Big Olaf Creamery Reviews

The best home made ice cream I stop two or more on the week while delivering office depot supply great place always clean that for me is A+

For the first time in a year we decided to take our health compromised child out for ice cream last night because his birthday is tomorrow. My family safely waited in the parking lot as the place was packed and not a mask in sight. As I began to place my order I asked the employee (who was not wearing gloves or a mask) if he could put on a mask due to my child s health risk. He refused. I said it would be very nice if they would consider doing this for customers who are health compromised. The response? Actually, Florida Law says we don t have to. Correct, it does not. But I wasn t asking for her to be forced to wear one- I was asking them to wear one for 5 minutes to protect a CHILD. Obviously this company is more worried about their personal comfort than the safety of their customers. We ll never go back and I will tell EVERYONE I know about this experience. Mennonites want to share the love of Jesus?? Start by not giving people COVID. There s a start.

Fabulous ice cream. Well worth the money and the wait

My husband and I were here yesterday with our two kids. It was the first time we had ever been here, and it was fantastic! The staff were friendly (lovey people, seriously), I loved the family-friendly atmosphere, and the ice cream was amazing. Overall, a 10/10 experience. We ll definitely be stopping by here again! I highly recommend!

Dude, if you like ice cream, your gonna love this place! Best flavors

Walked into this place for the first and last time last week. The ice cream was not that great. The young girl in the front was friendly but I walked to the back to see if they had something that they were advertising. Two women were behind the counter and both of them saw me but neither acknowledged me. I am a native of Sarasota and I assure you I will let everyone I know to not visit this location. Rudeness and ill manners do not set well with me. The ice cream is overpriced for what you get and the quality is meh. So disappointed. I will take my business where they appreciate it.

Great ice cream, friendly staff. Interesting part of town with the Amish population

This truly is a Sarasota staple and a must go to when visiting. Great atmosphere and even better desserts/ice cream.only downside need to be more aware of basic health codes such as washing hands after handling money back to food.

PACKED AND NOT 1 PERSON WAS WEARING A MASK. COMPLETE 180 FROM 2 WEEKS AGO PLEASE STAY SAFE PEOPLE!! IF THEY CARED ABOUT US THEY WOULD BE ACTING AS EVERYONE ELSE IS TO ASSURE OUR SAFETY And I've ALWAYS loved this place Sad day..

The ice cream is so delicious and a person that weight around all this was so delightful I'm sweet and comfortable seating outside so it was really a tree