I was so disappointed and was expecting much more ...

I was so disappointed and was expecting much more considering this is the oldest pizzeria. First of all it's expensive and over rated. Plus if you are going to be charging these kind of prices you would expect proper silverware, nope this is all paper plates, plastic cutlery and plastic cups. Refills are not free and they didn't seem to have Coke products because my Sprite tasted like watered down Sierra Mist or something! We ordered the bleu cheese salad to start with $11.00! It was a big portion but definitely over priced. For the pizza we ordered a large meatball and the other half meat ball and pepperoni. To be honest we had better pizza at the hole in the wall places around NYC, this one was dry and pretty bland. I wouldn't go back and I wouldn't recommend either, better trying the other places around NYC.
** Oh and beware this is cash only, my husband had to use the ATM located across the street to get cash out, very inconvenient considering its 2017!