I was here for HRW and got an appetizer, entree, a...

I was here for HRW and got an appetizer, entree, and dessert.
They give an amazing garlic bread prior to being served. As for the food, the server suggested the turtle soup and said that everybody loves it but with all honesty, it wasn't that good. As for the pecan wood grilled filet mignon, it was tender and delicious. Even the carrots were good. For dessert, I got beignets and they were okay; they are definitely not the best ones I've had. Overall, the ambience is really nice; it's dark and mostly quiet. I did like that there was valet parking ($5) because it's very hard to find parking in that area.
Although everything was good, it wasn't great. For this reason I decided to only give it 4 stars because I feel like the restaurant is way too overrated.