This is our second visit as we try to eat at an au...

This is our second visit as we try to eat at an authentic Italian restaurant for our anniversary. This year we were a bit disappointed.
I had the Salmon and Shrimp Vincitorio which was perfect, except for the shrimp. The shrimp was well over cooked, very dry and crunchy. It needs to be moist and snappy. The fettuccini noodles we're perfectly al dente and the Salmon was spot on. That shrimp though.
My wife had the cheese ravioli. The dish was very acidic and had a vinegary taste and feel. Something was missed.
Our server didn't know the wine selection that well. While she was very attentive, she seemed off.
The staff at the front could have been much more warm and welcoming rather than quiet and stoic. While they performed their tasks well, they just seemed unattached. They tried to seat us in their back room that had a very large and loud party of at least 14 people. We were looking for a nice quiet anniversary dinner. We declined that location and waited for another table. The second location was perfect.
The lobby area in particular could use a good cleaning. The tops of the shelving units, decorations, and chandelier were very dusty.
Overall, an average night. This is unusual for this establishment. Hopefully just a one-off.