Mama Luke’s Pizzeria Review

Rustic feel, good service all around! Pizza was absolutely delicious! Large portions! Highly recommend!

Best steak and chesse grinder with fresh garlic best ever

Great food and service. We had a work dinner here with a group of 12. Fun times great food

Ok another OMG moment food was awesome had the meatball grinder meatballs were flavorful and the size of baseballs for a 12 inch grinder I could only eat half my wife ordered the pasta and that too was huge portions you really get a bang for your buck here
Also order a Irish cream float even though it wasn't on menu waitress made me one and it was fantastic and yes service here too was what it's supposed to be like eating out
If I could give 10 stars instead of 5 I would
Great for family or date night like I did

Pizza 5 Stars, been going here for years. Formerly known as Joey Garlics.

Prices , portions , wait staff and owner were very impressive

Pizza quality has fallen significantly. My recent order had little topping.

Great food (and lots of it), service, and ambiance. Love everything about this place - we will be back!

Huge servings .1 pnd pasta for every order. great eggplant fries too

The food was so delicious, huge portions, and friendly service I wish I lived closer!

Great food..portions where more than I could eat and excellent ser9

Went in a month ago and my orger was made wrong, however the atmosphere and food that I was brought was still awesome even if they gave me the wrong order completely lol

Has gone down hill since owner change. I asked for large light cheese... Waited 15 minutes past promised time, and pizza had wayyyy too much cheese. When I told staff, no offer to remake

This use to be Joey's Garlic, but the owner branched off and renamed it Mama, Luke's. The food is pretty much the same with some new items. I really enjoyed the food. The manager and waitress was very attentive. If you are used to Joey's Garlic, You will continue to enjoy this little surprise and shall I see you will get a lot of food for your money. I mean alot.
I highly recommended this place.

Great food, good service, they make the best Long island iced tea.

Excellent, huge portions, service was great. Pasta Alfredo was soooooo very good

This past Sunday was my first time at Mama Luke s and the rumors I heard about the generous portions were true. We walked in for a table of 6 and were seated in a prompt, timely manner. The food was delicious and we have basically enough leftovers for three more meals. We ordered the long hots and eggplant fries as an appetizer and various pasta dishes and 14 subs/grinders. I ordered a seasonal sugar cookie martini and it was absolutely delicious, I highly recommend this festive, holiday drink! My only small, really insignificant issue is that the tables and seats are a bit close, but other than that I have no complaints whatsoever. I recommend this place for families who like to eat and be merry!

THE Bomb!!!! Huge portions..awesome food..EXCELLENT service!!! The Fra Diavlo rocks!!! My Girl LOVED the Scampi..TONS of shrimp and you can not beat the Eggplant fries!! We'll be Back!!!

Had a great salad and adult beverages. Lovely staff

Great food and service, our first time here we will be back .

Very good place to have a party,the staff was very attentive kept the food flowing. I would recommend this place to everyone.

Service was great!! extremely friendly. very family-orientated. They have very good, homemade food.reasonable pricing . thanks for following up on us. 28,000 people have followed.we view a new out of the way place every day .

Very nice parking lot I turned around but thanks google for forcing this 1984-esque rating system down our throats

This time i received my food the way it should have been. My last transaction with Mama Luke's it wasn't a pleasant one, the food i received wasn't cooked correctly. But i explained today's order the way i wanted it and the way they prepared my last order. But it came correct today... Thanks

The food is in a class of it's own. It was very delicious. The wait staff was attentive and fun. I have been going back almost everyday.

The former Joey Garlic's has seen no diminishment of the quality of the food or service at the table since the name change. Today was one of the rare tines of being seated without a lengthy wait. Always busy and often overflowing, parking can be a bit of a challenge, even with the overflow lot. Being on a busy street, exiting, especially left out of the parking lot, can be a harrowing experience .
The menu additions in recent years, especially the Impossible Burger, has made it more inviting to my vegetarian tastes. My son, who has certain health conditions was able to modify his menu choices as well.

Great food and great portions for a great price! Staff is super friendly too!

