Haven't used Bake it Paleo yet?
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Bake it Paleo

Generated with AI from 279 reviews on Trustburn · updated 4 days ago

Customers frequently praise the recipes for being delicious, easy to follow, and suitable for families, with many noting that the dishes turned out great even when they substituted ingredients.
What does Bake it Paleo do?

Bake It Paleo is a food blog run by Katie that features a collection of grain-free, gluten-free, and dairy-free recipes made with whole food ingredients.

Are there any complaints about Bake it Paleo?

The critical reviewers wrote that some recipes resulted in an unpleasant eggy taste, a dry texture, a flat cake with a gooey center, or cookies that did not spread as expected.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Emma Hallam
Reviews 1

I followed the Bake it Paleo recipe exactly as written, only swapping tapioca for cornstarch since that’s what I had on hand, and the result was absolutely amazing! I usually have some doubts when it comes to almond flour treats, but this one really won me over.

Bridgett Hobson
Reviews 1

Bridgett Hobson here! At 12 years old, I can safely say this recipe from Bake it Paleo is absolutely amazing. I gave it a try by swapping out coconut flour for cassava flour, and the result was just as delicious. My tip: cook the pancakes for about five minutes on each side to get the best texture. This is my first time trying a recipe from your blog, and I’m definitely going to explore the rest of your site!

Danielle
Reviews 1

Thanks, Katie! These turned out fantastic in the air fryer last night. I just set it to 375 degrees for around 10 minutes and flipped them halfway through. I always end up getting distracted by other delicious-looking options on the Bake it Paleo site, which just shows how many wonderful recipes you have. I really appreciate all the resources you share!

Elise
Reviews 1

I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of these cookies from Bake it Paleo. They have an excellent texture and a really pleasant taste, making them the perfect companion for your morning coffee. It feels good to enjoy a treat that actually has a purpose behind it. Highly recommended!

Kathleen
Reviews 1

Finally found a paleo pancake recipe that actually works! I’ve attempted so many others with mediocre results, but these were absolutely incredible right out of the pan. Even my partner, who is quite picky about breakfast, declared them the best he’s ever tasted. They taste almost too good to be healthy, so I’m curious—does Bake it Paleo have the nutritional breakdown available? I’d love to make these a daily staple if the macros align with my goals. Thanks for sharing!

Melina Sagarrica
Reviews 1

Hi Katie! Apologies for the double post—I just had to share that my mini and regular Paleo muffins turned out absolutely perfect using your timing (15 and 17 minutes at 350°F, respectively)! Huge thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe from Bake it Paleo. I also have a quick follow-up: is there a specific reason for using water in the recipe, or can I simply swap it for an equal amount of non-dairy milk?

Christina
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo delivers consistently tasty bread, and this loaf is definitely a hit with my daughter. The recipe is incredibly simple to whip up. I’ve actually just popped another one in the oven at home—though this specific loaf is for me since she’s back at university! 😊

Sue
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo really nailed the flavor profile with these treats! I swapped out the beet powder for ground dehydrated raspberries and added some toasted coconut flakes on top, which made them a huge hit. The chocolate base has that rich brownie taste and pairs perfectly with the raspberry coconut cream. While the finish on the cream wasn't as glossy as I hoped, the taste was absolutely outstanding.

Christina
Reviews 1

I finally decided to whip up some pancakes this morning since I was completely out of Bake it Paleo muffins and loaf—my last batch was already sent off to my daughter at university. Even though I have made the tigernut variety countless times, this was my first time trying the pancake recipe, and it was a hit. Just like the site says, they came together in no time, taking only about 30 minutes. I topped them with almond butter for some extra protein, and they were truly delicious and satisfying. Thanks again, Katie, for another winner of a recipe! I’m also really enjoying the fresh new look of the Bake it Paleo website; it’s much easier to navigate now.

Christina
Reviews 1

Katie, another fantastic recipe! I love that you manage to make these muffins both nutritious and absolutely delicious. I actually sent a batch to my daughter at university—she’s a huge fan of all your recipes, to be honest—and she just messaged to say she really enjoyed them. Thanks for always keeping the recipe ideas fresh and exciting!

Kathy Pearson
Reviews 1

I found the perfect way to use up my wet hazelnut and cashew pulp with the Bake it Paleo pancake mix. The result was incredibly light and delicious. I followed the tip to let the batter rest for five minutes to help the coconut oil absorb, and it made a real difference.

Sarah
Reviews 1

If you are a fan of cinnamon buns but watching your health, Bake it Paleo offers a fantastic solution. I tried their protein balls and found them to be a wonderful substitute—perfectly balanced in texture and flavor without being overly sweet or dry. They feel like the ideal guilt-free treat. I even customized the recipe by swapping in dates for raisins, which worked beautifully. Highly recommend checking out bakeitpaleo.com for such thoughtful, delicious options.

