Login or sign up
For business

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

5.0· 195 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
5.0/ 5

Based on 195 reviews

595%
45%
30%
20%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

Based on 195 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 6 days ago

Customers describe the blog as a reliable go-to source for various recipes, praising the clear, elegant, and easy-to-follow presentation style. Many readers appreciate the transparency regarding ingredients and find the instructions helpful for troubleshooting cooking issues, such as making yogurt or hard-boiled eggs. Some users also enjoy the nostalgic taste of the treats and the convenience of the site for finding simple cooking methods.
What is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz?

This Old Gal is a recipe and food blog run by Jill Selkowitz that shares homemade recipes with step-by-step instructions. The site organizes content by category, including low carb and keto dishes, holiday and seasonal meals, Jewish and Asian recipes, and dishes prepared using specific methods such as Instant Pot, pressure cooker, air fryer, and slow cooker. It also features a pressure cooker cookbook, kitchen tools, gift guides, and links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories.

What categories of recipes are available on the site?

The website organizes recipes by categories such as Keto/Low Carb, Appetizers/Drinks, Breads, Breakfast, Desserts, Main Courses, Soups, Side Dishes, and Casseroles. Additional seasonal categories include Rosh Hashanah, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Chanukkah, Christmas, New Year’s Eve, St. Patrick’s Day, Super Bowl/Game Day, Easter, Passover, 4th of July, Cinco de Mayo, and Memorial Day. Specific cooking methods like Instant Pot, Air Fryer, and Slow Cooker also have their own sections.

What products and resources can visitors purchase or explore?

Visitors can access a pressure cooker cookbook, shop for kitchen essentials, and browse a gift guide. The site includes links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories and offers a newsletter subscription. Additionally, there is a dedicated section for buying the cookbook and a page for working with the brand.

What do reviewers say about the potato salad recipes?

Several reviewers highlight that the potato salad has become a staple in their kitchens, with families enjoying it multiple times. Some users mention adding their own favorites like olives and radishes, while others note that the recipe serves as a great introduction to pressure cooking potatoes.

What do reviewers say about the holiday and seasonal recipes?

Reviewers mention that the site offers a wide range of holiday and seasonal recipes, including Super Bowl 2024 Instant Pot Party Food Recipes. These recipes are designed to help plan successful parties for guests.

What do reviewers say about the pressure cooker recipes?

Reviewers praise the pressure cooker recipes for their simplicity and effectiveness. Some users mention that the no-ice-bath method for hard-boiled eggs is particularly simple and effective, leading them to return to the site frequently.

What is the official website of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz?

The official website of This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz is thisoldgal.com.

How is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has a rating of 5 out of 5 based on 195 reviews.

Is This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz on social media?

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

bev pasquariello
Reviews 1

Loving the recipes from This Old Gal! I used Jill's pork rind crumbs for a family who typically eats breadcrumbs or torn-up bread in their meatloaf, and they absolutely loved it. These crumbs have no flavor of their own, which is perfect because they just act as a binder or breading. Great product!

Nicole
Reviews 1

After the 10-minute rest in my This Old Gal air fryer, should I remove the eggs immediately or let them sit inside until they’re cool enough to handle? I tried leaving them in the basket, but they were still too hot to touch. Even after moving them to a carton, they stayed warm for several minutes before I finally set them on the counter to cool down completely. The results were excellent, though—I’m just curious if I could have skipped the manual cooling step and let them rest in the appliance until fully cooled.

T. Rickard
Reviews 1

I was trying out a new technique in my air fryer, mostly breaking away from my usual go-to foods like tater tots and onion rings, and the results for hard-boiled eggs were genuinely impressive. It’s definitely going to be my preferred method going forward, even though I already own an electric egg cooker. If anyone knows where to find a trivet specifically designed for smaller air fryer models, let me know! Great find on this Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz.

Anita
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz has a winner here. I paired this recipe with fresh Pacific Northwest salmon, local honey, and a heavy dose of garlic to please my garlic-obsessed family. It was the perfect complement to a spicy bean dish and some leftover rice. We absolutely loved it!

Bill Dickhaus
Reviews 1

Delicious results from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz! I scaled up the recipe by 1.5 and used skirt steak, which provided plenty of leftovers for just two people. While the stir-fry was a hit, I’m already eyeing the pressure cooker version for my next attempt, and I plan to try the Pad Thai recipe next.

