Reviews 12
Filters:
Rating
Language
Sort:
Most recent
K
9 months ago

The pizzas at New Bethel Ordinary are simply outst...

The pizzas at New Bethel Ordinary are simply outstanding! The crust is light and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Their customer service is also top-notch. Highly recommend trying their Veggie Pizza!

C
10 months ago

🌟 I can't get enough of New Bethel Ordinary's pizz...

🌟 I can't get enough of New Bethel Ordinary's pizzas! They never disappoint in taste or quality. The crust is always perfectly baked, and the toppings are always fresh. The staff is friendly and efficient. Highly recommend their Pepperoni Pizza! 🍕

A
11 months ago

The pizza at New Bethel Ordinary is fantastic! The...

The pizza at New Bethel Ordinary is fantastic! The crust is perfectly crispy and the toppings are always fresh. I order from them regularly and have never been disappointed. The online ordering system is easy to use, and the delivery is always on time. Highly recommend!

K
1 year ago

😍 I absolutely love New Bethel Ordinary! Their piz...

😍 I absolutely love New Bethel Ordinary! Their pizzas are incredible, and the service is always top-notch. The crust is crispy and the flavors are well-balanced. The staff is super friendly too. My go-to pizza place! 🍕

S
1 year ago

The pizza here is amazing! The crust is perfect, a...

The pizza here is amazing! The crust is perfect, and the toppings are always fresh. I love that they offer a wide variety of options to choose from. The customer service is phenomenal too. Highly recommend trying their BBQ Chicken Pizza!

P
1 year ago

I am a regular customer of New Bethel Ordinary and...

I am a regular customer of New Bethel Ordinary and I have always been satisfied with their service and food quality. Their pizzas are delicious and always fresh. The staff is friendly and efficient. I highly recommend trying their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, it's my absolute favorite!

J
1 year ago

I've tried various pizza places in town, but New B...

I've tried various pizza places in town, but New Bethel Ordinary stands out as one of the best. Their pizzas are consistently delicious, with a perfect balance of flavors. The friendly staff and prompt delivery are added bonuses. Highly recommend!

I
1 year ago

The pizza from New Bethel Ordinary is always a hit...

The pizza from New Bethel Ordinary is always a hit! The crust is perfectly cooked, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. The customer service is excellent too. They never fail to deliver a delicious pizza. Highly recommended!

R
1 year ago

🍕 New Bethel Ordinary is one of my favorite pizza ...

🍕 New Bethel Ordinary is one of my favorite pizza places in town! Their pizzas are always scrumptious and the toppings are of top quality. The customer service is also excellent, with friendly and helpful staff. I love their Margherita pizza 🍅🧀. Highly recommended! 🌟

F
1 year ago

New Bethel Ordinary is a gem! Their pizzas are del...

New Bethel Ordinary is a gem! Their pizzas are delicious and they have a good variety of flavors to choose from. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. I'm a regular customer and have never been disappointed. Highly recommended!

B
1 year ago

The pizza at New Bethel Ordinary is simply amazing...

The pizza at New Bethel Ordinary is simply amazing! I've been a loyal customer for years now, and they never disappoint. The crust is always crispy, and the toppings are delicious. Plus, the staff is always friendly and attentive. Highly recommend!

C
1 year ago

I have been ordering from New Bethel Ordinary for ...

I have been ordering from New Bethel Ordinary for over a year now, and their pizza never disappoints. The crust is deliciously crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are generous. Their delivery is always prompt as well. It's truly one of the best pizza places around!

About New bethel ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary: A Hidden Gem in Indianapolis

If you're looking for a cozy and welcoming place to grab a bite or have a drink, look no further than New Bethel Ordinary. Located at 8838 Southeastern Avenue in Indianapolis, this hidden gem is the perfect spot for locals and visitors alike.

At New Bethel Ordinary, you'll find a warm and inviting atmosphere that's perfect for relaxing with friends or family. The decor is rustic and charming, with plenty of wood accents and vintage touches that give the space an old-fashioned feel.

But it's not just the ambiance that makes New Bethel Ordinary special - it's also the food. The menu features classic American fare with a twist, including burgers, sandwiches, salads, and more. Everything is made from scratch using fresh ingredients sourced from local farms whenever possible.

One standout dish is the "Ordinary Burger," which comes topped with bacon jam, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion rings, and mayo on a brioche bun. It's juicy and flavorful without being too heavy - the perfect balance of indulgence and satisfaction.

If you're in the mood for something lighter but still satisfyingly delicious try their salads like their "Southwest Salad" which comes loaded with grilled chicken breast over mixed greens topped with black beans corn salsa avocado sour cream tortilla strips served w/ chipotle ranch dressing on side.

And don't forget about drinks! New Bethel Ordinary has an impressive selection of craft beers on tap as well as wine by glass or bottle to pair perfectly with your meal or just enjoy while catching up with friends at their bar area.

But what really sets New Bethel Ordinary apart from other restaurants in Indianapolis is its commitment to community involvement. They regularly host events like trivia nights charity fundraisers live music performances etc., making it more than just another restaurant but rather an integral part of its neighborhood community.

So if you're looking for a place to unwind and enjoy some delicious food and drinks, head over to New Bethel Ordinary. With its welcoming atmosphere, tasty menu, and commitment to community involvement, it's sure to become your new favorite spot in Indianapolis.

New bethel ordinary

New bethel ordinary

4.4