUTE" WAIT TIME) we were not offered a discount on the bill or a free drink or a dessert or anything at all. Not even an apology!! Maybe next time I'll wait an hour for the barbill instead of relying on false promises only to be disappointed. Two thumbs way down

My husband's burger was as ordered he did not like the french fries, I ordered the Pasta w Chicken for $21 and received a large bowl of pasta with chicken a few artichoke hearts and maybe 3 mushrooms and a very mild sauce no salad or even bread I cannot believe there was no salad - we will not go back

I went here for my birthday and the food was a hot mess, the nacho plate was great, my burger not so much. I might give it a second chance, but it won't be my first choice.

Great menu selection, food was good and service was excellent.

I would have given this five stars had our dinner bill not been sticker shock. The food was enjoyable and our server,Connor was pleasant. Our dinners came out in a timely manner and the presentation was very nice. The decor is reminiscent of the older days when this was an active train station stop. Even more so when a train went by on active tracks above our seating area outside.
Friday dinner seemed to draw a more mature crowd in the rear dining room. I am however,one of the crowd to fit in. The bar area was a bit noisier and a bit younger. Tough for us OLD folks to carry on a conversation. Dinner area wad much more subdued.
We would go there again.

Excellent food, great atmosphere, cool location, perfect service!
My daughter had her baby shower there and everyone had a great time. I highly recommend Riley Street for special events as well as every day dining out.

Situated on the same site as the ole' East Aurora
Train Depot and several pictures on walls and on table tops. Now, getting down to the necessities, the food, you will find well prepared whether thick burgers to entrees and at reasonable prices. I enjoy their Friday Fish Special but I've tried several other 'eats' and as stated already, well prepared. Best to call for reservations, especially on weekends.

Couple notes to add; first if lucky you may see and hear a train pass on tracks right near the Station, and if you like to ice skate (seasonal) there is an ice rink next door.

Always have had a good meal. One of our favorite places to go.

Good food and good service. In particular, they have excellent fish fries. My ONLY criticism is that the prices are about $2 more than I think they should he for the quality.

Went at dinner time on Sunday, it was busy. We were seated in the bar area. Good hosting, good service. Spinach artichoke dip is so yummy and filling! Burger is good, cooked just right. My husband had a Reuben, it was super good and big, lots of meat. We were so stuffed! Had a good experience, we'll be back.

Good service and food during lunch. Attentive service.

Cool old train station turned into restaurant. Enjoyed food and service

Fair prices, and their nacho appetizer is delicious (enough for 2-3 people)

Good food, service and of course, beer!! Nice atmosphere at both the bar and tables.

BEEN THERE 4 TIMES IN THE LAST 6 MONTHS AND NEVER HAD AN ISSUE. THE SERVICE WAS FINE AND SO WAS THE FOOD. VERY FRIENDLY EMPLOYEES AND NO ROWDY PEOPLE WHEN I WAS THERE AT THE BAR. THE BARTENDER WAS GREAT AS WAS EVERYTHING ELSE - WOULD NOT HESITATE GOING BACK
I GIVE IT 4 OUT OF 5 STARS
HARRY W.

Good food and service, little bit of a wait for the food. We would go again

Excellent service, food, and atmosphere! What more can you ask for...

Awesome! Amber was very pleasant! Food was very good.

It's a nice place to eat. the patios great in the summer. bars got a decent selection

Great spot. Good food. Great drinks. Great atmosphere. Especially this time of year. Especially if you like trains. Or even if you dont!

Nicely perserved but refurbished train station! Fireplace, ambience, setting offered a casual-to-fine dining experience. Our waitress Amber, absolutely friendly, accurate, courteous, efficient, just perfect!! There's outdoor patios as well. Also has bar. But this was NOT a sports/bar grill when dining. The dining areas completely separate from the bar area! Portions out weighed the cost for sure. Fair dining prices. Can't wait to go back!!

Great for drinks and food. Not to mention the Wednesday pub quiz where all are welcomed for a good showdown @730. Friendly locals, nice indoor outdoor area and a long bar to rest your weary bones for a pint or two:)

Bartender tapped the keg and left the old beer in my glass. Very slow night for a Saturday

Delightful atmosphere, attentive but not bothersome wait staff and delicious food. Highly recommend the experience.

Nice atmosphere for casual dining. I had the roast beef on kimmelweck with fries and a side saled.. The roast beef was on the tough side, the fries and salad were really good. Would go again and try something different.