Wanted a Turkey grinder, but no, not today I was told. So, asked for a pizza, but no, they had a big pizza order and could not fix me a pizza.
Are you kidding??!! No, not kidding. Same for others in my office.
Their menu is like a book, and really terrible, not user friendly.
It seems they cook whatever you want, whenever you want, and if people don't want that than tough.
Our office gets lunch every Friday and we were looking for somewhere new. Still looking.

We had a weird waiter who made us uncomfortable, and the portions are way too large and not humanly possible to complete in one sitting. Otherwise it was comfortable.

The environment was relaxing. The music was calming not hype and roudy. The food had good taste and textures. You definitely get your money's worth. The portion sizes are alittle extreme. One pasta meal can feed three people. Leftovers are a given. Overall the first time experience was excellent fun and worth the spending.

First time....absolutly loved it....great food excellent service and I enjoyed the rustic decor....

Was put on waiting list. Called us up ahead of another group (that we knew and) that was there ahead of us. The other group spoke up and got in. I then realized the were disorganized and had to ask if they put us back on the wait list in the order as I saw other people getting called ahead of us. I was right. We got crossed off the waiting list and was told we didn't come up when we were called. I called BS and we ended up getting in shortly after that.
Food good, once we were in and served. I will consider going back in the future...
K-Lap

Happy hour is great ... come every week at least ...orange salad w/chicken is my fav... tried the hamburger salad with the impossible burger awesome

Better than Joey garlic's. New Haven style pizza good beer.. the baby liked it!

It was very pleasant experience especially because you really feel safe. They are taking seriously keeping clean and safe. And the food was amazing. definetly recommended. thank you!

Just as yummy as Joey Garlic's. Owners split up so name changed. Eggplant Fries and Pizza are excellent choice.

Great food. Good service. Love their carmelized onion on pizza. Great portions too. The manager us very pleasant too

Food was amazing!! Everything from the salad, garlic bread, and our entrees. HUGE portions of pasta!! Service was very quick. Our waitress was extremely nice and very professional!

Food Delicious and Hugge Portions / Very Disappointed at the $4 extra charge for Gluten Free though. My grandson has to be Gluten Free/ why penalize His parents (or me $$ wise) for a condition None of us has any control over.

Amazing place food is awesome service is on point were there every week

OMG. You will be satisfied! My girlfriend took me here this afternoon to celebrate Father's Day & because they have the Impossible Burger. Mitch was our server, he was polite, patient and made sure we were happy throughout the visit. Hands down the best service and wonderful atmosphere. Burger was scrumptious and fries just as well! You'll be happy you tried Mama Luke's, I'm 100% certain I'm coming back and you will too!

Food is always delicious and portions are very generous. Their eggplant fries are to die for. A bit slow on service and we had to send the calzone back. Over 90% cheese with the tiniest bit of bread. So I wouldn't reccomend that but their Sicilian Salad is amazing.

Mama Luke's[formerly Joey Garlic's] is a really wonderful experience for the single, the couple or the family. Service is fast and very attentive. The food that comes out of the kitchen has been treated with love and affection. Portions are very generous, and exacting in quality. The attention to detail for each dish is the reason that the five stars are given. Whether you are getting apps[Calamari Friti is my Favorite, with hot peppers], entrees[the chef takes great care with all ingredients, and the seasoning is exacting], or a sandwich[Chicken parm grinder with 3 pounded breasts, sauce and fixings], every order is attended to with great care and pride.
The emphasis on fresh ingredients, generous portions executed well and the customer is always the focus. OH..........and let's not forget the very friendly bar that is available, well stocked and staffed with knowledgeable people happy to make your stop enjoyable. A total experience, for the birthday dinner or just a night out. It's worth the trip

It is GREAT restaurant!!! Waiter was very pleasant!!
All there food is FABULOUS!! Have never had a bad meal!! All there portions are HUGE!!

Love the pizza and eggplant fries. Unfortunately last time I picked up I asked for half cheese on one of the pies and they were all full cheese.

Had chicken parmesan. Very good! Portion large had to take half home. Great for a second meal.