Reel it In

Review of Belhurst Castle

The only reason this gets 2 stars is due to the wa...

The only reason this gets 2 stars is due to the wait staff otherwise it would get zero.

Wife and I were out for an extended weekend the pinnacle of which would end with what i'd had hoped to be a truly memorable meal at Egars. I had ordered the 24 oz prime rib and added scallops for a "surf and turf" believing that a steakhouse would prepare a treat. How dissapointed I was when about 10 oz of the 24 was nothing but grizzle, fat and silver skin. Completely inedible!

I should have suspected something was up when the dish was brought and it was covered in a thick au jous hidding what should have been a beautiful piece of medium rare prime rib but what ended up being the lowest quality piece of meat. A good steakhouse wouldve served any sauce or au jous on the side.

When i wouldnt finish it and made my displeasure known, i was offered a dessert on the house. Gee, thanks for the $8 consolation for serving me $40 piece of flavorless tendon.

If you want a nice place and great food go to the Seneca Harbor Station in Watkins Glen. DO NOT EAT AT THE BELHURST!