Laura Ann

Review of Sam's Cellar

I see alot of great reviews so I understand this i...

I see alot of great reviews so I understand this is just my personal opinion but I was really disappointed in the pizza. I'm a New Jersey native and looked up "New york style pizza in Neosho" and Sam's came up so I gave it a shot and ordered two pizzas for carryout. At $15 per a "large" that is equivalent to a typical medium pizza at most places, I expected to be blown away. I personally think it tasted like a pizza made on a tortilla and the sauce was sweeter than I anticipated. No one in my household liked it including my 6yr old who begged to eat anything else but after spending $30 on 2 "large" pizzas, they were going to be eaten so I doctored them up. Definitely not a New York style pizza. I was really disappointed and regret spending that much on pizza we all had to doctor and force down.