Leah G
Reviews 1

I whipped up this salmon recipe from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz tonight for my husband and five teenagers. It was incredibly easy to prepare. While I served mahi-mahi with a lemon-garlic-dill sauce to the others since that’s their usual preference, the salmon disappeared the fastest! I followed the recipe exactly without any changes and will definitely be making it again. Thanks for the great idea!

elizabeth joseph
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz provided a fantastic base that was easy to adapt to my taste. I swapped out some spices for garam masala, used ground coriander and smoked paprika, and skipped the bay leaf entirely since I wasn't a fan of it. I also peeled the eggplant to avoid the skin, which doesn't sit well with me, and cubed it fresh. Because I wanted more servings than the original recipe yielded, I added baby spinach and adjusted the fats with two tablespoons of ghee and a tablespoon of olive oil. The whole process took about twenty minutes from prep to plate, and the result was absolutely incredible. Thanks, Jill, for sharing such a delicious recipe!

Sandra Morrissey
Reviews 1

Jill, I just wanted to say that every single recipe from This Old Gal has been a success for me. It’s clear you’ve done your homework, and I really appreciate the detailed context you provide before I start cooking. I even picked up your cookbook! I do have a quick question for my friends who follow Weight Watchers. I’d love to make homemade yogurt for them, but I’m not sure which milk is best—should I go with 2% or whole milk? Also, does the fat content of the final yogurt matter, or is it better to use full-fat versus low-fat options? Any nutritional tips or info would be greatly appreciated.

Sandra Morrissey
Reviews 1

Jewel, I’ve found every recipe from This Old Gal to be perfectly reliable, and it’s clear you’ve done the research. I even have your cookbook and always take the time to read through your detailed notes before cooking. I’m planning to make fresh yogurt for my friends who follow Weight Watchers. Do you recommend using 2% or whole milk for this? Also, is there a way to access the nutritional information for your recipes?

PAM
Reviews 1

I’ve actually kept my Instant Pot brand new in the box since last year! But this looks like the perfect excuse to finally unbox it. I’m going to get my daughter to walk me through the steps so I can make the most of that ham waiting in the fridge. Thanks for a great holiday recipe from This Old Gal!

CHRISTINA DIBLASE
Reviews 1

Hi! I’m curious about the texture since I’m using a pressure cooker instead of traditional browning—will I miss that crust? Also, would it make a difference if I pan-fried the pieces first before pressure cooking? I get that four minutes is the target time since the meat is chopped, but I’m really aiming for that authentic Miami restaurant style. Thanks!

MaryIM
Reviews 1

I tried this chili recipe last night, which was actually my second time using my Instant Pot. It was also a huge milestone for me: at 60-something, it was the very first time I ever made chili from scratch! The result was great with plenty of flavor. I really appreciated the helpful tips from other users, especially the advice to cut back on the water. Thanks for sharing such an easy-to-follow recipe!

Mark Drexler
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz is a gem for holiday cooking! I brought the extended family over for Thanksgiving and tried this recipe—it was an instant hit. Everyone insisted I have to make it for Christmas too. I smoked the ham at 140F for two hours, then used a classic pressure cooker method: Coke and low for 15 minutes. Drizzling that leftover glaze over a slice was pure yum. Highly recommend for festive meals!

Barbara
Reviews 1

I’m eager to give this recipe a try since I’ve always enjoyed your other dishes. However, your site’s performance is becoming a real turn-off. The constant ads make the pages crawl to a halt, and the pop-ups really mess with the scrolling experience. It’s frustrating because I don’t have these issues on other blogs I follow, so I’ve actually started cutting back on my visits to This Old Gal, which is a shame because I love your content.

christine
Reviews 1

Jill’s pizza recipe is absolutely delicious! I have two quick questions though: does the dough freeze well for later, and is the batch supposed to yield two crusts or just one? Thanks again for the great instructions. As a New Yorker, I’ve always been on the hunt for a recipe that truly captures the flavor of those classic local pizzerias, and I think I’ve finally found it.

Linda in Rochester, NY
Reviews 1

That sounds delicious! I actually had turkey for dinner last night, so this is perfect timing. I’m planning to give the recipe a try, though I’ll swap the potato starch for cornstarch to get that nice crispy texture, since that’s what I usually use for Asian dishes.

Deborah Kozlowski
Reviews 1

I recently tried making wings in my air fryer using your recipe from This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz, and I was thrilled with the results. I loaded 12 wings into my 3.5-quart basket, making sure to shake and flip them every seven minutes since some pieces were stacked. By sticking exactly to your instructions, I ended up with the crispiest, most delicious wings I’ve ever had. Thank you for sharing such a fantastic recipe!

Sally Graeber
Reviews 1

I’ve been waiting for the right moment to make This Old Gal’s cranberry recipe, finally giving it a shot this morning. Even though I’m not usually a fan of cranberries, I was really impressed by the flavor—the sauce hits that perfect balance of tangy and sweet. The French bread was delicious, though mine ended up a bit undercooked in the middle. I wonder if that was due to the Pyrex dish I used or because I covered it with foil, since the original instructions don’t call for that. I’m thinking a bundt pan might give more even results next time. Thanks for sharing such a great recipe; it’s definitely going to be a holiday staple!

Cathy
Reviews 1

I was initially surprised that the recipe called for just two cups of broth, but when I made half the batch, I actually used four cups of chicken broth and it still turned out perfectly thick. The result was absolutely delicious—so good that I had to share it with all my non-keto family members at This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz.

Lauren
Reviews 1

That recipe from This Old Gal is a real winner. I tried it last night and absolutely loved the result. I ended up cutting the portion size in half, which turned out to be a regrettable move since I’m already missing some leftovers. Jill, thanks so much for sharing such a delicious find!

Susan Woodhouse
Reviews 1

I’m looking for some guidance. My husband gave me the Mini-Duo Instant Pot, which was a thoughtful gesture, but I’ve decided I need to upgrade to a larger model. I’m curious if your recipes in the book are designed to work seamlessly with a 6-quart pressure cooker?

Bart
Reviews 1

Another classic troll performance from you, Joan. It’s hilarious that you came to This Old Gal for free recipes and your immediate response was to attack the author. Does your life really revolve around finding strangers to insult? You’re basically hiding behind a screen just to get a reaction out of people. I doubt you have the nerve to say any of this to someone’s face. Your comment is insignificant and nobody really cares. You’re just a spiteful troll venting because you have nothing better to do. And nice try hiding, but I caught you posting almost the exact same thing months ago under the name Joe.

Susan Stokes
Reviews 1

This looks fantastic! I’m just double-checking the cooking time—is it really only 4 minutes? That seems surprisingly short compared to the usual 40-45 minutes I see for pork shoulder in the Instant Pot. I really appreciate the thorough research Jill does to bring us such tasty instant pot recipes. By the way, your sourdough bread recipe is absolutely terrific, too!

Paula
Reviews 1

I’ve been relying on This Old Gal’s recipes for months now. Since fresh blueberries are out of season, I improvised with Craisins and sautéed almonds, and the result was delicious. I also took the liberty of toasting the oats in butter, which added a wonderful depth. Interestingly, I often prepare this dish the day after making Greek yogurt, using a mix of half whey and half whole milk. The subtle tang from the whey perfectly balances the sweetness of the Craisins, making it a standout dish in Jill Selkowitz’s collection.

Heather
Reviews 1

I’ve turned to This Old Gal’s wings recipe twice now, and they are always a hit. For my first batch, I followed the standard instructions, but today I adjusted the flavor profile by cutting the hot sauce in half and adding two tablespoons of brown sugar. Both versions were absolutely delicious. Big thanks to Jill Selkowitz for such great recipes!

Samir Parekh
Reviews 1

I’m planning to make a big batch of these treats and stash half of them in my freezer! They look absolutely delicious. Could you share how long they keep frozen? Also, do you have any tips on when to take them out before serving so they don’t end up like hard lollipops? I’m worried the chocolate coating might get soft and runny if I thaw them out. Should I just leave them in the fridge instead? Thanks for any advice!

Cheryl
Reviews 1

We absolutely enjoyed This Old Gal’s recipe for dinner last night! It yielded generous leftovers for lunch, which was a huge bonus. I paired it with steamed veggies and swapped the Chinese wine for gin to keep things low-carb. Really appreciate Jill for sharing such a delicious and adaptable dish.

Paula
Reviews 1

This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz always delivers reliable recipes, and this one is no exception. It’s delicious, and I love customizing it with Craisins and a handful of sliced almonds. I prep it right before bed, so coming downstairs to find breakfast ready while I shower and get dressed is so convenient. Since I’m the only hot cereal eater in the house, I divide it into one bowl and three fridge containers, giving me four easy days of breakfast. Truly delightful!

Vicki
Reviews 1

Jill, that single star review tells us almost nothing about how the latke recipe actually turned out. You acknowledged the symbolism of frying them, which is fine, but what really matters is the result. Was the flavor good? Did they have a nice crisp exterior or were they soggy in the middle? Did they need more time in the pan, extra salt, or perhaps a different starch? Leaving just a rating without those details feels unhelpful. To balance out your score, I’m leaving five stars.

Stephanie
Reviews 1

I made a dough using a single flour type, and the result was surprisingly good. The only hiccup was that it felt too loose to form into a ball, so I kneaded in a bit more flour before popping it in the fridge overnight. That step did the trick—the crust came out with a perfect chew and crispy edges. Even though I’m a beginner baker and still figuring out the right measurements, I’m thrilled with how it turned out and will definitely use This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz’s method again.

Maxine
Reviews 1

Jill, these dishes look absolutely delicious! I’m a huge fan of your recipes and really appreciate the helpful tips you share for getting the most out of your Instant Pot creations. I’ve already pre-ordered your cookbook and am eagerly counting down the days until it arrives. Thanks so much for all the inspiration you provide!

Jennifer Lee
Reviews 1

My niece and nephews absolutely loved this treat during their recent visit. Their verdict? It tastes exactly like a real Oreo cheesecake. The kids devoured two slices each, and I had to finish the rest to keep them from eating too much sugar. Definitely a winner!

Linda
Reviews 1

I’ve been using This Old Gal’s blends with great results—adding brown sugar and a splash of Chinese rice wine really elevates the flavor. If you’re short on time, you can skip the oven: just brown the meat in a skillet, add the dry packet, and let it do its thing in the slow cooker on high.

sonya
Reviews 1

So happy I stumbled upon This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz! My air fryer has been working overtime since I got it a few months ago. I really appreciate not dealing with pouring out excess grease and oil. The recipes are so practical, using ingredients I can easily find at the local market or that I already have in my pantry. I’m still on the lookout for a good cookbook that’s designed for everyday folks like us.

Colleen
Reviews 1

I made this recipe for my family and they loved it. To work around what I had on hand, I swapped the wine for unsweetened apple juice and used corn in place of peas. I also added some pre-cooked chopped chicken and cheese to bulk it up. The instructions were mostly clear, though I did get a bit confused when the printables didn't mention reserving some carrots to add at the end—that tip was helpful once I checked the post again. Thanks, Jill, for sharing this adaptable dish on This Old Gal!

Jutta Holden
Reviews 1

We are definitely making this again soon! I ended up with plenty of leftover fish and shrimp from the roughly 3 pounds I bought. I didn’t realize the recipe served as a one-pound portion until I saw a customer ask about it earlier. I forgot to add the cream, but we enjoyed the dish so much that I’m now wondering if I’ll even need it next time. Also, I used dry sherry—was that the right choice? Thanks again for the fantastic recipe from This Old Gal.

Bobbie
Reviews 1

Hi Jill, I really enjoy your recipes on This Old Gal! I did notice a small oversight in this one: milk is listed in the ingredients, but it isn't mentioned in the instructions where it should be added. I assume it goes with the eggs, but it would be helpful if that step was explicitly stated.

Lisa
Reviews 1

This Old Gal’s recipes really hit the spot for our family. The boys absolutely loved this one, marking it for the “keep and make again” list. We swapped in 4 oz of medium green chilies for some great heat and used black beans in place of the red ones since that’s what was on hand—the result was fantastic. You’ll get six filling servings, and don’t forget to top it with fresh avocado slices!

Amy
Reviews 1

I just tried this recipe and it was delicious! I made it in a 7-inch pan and added extra butter to the crust, using all seven graham crackers. I also did exactly what the instructions said not to do: I put it back in the oven and cooked it longer. I’d recommend adding 10 minutes to the cooking time next time. But yes, I will definitely be making it again!

Noreen Quintal
Reviews 1

Jill, a pro tip for anyone cooking Greek food: definitely swap in Greek or Mediterranean oregano. It makes a huge difference in capturing that authentic taste compared to the Mexican or Italian varieties I keep on hand. I’m usually the type to make my own ravioli and tortellini from scratch, but your posts are so convincing that I’m actually tempted to just grab some pre-made ones for a quick salad this time.

Amy
Reviews 1

I was worried the mix of lemon juice and vinegar in This Old Gal’s recipe would be too sharp, but it turned out perfectly balanced. My children really enjoyed it, which is always a win. I swapped in shell pasta, which required an additional three minutes under pressure to cook through. Thanks for sharing this great recipe!

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About This Old Gal by Jill Selkowitz

This Old Gal is a recipe and food blog run by Jill that shares homemade recipes with step-by-step instructions. The site organizes content by category, including low carb and keto dishes, holiday and seasonal meals, Jewish and Asian recipes, and dishes prepared using specific methods such as Instant Pot, pressure cooker, air fryer, and slow cooker. The site also features a pressure cooker cookbook, kitchen tools, gift guides, and links to an Amazon storefront for cooking accessories. Additional sections include contact information, privacy and cookie policies, and terms and conditions.