Dawna
Reviews 1

This paleo vanilla cake from Bake it Paleo is hands down the best one I’ve ever baked. I made it for my boyfriend’s birthday and topped it with a homemade strawberry cream cheese frosting. The texture was incredibly moist and the flavor was outstanding. It’s impressive that it’s dairy-free, grain-free, and completely refined sugar-free—you really can’t tell the difference. It’s a must-have recipe that I’ll definitely be making again. I wish I had taken a picture because it looked fantastic!

Jonathan Irvine
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo’s waffle recipe is easily the best wheat-free option I’ve tasted. I use a standard large waffle iron, and the yield is perfect for one person—just two waffles. If you’re a fan of adding a quarter cup of maple syrup to each one, this portion size is spot on. I highly recommend finishing them in the oven; that extra step makes a huge difference, giving them a fantastic crispy texture.

Anita Elsbree
Reviews 1

I’ve been experimenting with recipes from Bake it Paleo and the results have been fantastic. I tried both the chocolate and the plain versions. However, I’m running into a textural issue: my cookies aren’t spreading out in the oven; they just hold their scooped shape. I’m wondering if my ratio of tahini oil is off, or if I’m using too much cassava flour? I’d love some tips on how to get them to flatten properly. Thanks!

Noelle F
Reviews 1

My family loved the latest creation from Bake it Paleo! It captures that comforting takeout flavor perfectly while sticking to wholesome, nourishing ingredients. I tweaked the recipe slightly to align with our GI protocol: I used tapioca starch instead of sweet potato, skipped the heat from the sriracha and red pepper, and swapped in a teaspoon of Manuka honey instead of the larger amount of sugar. A garnish of green onions was the perfect finishing touch. It’s already earned a spot in our regular dinner rotation. Thanks, Katie, for sharing this delicious idea!

Janell
Reviews 1

These Paleolithic treats from Bake it Paleo have quickly become a staple in my kitchen. After they sold out the first time I tried them, I made sure to order a double batch immediately. The flavor is just as good as I remembered, and I’m already planning my next purchase.

Kaz
Reviews 1

Another winner from Bake it Paleo! I even messed up and used a whole teaspoon of baking soda instead of the amount called for, but the result was still great. I’m planning to adapt this recipe into a loaf next time to make French toast. One small suggestion for the site: could you please add the gram weight for the almond butter? It’s so much easier to tare the mixing bowl on a scale and just scoop it in directly, rather than dealing with a sticky measuring cup.

Ali
Reviews 1

I was so eager to try Bake it Paleo’s recipe that I accidentally measured out a full cup of flour instead of the required third cup. To fix the thick batter, I gradually stirred in milk a tablespoon at a time. I preheated the air fryer to 350 and divided the mixture into four ramekins. I baked two ramekins at a time, covered, for 20 minutes. These banana pancake muffins were absolutely perfect—just what I needed to satisfy my cravings. Thanks for sharing this delicious recipe!

Lisa
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo delivered some seriously tasty treats! They were incredibly moist and fluffy, just as advertised. I found them a bit mild on the flavor side, so I’m planning to mix in some pumpkin spice next time to really amp up the taste. Still, a solid choice for paleo baking!

Jenny
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo delivered exactly what I needed. The seasoning balance was excellent and the cooking time instructions were accurate, resulting in chicken tenders that were thoroughly cooked yet remained incredibly tender. They were a hit with my toddler, who enjoyed dipping them in plain Greek yogurt—though he’d probably eat them with any curry-flavored sauce anyway. A great choice for family meals.

Marinna
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo nailed it with these cassava pancakes! They have a fantastic flavor and a light texture, completely avoiding that usual gummy feel. The pumpkin adds just the right amount of moisture, which is a huge relief since cassava pancakes tend to dry out and lose their appeal as leftovers. I’m really hoping this brand can finally solve that stale problem.

Rebekah
Reviews 1

Katie, I really appreciated the tip about the parchment paper. We served this wonderful cake for my son’s fifth birthday, and it was an immediate hit with him. The spice blend was excellent and the texture came out perfectly. Even though I used the entire can of coconut cream and sweetened it with date sugar instead of monk fruit—resulting in a slightly runnier frosting than usual—I’d still do everything exactly the same way. The recipe is fantastic; 10/10, and we will definitely be making it again.