Great local watering hole. Tuesday's have a $2 tacos and $4 margheritas deal

Food and atmosphere is awesome drinks are a bit pricey but the food is phenomenal

Ambiance is casual. Roast beef sandwich was up to par. Service was good.

good food, good menu selection, cool location. great patio area, staff was very friendly and accommodating

It is a nice atmosphere but the drinks are not so good, per experience.. when you order a tall glass it should be filled with ice and a double of which ever liquor you choose not taste just like the juice or pop you pick and barely any ice or garnishment. Very disappointed for the price of the drinks. The best part of my night here was the entertainment provided by Wasted Whisky

Absolute worst pizza ever. Ordered through doordash and after getting The order wrong they sent a disgusting frozen dough mess of a pizza over two hours later. It went right in the garbage.

Great service, we had 1/2 of our hockey team in for pregame light food....perfect setup! Bar and dining room was a great setup.

Nice restaurant in East Aurora. Nice atmosphere with the restored train station.

Great food, nice atmosphere. Enjoy the place greatly

It can be a little pricey when ordering fries onion rings & drinks etc.The dinner menu was average price. My fish tacos which were considered appetizers were excellent & with a cup of soup was a perfect size "dinner" for me.My husband had beef on weck which got a thumbs up I had a cup of mushroom soup that was hot creamy rich & loaded with mushrooms. Husband had Cajun potato soup which he ate every drop.
The service was good.The beer on tap could have been colder

They ask for a credit card when you sit down. Who does that? I am with my girlfriend with a food menu. Am I a flight risk or something? Immediate turn off that I would normally just leave, but I was hungry.
I had a southwestern chicken wrap. $14 for extremely dry chicken, lettuce and some black beans. No fries or anything. The beer was cold, I guess it deserves a star for that

The bartender Cindy is an absolute treasure! Always so cheerful, and friendly! Second to none!

Gluten free options and attentive wait staff! It's limiting to eat at American style restaurants as a Celiac due to the many deep fried options that are omitted, but Riley Street Station did an excellent job making it a breeze! They recommend a few dishes that could be adapted, and a few that were naturally GF.

Would recommend as a safe option for Celiac's.

My wife and I always stop in for lunch when in East Aurora. Great food in a railway station setting.

Always clean and the atmosphere is cozy. Servers are amazing and don't make you wait for those water refills we all love! French onion soup is my favorite here!

Great use of location and the food is equally as amazing. Great for dates and special nights and the prices aren't too high, but portions are appropriate to the price.

This place creeped me out. Staff couldn't have been less interested. Food is ok, but over priced. In a town filled with great bars and restaurants, there is literally no reason to go here.

Cool place, it's an old train station. Food is decent and service is great.

Excellent variety of beers & very good service. Employees were exceptional.

Food is generally good (especially the fresh oysters and clams in the summer months), beer selection good, mixed drinks can be hit or miss. Not a huge wine selection. Service can sometimes be very slow (and food takes forever to appear sometimes as well, even when they're not that busy).

Food took 45 minutes to come out. Portions were small and not what we expected. Food was also very average for the price.

Stopped for lunch and enjoyed the pasta special. Great service very nice atmosphere.

Service was good and the Cajun seafood was very tasty we also tried their homemade potato chips with cheese dip that we thought was excellent

Bartender was extremely rude. As soon as we approached the bar she told us that we had to go somewhere else due to the fact that I am under 21. However, another party that had 2 children with them were not told to move. After that the experience was nice.

Don't know if we caught them on an off night but....Sorry I cannot recommend
Good food. Amazing location. Unfortunately not the kind of service I would have expected.

But the bar and front desk were empty. After a hunt I found everyone setting tables in a back room chatting like nothing was wrong.
With so many choices in East Aurora, this is a shame because I love the layout and the look and feel of the place. Work on the service and I will be back

Little bit of shotty service at the bar, but a great venue

Had a great time listening to a great band. Drinks were a little pricey, & they raise the prices when the band starts

Great food ,comfortable sitting, good bar to get a drink

At a bridal shower at this venue, and found the barmaid very rude. She charged $7 for a change in the juice mixer ( the alcohol was prepaid) and it was for one single guest and one single juice. $7!! She was rude to another guest as well. Maybe a bad day? I don't know, but a lot of money was spent on that shower. Food was okay, pretty standard, not spectacular. Pretty place, but all in all, not impressed.

Consistently bad food a d high prices. I wont be back.

Visited this restaurant during restaurant week. The food was excellent, the service was great.

Just decided to stop in for pizza and wings ....let's say please take the pizza off the menu....frozen dough, bland sauce spiced up with oregano and cheap pepperoni....to RSS's credit they did offer to take off bill and replace...but we said no, but they still removed pizza off bill...of course we left the other half....maybe try a sandwhich next...fyi our male waiter was fantastic and understanding..he gets 5 stars...

Nice atmosphere, good food, nice place to hang out.

Food was okay. My order was wrong. At the end of our meal all you could smell was sewer.

Food is hit or miss here. Sometimes service can be slow. Place has potential, but currently not where it needs to be unfortunately.