Catamaran is a 3 star resort for 5 star pricing. ...

Catamaran is a 3 star resort for 5 star pricing. Don't get me wrong, the amenities are great, but the rooms are very dated and need a good deep cleaning. Old carpet, wallpaper, cracked wood, cobwebs on the deck (big ones!). I could overlook all of that if it were a rate more appropriate, but if I'm paying that much, I'm going to expect a certain level.

We stayed 3 nights and our room was never cleaned. First day we had do not disturb up until 9, but the next two it was open for cleaning. We didn't even care about cleaning, but some fresh washclothes and toilet paper would have been nice!

I'd recommend dropping the prices, or renovating. Get it on a discount if you can, not worth full price.