Generated with AI from 10 reviews on Trustburn · updated 16 days ago
Customers frequently describe The Polo Grill as an upscale fine dining restaurant with consistently excellent food, attentive service, and a relaxing atmosphere, with several mentioning memorable experiences with dishes like shrimp and grits, filet mignon, and gazpacho.
What are the most common complaints about The Polo Grill?
The most common complaint in the available reviews relates to inconsistent steak preparation, with one reviewer reporting their medium-rare steak came out well-done, then overly rare and cold, and feeling a manager should have addressed the issue.
I don't hand out 5 star ratings, but this is a 5 star experience through and through. Want to impress *insert name of whoever you want to impress*? Take them here for any meal. I typically get the choose two, grilled cheese and tomato bisque (be sure to get the apple wood bacon added to the grilled cheese). Everything is well prepared, including the drinks. The service is essentially a pampering.
It is priced at exactly what you would expect for food and service of this quality, so be prepared for that.
Missed the mark! Should have stopped at appetizer and went straight to dessert. Order steak medium rare. First one came out well done, second time overly rare actually cold in the middle. Third time correct, by then the rest of us were thru with our meal. Our waiter apologized and was nice about it. Personally, I feel a manager should have addressed the issue. Maybe offer to buy my sons beer while he waited. Not the Polo Grill I have been used to in the past.
I cant remember the martini I had but it was excellent! I come here for the bacon wrapped lime shrimp (see togo container with shrimp swimming in lime butter). Their salads and other entrees are excellent as well, I ve had the shrimp, salmon, NY, chopped salad and a few other items just can t remember at the moment.
Polo Grill may be the most consistently excellent fine dining restaurant in Tulsa for decades. The remodel during the pandemic is a classic look. Monday I tried shrimp and grits...risky since we aren't anywhere near NOLA. It was awesome!
Schmancy! My wife and I went here for our collective birthday dinners. We were sat outside, right next to the door, and at first it was a little too bustling. We were at a tiny, slanted table, in the middle of everyone s coming and going. We ordered the chef s tasting menu, and once the food started coming, things started to get more interesting. We also got the wine pairing, which added a nice touch. The chef came out and spoke with us, and they gave us a complimentary bottle of wine. Finally, after an hour or so, the restaurant started to slow down, and it felt a little more private and intimate.
Reserved a private dining room. Awesome. Filet mignon and risotto was excellent. Chef came and talked too us, bonus points. Pear martini was too good. Japanese whiskey selection on point. 10/10
Food is delicious and service is excellent. Tyler was our server and he took such great care of us!! We went for my birthday and can't wait to go back!
A recent patio visit to celebrate as friend s birthday was served by very attentive waitstaff. Salads were beautifully presented. Other menu choices would satisfy a discriminating palate. Given the current epidemic, Polo s Patio makes for a wonderful dining experience.
Pro: Relaxing upper scale atmosphere. Many staff members wore a coat to keep up the atmosphere.
Menu was diverse to fit the atmosphere and most pallets. Pricing was comfortable, on the upper side to fit the atmosphere and location.
No Guinness!!! Not a large beer selection
Ordered Gazpacho Soup. Wow fantastic!!!!!!!!!! Now that's Gazpacho! Who seemed to be the owner noticed we ordered the Gazpacho Soup and walked from the bar to offer a twist to the soup . His suggestion was awesome if we accepted but my wife declined. I think other's may want to give it a try...I won't reveal the secret sauce he suggested, just mention you read about his offer to "spice up" the soup.
Con: We decided to sit at the tables by the bar. If your long legged, do not . The seat back had no contour or pitch and left us both VERY uncomfortable. Maybe we should have had the owner sit with us for a long period .
In summary, will we return? Yes! But we'd sit at a table or booth.
Welcome to polo grill ! Placed in beautiful Utica square is a fancy upscale joint that has served Tulsa for so long. The food here is excellent to say the least for sure. Very big selection of wine and cocktails to get you nice and relaxed. Jesus was our server and did a fantastic job taking care of our group. Very knowledgeable and didn't miss a step. Loved every minute here and I'm sure you will too. Enjoy! Support your local restaurants and servers!
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
Widgets
Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.