Candace
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo has definitely perfected their banana pancake blend. I’ve been cooking these weekly for a few months and they consistently come out amazing. The key is to use just a light coating of coconut oil in the pan; otherwise, they take a long time to cook through. Grateful for this delicious find!

melissa
Reviews 1

I’ve been hunting for a Bake it Paleo recipe that fits my low-sugar, grain-free needs, specifically to use up some pea protein. For these muffins, I skipped the almond yogurt to avoid the added sugars found in most commercial brands and instead used a cup of pumpkin puree, just as suggested. Since I didn’t have vanilla pea protein on hand, the plain version worked perfectly fine. I baked them as ten generous-sized muffins, topping them with raw, unroasted walnuts and a mere drizzle of raw honey. The result was fantastic—fiber-rich, vegan, and perfectly sweet, making them an ideal companion for my morning coffee.

Chris
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo has truly nailed the recipe with these cookies. They are soft, rich in chocolate, and perfectly minty—exactly what I was hoping for. I bake a variety of paleo treats, but these have become my new go-to for every holiday season.

Lorrae
Reviews 1

Hi from Bake it Paleo! Thanks for the kind words on my baking. To answer your question, swapping out the molasses for just the two tablespoons of honey should work fine for sweetness, though keep in mind it might slightly alter the texture and moisture level compared to the original recipe. Hope that helps!

Deborah
Reviews 1

Bake it Paleo, you nailed it with these! I’ve spent ages hunting for ground beef recipes that are both gluten-free and egg-free, but I never thought to try cassava flour until now. The texture is spot on—no gummy or grainy bits at all. I swapped in some dried basil (cut the amount to 3/4 tbsp) and finely chopped jarred pimentos, plus I used your GF Sesame Teriyaki sauce since that was all I had in the pantry. The result was absolutely fantastic. Thanks for the inspiration!

Linda Boror
Reviews 1

These paleo banana pancakes from Bake it Paleo are absolutely delicious! My only minor gribe is that the yield feels a bit small—I consistently have to double the batch to get around 13 pancakes, which suggests the serving size might be smaller than expected.

Corey
Reviews 1

I had extra hazelnut flour on hand after making my own nut milk and stumbled upon your recipe. It came together so fast and tasted great! It turned out a bit more like a cake than a traditional cookie, which was an interesting twist, though I am curious if they are meant to crisp up more in the oven. Either way, these were delicious and I’ll definitely be baking them again. Highly recommended!

Brittani
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed these cookies from Bake it Paleo! Since I was trying buckwheat flour for the first time, I was a bit unsure, but they turned out great. I had to make some swaps for my allergies: I used butter instead of shortening, honey for sugar, and a mix of arrowroot, oil, and water as an egg substitute. I also added an extra tablespoon of buckwheat flour. The dough felt a little too wet and thin for a cookie at first, but adding two tablespoons of psyllium husk powder fixed the consistency. After baking for just 11 minutes, I had perfect cookies. Thanks for the awesome recipe!

Claire
Reviews 1

Finally discovered a savory loaf from Bake it Paleo that doesn’t taste like dessert! I was worried about the flavor profile, but it definitely hits the savory mark. If you’re looking to swap out eggs or regular flour, try using flax eggs and a gluten-free blend like I did—the result was fantastic. Just remember to mix 3 tablespoons of ground flax with 9 tablespoons of water, stir it up, and let it sit for 15 minutes before adding it to the batter. This bread is a keeper; I’ll definitely be baking it on repeat.

Heather B
Reviews 1

Katie, this recipe is fantastic! I tried it today using coconut oil in place of palm shortening and threw in some shredded carrots. We skipped the frosting and just drizzled honey on top—it was a huge success. Two thumbs up. Thank you.

Laura
Reviews 1

I adjusted the Bake it Paleo recipe by halving it and swapping the flax for a single egg, which works great since I don’t have an egg sensitivity. The waffles came out perfectly without sticking to the machine, and the flavor was absolutely delicious. Thanks for posting this useful tip!

Questions & Answers

No questions yet — be the first to ask.

News & Press

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying widget on your website — its a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Embed code

<script src="https://trustburn.com/widgets/index.js"></script>
<div class="trustburn-widget" data-trustburn-protocol="https:" data-trustburn-domain="trustburn.com" data-trustburn-widget="score" data-company-path="bakeitpaleo-com" data-lang="en"></div>
More widgets

About Bake it Paleo

Bake It Paleo is a food blog run by Katie that features a collection of recipes made with whole food ingredients. The recipes are all grain free, gluten free, and dairy free, and follow paleo dietary guidelines. The site organizes content by meal type, diet, and category, and includes sections for desserts, breakfast, and trending recipes such as baked goods, pancakes, bars, and ice cream. It also includes wellness content and a shop section, along with social media links to Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube.