I heard a lot about the shop in advance and I was ...

I heard a lot about the shop in advance and I was there with high expectations and full of anticipation. Unfortunately, I was disappointed across the board.
The only positive first. If you are lucky enough to get a seat in the front of the restaurant, the restaurant has a certain charm. If you are not lucky enough to only get a seat in the back of the "restaurant", you can eat in a room that is more like a storage room.
The pizza itself was really underground. Very greasy, but totally tasteless. The whole thing is served on a paper plate.
Add to that the outrageously high prices. Sure, New York is not cheap. But I ate much better and cheaper in other restaurants there.
The staff wasn't really rude now,
but you noticed that they are not really trying to please the guests. According to the motto: It's the oldest pizzeria in New York, and that's where guests come automatically.
Which, however, is not wrong. The shop lives solely from this fact.
I cannot recommend this restaurant, purely tourist rip off.