Reservoir Restaurant INC

Reservoir Restaurant INC is a family-owned restaurant located at 106 West South Orange Avenue in South Orange, New Jersey. Founded by Vincenza Agnellino in 1935, it is known for serving the original pizza pie and has been a favorite for over 90 years. The restaurant offers a menu featuring homemade ravioli, veal cutlets, and daily specials alongside its famous tomato pie.

The restaurant claims to be one of the first places to make 'tomato pie,' which is now known as pizza. They earned the name 'Home of the Original Pizza Pie' through their delicious tomato pie, which they have been serving since 1935.

The rating split shows a mix of experiences, with several 5-star reviews praising the scrumptious food and excellent service, while some 3-star reviews noted average service and slow waitstaff. The presence of both high and lower ratings suggests variable experiences depending on the visit.

Customers can order from a menu that includes appetizers like Zuppa Di Clams, salads such as the Tony Salad, and various pizzas. The restaurant accepts cash or check only, as no credit cards are accepted for payment.

The restaurant has been operating since 1935, celebrating 90 years of service. It relocated to its current location in South Orange, NJ, in 1965, but has maintained the same recipe for its famous pizza since its founding.

The restaurant offers catering for large or small parties and can seat up to 45 people in its private party room. For dining, they operate on specific lunch and dinner hours, with Tuesday being completely closed.

Some reviewers praised the staff's attention to detail and friendly demeanor, while others mentioned slow and inattentive waitstaff. One reviewer specifically loved the dessert selection, calling it a hidden gem.

Lunch is served from 11:30 am to 2:30 pm on most days, while dinner runs from 4:00 pm to 8:30 pm on weekdays and later on weekends. Sunday dinner starts at 3:00 pm and ends at 8:30 pm.

The menu includes items like Chicken Murphy, Rigatoni a la Jake, and the Bernstein Salad with sausage. Pizza options range from cheese to a 'Super Mushrooms' combo with multiple toppings.

Appetizers start at $23.95 for Zuppa Di Clams, while salads range from $4.50 for a small salad to $24.95 for a Bernstein Salad with sausage. Pizza prices vary based on the crust and toppings, with extra cheese costing $16.75.

The business can be reached by phone at (973) 762-9795 or (973) 763-1488. The address is 106 West South Orange Avenue, South Orange, NJ 07079.

Visitors might wonder about the variety of the menu, given its history of having a small menu that included homemade ravioli and veal cutlets. They may also question whether the restaurant is suitable for groups, considering its capacity to seat up to 45 people in a private room.

The restaurant's history as a family favorite for three generations implies a strong tradition and consistency in their recipes. The fact that it was named the 'leader in reader recommendations' by The Star Ledger's Munch Mobile indicates a positive reputation in the local community.

The restaurant provides catering services for parties of various sizes and has a private party room. They also offer a summer special starting in July, featuring two plain pizzas for $20.26 on Wednesdays only.

Customers can visit during the specified lunch or dinner hours, place their order from the menu, and pay with cash or check. After dining, they can leave feedback, as evidenced by the numerous reviews on Trustburn.