Login or sign up
For business

Windy City Dinner Fairy

4.9· 72 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.9/ 5

Based on 72 reviews

594%
46%
30%
20%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Windy City Dinner Fairy

Based on 72 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 6 days ago

Customers describe the recipes as easy to follow, straightforward, and delicious, with many noting that the results were a hit with their families and guests. Reviewers appreciate the creative concepts and the simplicity of the instructions, which often allow for minor ingredient swaps without affecting the outcome. The content is praised for being reliable and suitable for various occasions, from casual family treats to cocktail parties.
What is Windy City Dinner Fairy?

Windy City Dinner Fairy is a food & beverages listed on Trustburn. Windy City Dinner Fairy is a food blog created by Nicole, a classically trained pastry chef turned blogger and food stylist.

What is the official website of Windy City Dinner Fairy?

The official website of Windy City Dinner Fairy is windycitydinnerfairy.com.

How is Windy City Dinner Fairy rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Windy City Dinner Fairy has a rating of 4.9 out of 5 based on 72 reviews.

Is Windy City Dinner Fairy on social media?

Windy City Dinner Fairy has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Paula
Reviews 1

Windy City Dinner Fairy, thanks for the recipe! I tried it out tonight, though I had to swap in a different bourbon since my usual choice was out of stock. Honestly, it turned out so well that this is now my go-to bread pudding. I also decided to use croissants for a bit of extra flaky crunch on top, which worked perfectly. Delicious treat!

Beck
Reviews 1

Windy City Dinner Fairy’s recipe is a total hit, even if you don’t have easy access to their signature bourbon here in Canada. I found that mixing bourbon with Kahlua and aromatic bitters works beautifully as a substitute. It’s also a fantastic option for brunch, though the espresso flavor alone is worth the effort.

Mariah
Reviews 1

If you haven’t tried Windy City Dinner Fairy’s oatmeal chocolate chip cookies yet, you are missing out. They are absolutely delightful—crisp on the outside with a tender, warm center that never fails to impress. The best part? The recipe is straightforward enough for anyone to recreate at home. I love that they stay fresh and delicious even a day or two later, making them perfect for meal prep or sharing. They are always a hit at gatherings, and I find myself sending people directly to their website to get the scoop every time the recipe comes up.

Richard Kight
Reviews 1

The Windy City Dinner Fairy helped me transform simple leftovers into a real feast. I took leftover turkey, chopped it up fine, and swirled in my own homemade tomato paste instead of standard sauce. The result was absolutely great—comforting, fresh, and exactly what I needed.

jill
Reviews 1

I just tried Windy City Dinner Fairy for the first time last night and absolutely loved the results. I was so eager to taste them that I actually had one for breakfast, after letting them cool overnight. The flavor did not disappoint in the slightest—these are fantastic!

Kaye L Perry
Reviews 1

If you love cheesecake, you absolutely need to try the bars from Windy City Dinner Fairy. The blend of creamy cheesecake and snickerdoodle is just perfect. I’ve baked quite a few desserts, but these are hands down the best I’ve ever made. They’ve officially earned a spot in my top recipes.

Cassidy
Reviews 1

Windy City Dinner Fairy’s recipe was spot on, though I noticed the oven temperature wasn’t explicitly listed. I baked the meatballs at 425 degrees for 20 minutes, and they came out perfectly. I also simmered the tomatoes on the stovetop, which added a delicious flavor. Great find!

Amanda
Reviews 1

I whipped up the blackberry sauce for my Thanksgiving feast at home and it turned out absolutely divine. Since I couldn’t source the jam locally here in Luxembourg, I left it out, but the flavor still shone through. I’ll definitely be making this a holiday staple every year!

Kim Keener
Reviews 1

I whipped up this dish for the Super Bowl last year and it was an absolute smash. It’s incredibly straightforward to prepare, so I’m making it again for a Mulan watch party on Disney+. It’s definitely my go-to recipe when I want to impress guests at Windy City Dinner Fairy style.

Amy
Reviews 1

As a huge fan of Brussels sprouts who is constantly experimenting with recipes, I have to say these were a standout. They were so delicious that I didn't even miss the protein I usually serve them with. The interplay between the saltiness of the sprouts and the sweet reduction was truly incredible. Plus, they are incredibly easy to prepare, which is just the cherry on top. Windy City Dinner Fairy really knows how to do it right!

Katie Beck
Reviews 1

Windy City Dinner Fairy knocked it out of the park with this recipe. It was incredibly easy to follow and the result was both tasty and light. I was actually surprised to learn that Rum cream is a real ingredient! The instructions were so straightforward that anyone could do this. Definitely going to add this to our regular rotation.

Jocelyn
Reviews 1

I was thoroughly impressed by the quality from Windy City Dinner Fairy. I topped my batch with a dash of sea salt, and the result was absolutely perfect. Even though I followed the recipe exactly and noticed the cookies didn't spread as much as expected, it didn't detract from the flavor at all.

Lisa | Garlic & Zest
Reviews 1

Living in Chicago, I’m always on the lookout for culinary inspiration, and this post from Windy City Dinner Fairy is exactly the kind of tip I need. I have Brussels sprouts sitting in my fridge right now, and your balsamic reduction idea is the perfect solution. It’s a brilliant way to elevate the dish with those tangy notes and the goat cheese pairing. The charring on the sprouts looks fantastic—definitely giving it a try!

Megan
Reviews 1

Windy City Dinner Fairy nailed the flavor profile on this one. I based it on quinoa and added roasted zucchini, but honestly, the dressing is the star—it’s going straight into my weekly rotation for other salads. A total win and definitely coming back to this menu. Thanks for the great meal!

Bailey Johanson
Reviews 1

I was really happy with the flavor of my cookies, even though they didn’t spread as much as I expected. I suspect using old-fashioned oats—since that was all I had on hand—might be the reason. Still, it’s a solid recipe and a wonderful blog post. I agree with others who said I love how she gets straight to the point and shares tons of general baking tips. I’ll definitely be trying more recipes from Windy City Dinner Fairy in Chicago; maybe practice makes perfect!

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Windy City Dinner Fairy

Windy City Dinner Fairy is a food blog created by Nicole, a classically trained pastry chef turned blogger and food stylist. The site shares easy recipes and entertaining tips for home gatherings, featuring categories such as appetizers, charcuterie, cocktails, mains, salads, sides, soups, sweets, and seasonal dishes. It also offers recipe collections, a free email newsletter, and opportunities to work with Nicole through her services as a food stylist. The blog is based in Chicago and includes links to its social media profiles on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube.