Login or sign up
For business

The Recipe Critic

4.7· 1,377 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.7/ 5

Based on 1,377 reviews

579%
49%
34%
24%
14%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about The Recipe Critic

Generated with AI from 1,377 reviews on Trustburn · updated 25 days ago

Customers generally describe the site as a gem and a staple in their kitchens, praising the weekly meal planners and side dish suggestions for making cooking easier and more efficient.
What does The Recipe Critic do?

The Recipe Critic is a website that functions as a recipe blog, publishing content for dinners, soups, desserts, and other dishes.

Are there any complaints about The Recipe Critic?

The critical reviewers wrote that some dishes turned out tough, overly soupy, or tasteless, and one reviewer noted that an ingredient mix gave a meal an artificial flavor.

What do people say about The Recipe Critic outside Trustburn?

People outside Trustburn discuss the site's recipes on Reddit, noting that some dishes are easy and hit the target flavor of restaurant meals, while others are used for quick weeknight dinners or adapted for specific dietary needs.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Jen
Reviews 1

I am a big fan of The Recipe Critic, and this dish has become a regular staple in my kitchen. I’ve adapted it slightly to suit my taste: I dice the andouille sausage into very small pieces to keep the heat level manageable. I also skip the browning step since the sausage is already fully cooked, which saves me a bit of time and effort. Even with these shortcuts, the result is consistently delicious.

Linda
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed this recipe and paired it with mashed potatoes and a fresh salad—it was delicious! I’m so happy I discovered The Recipe Critic. The weekly meal planner and the suggested side dishes for each main course make cooking so much easier and more efficient.

mrs.dowler
Reviews 1

I was actually quite disappointed with this result from The Recipe Critic. While the final photo was very appetizing, the dish itself missed the mark. The onion soup mix gave the meal an overly artificial flavor that really stood out. I’ve never cooked with that ingredient before, so I wasn’t sure what to expect, but this experience definitely taught me to avoid it in the future.

Brenda
Reviews 1

As a 48-year-old cooking enthusiast who relies heavily on online resources, I finally decided to leave my first-ever comment here. The chicken recipe at The Recipe Critic is absolutely spot-on. It is the only method I use for chicken breasts now because the meat comes out juicy every time, never dry. I’ve already passed this gem on to several friends. Thank you for sharing!

Kim Lippy
Reviews 1

For the best Antipasto Salad experience at The Recipe Critic, try layering your veggies, cheeses, and dressing at the bottom of the bowl first, then topping with torn romaine. Keep them separate until serving time so the greens don’t turn soggy too soon. If you do mix it up, eat it immediately—leftovers usually don’t hold up well the next day.

Emily Clemente
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic hit the nail on the head with this chicken breast recipe. My husband, who usually avoids white meat, was so impressed by how tender and flavorful it was that he asked why I don’t make it more often. It was also super simple to prepare, so it’s definitely going into my regular rotation.

Stony
Reviews 1

As a huge fan of The Recipe Critic, I have to say this dish is right up there with my absolute favorites like gumbo and crab bisque. Alyssa’s version feels incredibly similar to how I prepare it at home, though I usually top mine with fresh tomatoes, lettuce, and cheese. It’s a truly yummy soup.

Irene
Reviews 1

I tried this dish from The Recipe Critic for the first time last night and it was absolutely delicious! Since it’s just me and my partner, I made half the batch. I also swapped a few ingredients to fit what I had in the pantry—using mild Italian sausage instead of ground beef, and swapping water for beef broth with some Better Than Bouillon for extra depth. It’s definitely going into my regular rotation.

Holly
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic never disappoints! This is a fantastic, stress-free recipe. I tweaked the method slightly by browning the ground meat on its own before introducing the garlic and ginger puree. Since I didn’t have low-sodium ingredients on hand, I adjusted the sauce components to about a tablespoon each of soy sauce and brown sugar to keep the sweetness in check. I also elevated the flavor profile by whisking in a splash of red wine, rice wine vinegar, Korean chili flakes, and a touch of hoisin sauce, pouring it all over once the aromatics were heated. To finish, I added green onions, toasted sesame seeds, and a dash of sesame oil. Served over jasmine rice topped with furikake and accompanied by edamame, this meal was a hit with my husband and daughter. We’re definitely making it again!

Mickey
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic really hit the mark with this one! I whipped up the Spinach and Mushroom Fettuccine Alfredo for my daughter and her vegetarian boyfriend last night, relying on your sauce recipe. Everyone absolutely loved the meal, and it was incredibly simple to make. I’m definitely sticking with your recipes from here on out—thank you!

Lesley
Reviews 1

I was really let down by The Recipe Critic’s London broil. Even though I followed the instructions and marinated the meat for 17 hours, it turned out incredibly tough. It was so tough that my husband actually struggled to chew some of the pieces! I was excited for a nice Sunday dinner, but that didn’t happen.

Heather
Reviews 1

The flavors in The Recipe Critic’s dish are definitely there, but the final result was quite oily. I noticed the sauce kept separating in the slow cooker, no matter how often I stirred. I followed the instructions to keep the bacon grease for searing and added the other ingredients later, without draining it. I also skipped cubing the meat, using a bottom chuck roast instead and letting it fall apart, and thickened it with all-purpose flour in the pan. Since the recipe didn’t specify draining the grease, I’m not sure if that’s where I went wrong. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

Kasondra
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic’s Alfredo sauce is hands down my new go-to. I tweaked the standard ratio by doubling the batch and swapping in a mix of heavy cream and milk since I was low on cream. It needed a bit of thickening, so a cornstarch slurry at the end did the trick. Truly delicious.

LaLa
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic nailed the ratios on this jalapeño poppers recipe, fixing the issues I often run into when improvising. It’s a solid base that lets you customize the heat to your liking; I prefer a kickier popper, so I leave the ribs intact while still removing the seeds. A reliable go-to for a perfect result.

Katie R
Reviews 1

I made The Recipe Critic’s dish using my usual generous amount of spices, cherry tomatoes, and bouillon instead of broth, cooking it low for about ten hours. The chicken was incredibly tender, falling apart with ease, and the sauce was packed with flavor. I served it alongside rice made with bouillon to soak up every bit of that delicious sauce.

Lindsey
Reviews 1

Shoppers at The Recipe Critic often look for ways to sneak more veggies into their meals, and adding a pre-diced mix of carrots, onions, and celery is a great trick. I use this blend instead of plain onions, and it works perfectly—the meatballs stay intact while remaining tender and full of flavor.

Eileen Maringo
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic served up a simple yet flavorful dish that felt like a warm hug. While the seasoning was generally spot-on, I recommend dialing back the salt slightly to suit your personal taste. Paired with some cheesy garlic bread, it made for a truly hearty and comforting meal.

Dalton Miller
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic delivers on its promise with this exceptional steak. The sear created a fantastic crust while the inside stayed perfectly pink and medium-rare. I appreciate the garlic butter and herb blend that complemented the meat beautifully. Even though I seared the steak briefly before air frying, the result was absolutely delicious.

Chad Cox
Reviews 1

I’m a devoted follower of The Recipe Critic and have prepared this dish countless times, often with my own small tweaks. It’s become a family favorite! Since I’m known as a foodie, my friends know that anything I share from therecipecritic.com is genuinely good—so I recommend it constantly. I usually boost the protein with a bit more meat, toss in some steamed broccoli, and scale the sauce up by half. It’s a guaranteed crowd-pleaser. Thanks for the great content!

J.J. Mann
Reviews 1

Huge fan of The Recipe Critic! Alyssa, your collection of delicious posts is always a hit. The Stuffed Cabbage Soup is a total game-changer for chilly weekend evenings. I highly recommend stirring in some sliced Serrano or Jalapeno peppers for a nice kick—they’re packed with Vitamin C, too, which is great for boosting immunity during the colder months. Just taste-test the peppers raw first to get your desired level of heat right, then cook them into the soup. The result is absolutely incredible!

Karen
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic has a knack for creating dishes that truly impress. I first tried this salad at an Italian-themed luncheon where it stole the show with its vibrant colors and fresh taste. It was so popular that everyone asked for the recipe. I’ve been making it repeatedly since July—it’s easily become a summer staple for me.

Nancy
Reviews 1

I am a big fan of chicken piccata, and this recipe from The Recipe Critic really delivered. I did encounter a minor sauce issue, likely due to the pan being too hot and the cream being cold, but it was still delicious. I made a few adjustments to suit my taste: I added sautéed mushrooms and thickened the sauce with a cornstarch slurry. The result was a rich, velvety dish that I will definitely be making again. Thanks for the great inspiration!

Catherine Buckner
Reviews 1

I put The Recipe Critic’s dish in the cooker and cranked up the heat, tossing it in between broil cycles instead of frying it in oil. I cooked some non-GMO rice alongside it and sneaked in a handful of mushrooms for extra flavor, finishing with fresh green onions. The whole family absolutely loved it!

Chenoa Peterson
Reviews 1

I’m thrilled I stumbled upon The Recipe Critic for this dish. I’d been searching for that specific flavor from a favorite restaurant that has since closed, and this recipe captured it perfectly. Thanks for sharing! I can’t wait to cook it for my loved ones tomorrow.

Sunshine
Reviews 1

As someone who usually sticks to basic meals, I was thrilled to serve this at our election day potluck. It was a huge hit with my coworkers—there wasn’t a single bite left, and I even had to share the recipe! The only tweak I’d suggest is cutting back on the salt, since the soup base already adds quite a bit of flavor. Overall, a total success that really boosted my confidence in the kitchen.

Laura
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic nails the concept, but I had to adjust the measurements. We followed the instructions exactly, yet the Italian seasoning was way overpowering. I’m pretty sure the recipe meant 1 teaspoon instead of a full tablespoon. I’ll definitely give it another shot with the reduced amount to see if it balances out better.

Patti Berent
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic provided a fantastic base for a quick weeknight meal. I used their cheese sauce for a rotisserie chicken noodle casserole, combining it with shell pasta, green onions, and chopped bell peppers. To finish it off, I topped the mixture with crispy bacon and a Ritz cracker crust made with melted butter. The sauce was quite thick, so I adjusted the consistency by adding extra milk, seasoning with salt, pepper, and a dash of cayenne for some heat. I opted for Sharp Cheddar and Monterey Jack, but I can easily see how Gruyere with a bit of stone-ground mustard would work wonders as a pretzel dip. It’s a versatile recipe that adapts well to different tastes, and I’m excited to see how it turns out!

Jenny Tatum
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic nailed it with this Alfredo sauce. I’m thrilled with how it turned out, especially since it was my first time making it from scratch. If you’re looking to elevate the taste, a dash of onion powder adds a wonderful depth. Highly recommend giving this recipe a try!

KimS
Reviews 1

I recently tried these bratwursts in my air fryer and was genuinely impressed by the results. The texture was fantastic, and the sausages turned out perfectly cooked. I also toasted the buns for the last minute, which was the perfect touch. It’s a simple method, but it really works and gives you confidence to try it. Highly recommended!

Rebecca M
Reviews 1

I’m with The Recipe Critic to say that this meal is a total hit—my husband swears it beats any takeout. The one caveat is the timing; my beef cooks surprisingly fast, usually done in just three hours on low. If I let it go for the full six, it turns out completely overcooked.

LaLa
Reviews 1

As a regular follower of The Recipe Critic, I usually trust their instructions implicitly. I decided to attempt their lemony chicken piccata with capers over angel hair pasta. The concept seemed solid, but I was skeptical about the technique: adding cream to hot chicken broth and lemon juice seemed prone to curdling. I followed the video step-by-step, yet the sauce split immediately. Even a补救ative dash of cornstarch failed to bring it back together. It’s frustrating when a tried-and-true method from The Recipe Critic doesn’t hold up under the heat.

Valencia
Reviews 1

As a sugar-loving teen, I found The Recipe Critic’s take on this dessert spot on. It’s a clever hack for using up those nearly overripe bananas. Since neither my mom nor I are huge fans of cooked fruit (apples aside), I adapted the recipe by swapping in just one cup of strawberries and two bananas. Naturally, this cut back on the flavor profile a bit, but the core concept held up well. It’s a solid, fun idea that I’d definitely try again to get rid of excess strawberries and bananas.

Carrie
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic’s recipe is spot on. I used up leftover chicken and rice, and adding frozen mixed veggies made the whole dish ready in no time. My husband and one daughter were so impressed they joked about eating it three times a week—that’s high praise coming from them!

Amy R Feise
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed the clarity of the instructions and the appetizing photos from The Recipe Critic. The potato texture was spot-on, achieving that ideal creamy consistency. However, the seasoning fell flat and lacked flavor. It’s a shame because the base recipe is so good; I’ll definitely double or triple the spice amounts next time, and I’ll try using fresh herbs instead of dried ones when possible.

Shelly
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed this dish, especially after swapping in ground turkey. The sauce had a nice rich flavor, though I did notice it was a bit salty—luckily, I remembered not to add salt to my pasta water, which balanced things out perfectly. I made it with whole milk instead of cream since my mom can’t have dairy, but it still turned out delicious. Thanks, The Recipe Critic, for the great tip!

Ree
Reviews 1

As a regular visitor to The Recipe Critic, I’ve generally had great results from their collection. However, this particular dish didn’t quite hit the mark for our tastes, possibly due to the vinegar balance. I followed the instructions to the letter, so it wasn’t a user error. Still, I appreciate the variety they offer and enjoy testing their new creations!

Rachel Knight
Reviews 1

I’ve been cooking this Alfredo sauce from The Recipe Critic for years, and it remains my absolute favorite. For a richer flavor, I swap the garlic powder for three or four cloves of minced garlic. I also love adding a dash of Pepper Palace’s French Quarter Cajun seasoning and finishing it with fresh green onions. If you’re looking for a top-tier sauce, I highly recommend giving this recipe a try.

Shasta
Reviews 1

Absolutely loved this dish! I tweaked the recipe based on other reviewers' tips and my own preferences. Instead of sun-dried tomatoes, I added six fresh cherry tomatoes. I also boosted the flavor with four minced garlic cloves, plus a teaspoon each of garlic and onion powder. Since I’m lactose intolerant, I swapped in two cans of coconut milk and a tablespoon of chicken bouillon powder for depth. I skipped the spinach entirely and let everything simmer for three hours, thickening it with a bit of cornstarch at the end. The result was incredible—my picky husband loved it too, even without knowing the exact ingredients! Such a success. 🥰

Noah P
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic really nailed this classic. While I love the base recipe, I like to spice it up by stirring in sun-dried tomatoes and fresh spinach midway through. It works perfectly—the greens wilt just right and the tomatoes heat up without losing their flavor. A solid go-to for Alfredo.

Hirsch
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic has some solid ideas. I actually cooked this dish last year after seeing it in a meme. Even though I’m not typically a huge crack fan, this version was incredibly addictive, especially since I went ahead and added extra bacon to the mix. It’s a great meal for a guy who, like me, is tired of eating alone and wants to spend more time in the kitchen.

Melanie B.
Reviews 1

Making this dish for the second time and it’s a hit again! I swapped in half-and-half and thickened it with cornstarch, and the result was just as delicious. It’s super easy to whip up at The Recipe Critic. If you’re looking for a high-quality meal that won’t break the bank, I highly recommend giving this one a try.

Katherine
Reviews 1

At The Recipe Critic, we know that mastering a custard is all about technique. Don’t skip roasting the asparagus to avoid excess moisture from blanching, which can make the filling watery. For a richer texture, stick to a ratio of six eggs to 1.5 cups of half-and-half rather than the standard four-to-two with cream. Also, remember to scald your dairy before mixing it with eggs to help the custard set properly without turning runny. If you prefer, you can start the bake at a higher heat for the first 15 minutes before lowering the temperature to finish cooking.

Bonnie
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed the flavor of my order from The Recipe Critic, but the structural integrity wasn’t quite there. Despite confirming doneness with a clean toothpick after multiple checks, the cake sank significantly, ending up about two-thirds of its original height. The taste is great, so hopefully, it was just a one-off baking issue.

A. D. Watts
Reviews 1

I swapped out the lemon for lime juice to add a bit of zest. I was pleasantly surprised by how the egg and oil emulsified into such a light, airy consistency. I stirred in a touch of sugar to balance the flavor, and the result was still a spotless batch of mayonnaise. Thanks for the great base!

Sarah
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic really nailed this one. It’s become my absolute go-to whenever I’m hosting a crowd, and I’m usually doubling or even tripling the quantities because the first batch disappears so fast. I love getting creative with it, too—last time I threw in some asparagus for a nice crunch, and it was a hit. It’s consistently the star of every potluck I bring it to.

Sandy Souter
Reviews 1

I tried a recipe from The Recipe Critic and wasn't happy with the result. Even though I followed the instructions exactly, the cake failed to rise. Next time, I’d definitely split the batter into two pans instead of using just one, as I ended up discarding the whole thing.

Kathy
Reviews 1

The Recipe Critic never disappoints! I tried this dish for dinner and the whole family enjoyed it. It’s super simple to whip up. I made a slight tweak by adding the flour slowly to the liquid mix after the butter melted since I forgot the original step, and it turned out perfectly fine after letting it simmer to thicken. Definitely a keeper—I’ll be cooking this again!

Lori
Reviews 1

Alyssa, I’m a huge fan of The Recipe Critic and have nailed your dishes time and time again. I do have one tiny tweak for this specific meatball recipe, though. Being raised with Swedish heritage, I know that authentic Swedish meatballs traditionally skip the garlic entirely, relying instead on allspice and nutmeg for that classic flavor. I absolutely love garlic in most of my cooking, but it just doesn’t belong in this particular dish. That said, your version is still a solid five stars; I’ll just omit the garlic to keep it true to tradition. Thanks!

K
Reviews 1

I’ve completely switched to air frying my corn, and I never want to go back to the old methods. Boiling always left it soggy and bland, while the oven or grill tended to dry it out or strip away that natural juiciness. I actually stopped eating corn for years until I got this air fryer and found The Recipe Critic’s guide. It’s been a game-changer. I followed the instructions exactly the first time and it was perfect; lately, I’ve been experimenting with different spices, and it still turns out amazing every single time. I usually toss the cobs around in the basket, but I’m sure just letting them sit would work too. I used my hands to rub on oil before seasoning, which I think is key. I read the comments and agree that adding butter after cooking makes a much bigger difference than cooking it in butter. While I’m still watching my intake, this is now my go-to method. I looked at other recipes, but their temperatures seemed too high. This one strikes the perfect balance—fully cooked, gently roasted, and packed with flavor. The photos sold me, and the result lives up to the hype: juicy, flavorful, and absolutely no wateriness. Five stars!

CINDY LOUISE VANDERZALM
Reviews 1

I was so impressed with The Recipe Critic that I had to make it again immediately. I doubled the batch and cooked it in my 15-inch cast iron skillet. The result was an enormous, perfectly puffed dish that everyone absolutely loved. Thanks for the great recipe!

Jordan
Reviews 1

My picky son is totally obsessed with The Recipe Critic’s version of this dish—it’s definitely his top choice. I bake it regularly, whether weekly or bi-weekly, swapping out low-sodium soy sauce for regular soy sauce thinned with water to keep the flavor just right.

Sylvia
Reviews 1

As The Recipe Critic would surely agree, this recipe is a winner! It turned out perfectly on my very first attempt. I even added a splash of vanilla for extra flavor. For my second batch, I wanted to cut down on the calories, so I swapped half the sugar for monk fruit and replaced half the butter with applesauce. The result was just as good.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About The Recipe Critic

The Recipe Critic is a website that publishes recipes for dinners, soups, desserts, and other dishes. The site appears to function as a recipe blog, organizing content into various ad slot placements around recipes and editorial content. Based on the available text, it serves as an online resource for finding recipes across multiple meal categories.