Login or sign up
For business
Average ratingExcellent
4.5/ 5

Based on 537 reviews

577%
413%
35%
23%
12%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Zaffiros

Based on 537 reviews on Trustburn · updated 101 days ago

Customers generally give Zaffiros high marks, with many calling the pizza the best around and praising the friendly staff and good service, though some have noted inconsistent food quality and slow service.
What does Zaffiros do?

No description is on file for Zaffiros, so it isn't clear from the information available what the business specifically does, though the reviews mention pizza and a restaurant setting.

What are the most common complaints about Zaffiros?

Describing what the critical reviewers wrote, the lowest-rated reviews cite a steak sandwich that made a customer sick, broken air conditioning and equipment along with burnt croutons and mediocre pizza, and rude or dismissive treatment from staff such as a cashier and hostess.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Bruce Frederick
Reviews 1

Were a Zaffiro's last night with the extended family....We had a very good time....The resturant was packed but we got the last seats..... Oh and it was loud with people talking, laughing and enjoying themselves..... I have eaten here many times.....the food was about average....we had pizzas and meatball sandwichs and desserts..... I have had really excellent pizzas in the past here..... I just think that there were too many people here and alot more waiting so maybe the kitchen was rushing to get folks served?? Dessert was a little bit mushy..... But what the hell..... We had a GREAT TIME here and will be back.....

Holly Dyer
Reviews 1

We ordered a Zaffiro s salad which was crisp and filled with wonderful cheese, sausage, black olives, tomatoes, croutons and a few peppers. It comes with a dressing which you add at home to avoid a soggy salad and Italian bread.
Our pizza was thin, crisp and delicious. Covered with cheese and mushrooms and half sausage. I know it sounds dull but it s what we enjoy and it is always wonderful when ordered at Zaffiro s.
Consider ordering the pizza and baking it at home on a pizza stone at 450 degrees. That way you control when you eat it and can serve it right out of the oven.

Ranillo Rodriguez
Reviews 1

Got to try this amazing pizza in Milwaukee earlier this week. I was in search for the best pizza in the city, and it definitely lived up to the hype. I went on a Monday and tried their large 2 topping pizza special for 11 dollars. It was so worth it. If you are a fan of thin crust pizza, you must try it. I got my pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Quality ingredients and super fresh. I placed my order over the phone an hour before and it was ready when I got into town. Maybe the best thin crust I have ever tried. Definitely give them a try sometime!

Letitia A Walker
Reviews 1

This pizza knocks it out of the ball park. Monday night special check it out. Fresh toppings so many to choose from. There lasagna comes in a boat shaped dish which is loaded with cheese layers tender meat and the beast sauce around. Plenty of pasta choices. Fresh salads with great dressings to choose from. Lots of drink choices. Fabulous desserts. Come by soon and check them out. So good. Superior service everytime!

David Mouradian
Reviews 1

Whether visiting or a resident... You must visit this East Side Landmark! This Classic Italian Restaurant has remained at the top of the Best Pizza in the region for decades. It's signature crisp crust is best enjoyed within the space that has remained un- changed since opening decades agob (1954). Upon entering, you'll first be greeted by the original "Milwaukee" style bar. Diners can choose to eat at the beautiful wood & glass bar, or seated in the pizzaria style table & chairs in the comfortable dining room. Although street parking is often hard to find, there is a little known lot at the rear, enter alley, a half block East of Farwell, North of Brady. Look for the yellow Zaffiro's sign. Enjoy this classic location while you still can. As part of a arrangement with Marcus Corp., this location closes when the current operater passes away. Marcus Corp., which operates a Zaffrio's in many of their theater complexes, purchased this family run business, conceding to allow the family to operate the restarant as an independent operation, with little corporate interference.

Dave Shapiro
Reviews 1

Zaffiro's has been in business for more than 60 years. It is a cozy place with a dining room separate from the bar. Though they serve a variety of foods, it is the pizza for which they are best known. Zaffiro's has been listed as the 56th best pizza in the U.S. It is good pizza however, I think Scotty's Pizza is slightly better. (Both are very tasty with all fresh vegetables, etc., I just prefer Scotty's sauce a little more.) As this is the East Side, parking can be a problem - prepare to walk (unless you are very lucky.)

Jordan Kerr
Reviews 1

AC was broken, fan in dining room was broken, soda machine was broken, soda from can was old and flat. Moved ourselves outside to get a little breeze. Food came and croutons on salad were burnt, garlic pizza was Texas toast with garlic powder sprinkled on top and pizza was nothing short of mediocre. Our waitress was nice and that s the only reason this place gets one star. recommend by family and very disappointed. 0/10 would recommend....

Jack Vento
Reviews 1

The best pizza I've ever had. If you're one for ultra thin crust heaven, then this is the place for you. I've been here a couple times, and even on very busy nights like Valentine's day, the staff is working there butt off to make sure you're night runs smoothly. The last time we brought my crippled brother and the wait staff was very accommodating and helping in moving some stuff around for us. Thank you for that. The salads are great and this is a great place for families and couples, and even larger groups.

Craig Burbey
Reviews 1

This place deserves its legendary status as the best thin crust pizza in Brewtown. There are some mighty fine thin crust places in Milwaukee but this is my personal fave.Our favorite saturday afternoons have been starting at Scortinos,heading to Gloriosos and then finishing up at Zaffiros for the ultimate Italian death march.

Emily Hall
Reviews 1

Pizza was pretty good. Thought it could use more cheese but that's just a personal preference. The fried eggplant was delicious! Service was good, nothing over the top but she was efficient and didn't hover so that was nice. I'd like to try some non pizza items in the future!

Joel Buchanan
Reviews 1

Amazing pizza, great cheese bread and an amazing vintage atmosphere.

We came after we saw the sign saying they've been serving pizza for over 50 years and we hope they serve for many more.

The thin crust pizza came cut into squares (which is the only way thin crust tavern style pizza should be served). The house red was delicious and all of the beers were in bottles.

We will definitely be back!

Peter Naiman
Reviews 1

Excellent service with a great waiter & food was served very quickly, but I was very disappointed in the pie quality. Total lack of taste, probably less than quality ingredients, although my wife order her own and although she wasn't raving she was very happy. After owning a gourmet Pizzeria & making some of the best pies in this area my standards are high especially after coming from the East Coast from Boston with some of the best authentic Pizza made in Boston's Italian North End. I'll admit to being a bit spoiled. Sorry I'm just not a fan of thin crust Pizza. I'll give it a second try and hope for better.

Laura Pinkowski
Reviews 1

I ordered a lasagna dinner with salad and an Italian beef combo with au jus on the side since they don't dip it. When I got home no salad and no au jus sauce was in the bag. I called and picked up the missing items. When I got back home the italian beef with au jus was completely salty and couldn't even eat. I don't recommend the italian beef whatsoever.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Zaffiros

Address
1724 north farwell avenue