Milwaukee Athletic Club Review

One of the best choices in Milwaukee! Thank you for great services.

Mostly nice. Pretty clean over all but the room had an unpleasant smell. Couldn t open the window for fresh air. The lobby looks great but the room was very plain and had not been remodeled in at least 40 years. The food was definitely above average. This is a members only club and you are allowed to do some things as a hotel guest but it always felt like we were the new kids in school.

Not at all as advertised. Even their daily specials and events are not as advertised. 4-6pm happy hour wasn't happy hour our bartender said. Flyers in the elevator suggested otherwise. Won't be back. You get what you pay for in this area. Extra 100 for a night will get you a nice, clean hotel nearby.

Good facility. I like their hours and the open space.

The rooms are not what the picture shows, once we complained and got upgraded to a suite it was reasonable. The suites are comparable to a normal room at a fairly upscale hotel. Customer service was great though once we voiced concerns. Location is hard to beat for Milwaukee

We recently chose to stay at the MAC based on convenience as we attended a wedding. Based on the MAC's reputation we expected first class accommodations throughout, unfortunately that's not what we recieved. The lobby areas, common spaces and ball room are dated, but fairly well maintained considering how old the building is. Unfortunately, we were utterly shocked and appalled on arrival to our room...EVERYTHING from the 1950s tiled bathroom, to the 1970s looking carpet, to the bedding, accordion style faux wood closet doors, etc was far beyond out of date. Our standard double queen room didn't even have headboards on the beds. Had I been blind folded while walking into the building I would have thought I was at a budget motel based on the condition of the room. The price we paid did not match what we received as far as room accommodations...oh and parking was an additional $16 a day. I appreciate history and have been to some of the oldest hotels in the country that have done an excellent job at both preserving a historical feel while still keeping a cleanly modern appearance. MAC has unfortunately woefully failed at this. I suggest this establishment go through a major reno of all their guest rooms to say the least! Next time we visit MKE we'll be staying at The Pfister or Westin, where for about the same price we'll get much more bang for our buck.

All in all my stay was great. I forgot the guys name at the front desk this past weekend of the 22nd Feb. 14. However he was very helpful and kind. And I thank you . The hotel was dated, but for the age of the hotel it was fine. Great location lots of stuff to do in the area. I didn't like the fact of paying 15 dollars for parking. But again it was OK. I can understand. the food service and drink/bar service was really not there for the weekend. I know the lobby bar was open until midnight Friday. But closed early on Sat and Sunday. Again a lot of things to do in the area, so it was not a bother.

The MAC was great for location.

Tues rooftop dancing is THEE best! Great music, fun and nice people, friendly staff, and great food and drink! A FAV!!!

Members only. Good place for a workout. There's also a rooftop bar here.

We stayed at the hotel cause the rates were nice and the location was great. I was upset that the women's sauna and steam room had been out of service due to a flood in the basement. They could have made the other sauna coed but they didn't. Room was nice but pretty sure it was haunted. Sarah, the masseuse was amazing! However I probably wouldn't stay here again.

This is a Historic Hotel and I enjoy visiting on occasion.
Rooms may be very small or average size, based on what you book.
I enjoy the quality and cleanliness of the rooms that I had.
The beds are so comfortable!!!
Check out the floor with the Gym and Swimming Pool...fantastic.
The restaurant and bar has great service, good for evening meetings.
You would also enjoy the Elephant Room for some business talks.

so wrong it's right. every thing from the public style toilets in the rooms to the creepy pictures on the walls make this a special stop for any traveler .

Very nice accommodations and relatively inexpensive for the area. Lots of great places within walking distance. Drinks at the bar where a bit pricey in my opinion and the rooms especially the bathrooms could use a little updating but overall a nice place.

Went for a wedding to the Milwaukee Athletic Club and fell in love with the venue! The food was AMAZING, gorgeous rooms, wonderful customer service!