Login or sign up
For business

Preppy kitchen

4.9· 375 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.9/ 5

Based on 375 reviews

586%
410%
33%
21%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Preppy kitchen

Generated with AI from 375 reviews on Trustburn · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally praise the recipes for being reliable, delicious, and easy to follow, with many noting that the baked goods turn out fantastic and moist.
What does Preppy kitchen do?

Preppy Kitchen is a brand created by an LA native that provides sweet and savory baking recipes for items like cakes, desserts, and drinks.

Are there any complaints about Preppy kitchen?

The critical reviewers wrote that one recipe's dough failed to rise and became like a brick, another reviewer found the frosting too sweet, and a third noted that a buttercream recipe turned out grainy.

What do people say about Preppy kitchen outside Trustburn?

People outside Trustburn discuss using Preppy Kitchen recipes for items like lemon cheesecake, shortbread, and pound cake, while also comparing them to other baking resources.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Tammy Bozza
Reviews 1

I wanted to share my experience with this Preppy Kitchen cheesecake recipe since I left a comment on the YouTube video as well. The original instructions call for a whole stick of butter in the crust, but I found that it leaked out of the pan and slid down the sides. I adjusted it to just four tablespoons of butter, and the result was perfect. Since my daughter isn’t a fan of white chocolate, I swapped the ganache topping for crushed Oreos. The cake ended up with a noticeable crack in the center, so I figured the ganache would just pool in the fissure rather than creating a smooth finish. I also wanted to avoid the extra sweetness that white chocolate might add. The Oreo crumble was the ideal solution and turned out delicious!

Judy
Reviews 1

These instructions are spot on! The cake turned out perfectly. I do have one technical quirk, though: when I try to save your posts as a PDF, the text disappears even though it looks fine on screen. It’s a bit odd since other sites work fine for me. Does anyone else face this? Anyway, thanks for sharing such great content!

Amy
Reviews 1

Preppy Kitchen’s baking recipes really hit the spot! These muffins were wonderfully light and fluffy with the perfect balance of sweetness. I used just 12 cups and they were overflowing, so next time I’ll probably make a full batch of 15 or switch to mini muffins. The instructions are so clear that I’m already planning variations with lemon zest, brown sugar cinnamon, and maybe some chocolate chips. It’s great to find LA-based recipes that feel so high-quality and inspiring. Thanks for the excellent guidance!

Pez48something
Reviews 1

I followed the Preppy Kitchen instructions to the letter and added the optional almond extract for an extra touch. The butter browning stage was a bit tricky for me—I had to practice twice because my dark non-stick pan made it hard to spot the exact moment before it burned. I skipped the muffin tin and used a financier pan instead, which was the main draw for me. Since I bake just for the joy of it, having to use a specialized mold like that feels like a fun challenge.

Brittney
Reviews 1

These cupcakes are incredibly simple to whip up and taste amazing! I baked 48 mini cakes for my five-year-old’s birthday, and they were a huge hit. The batch bakes quickly in about 13 minutes. I rolled the frosted treats in sprinkles, which meant I only needed to make a quarter of the frosting amount. If you want to pipe decorative swirls, you’ll want to prepare half a batch instead. It’s a great find from Preppy Kitchen for any baker.

Emily
Reviews 1

I baked these brownies for Valentine’s Day boxes and they were an absolute hit—easily the best item out of all the sweets I prepared. I completely agree with the reviews that these beat those tiny store-bought bites by a mile. They’re incredibly fudgy and rich, truly living up to the high standards of LA native John Kanell’s Preppy Kitchen. I can’t recommend this recipe enough!

Eddie
Reviews 1

Saved this recipe a year ago for a special birthday treat. The result was exactly what I hoped for: incredibly light, fresh, and flavorful. It’s no wonder LA native John Kanell’s creations are so popular. I’m already planning to dive into the rest of the Preppy Kitchen collection to see what else I can whip up in my own kitchen!

Jenny Long
Reviews 1

Preppy Kitchen has become my go-to for reliable baking, and this recipe is a perfect example. I’ve made it four times already because it’s so quick, simple, and uses everyday ingredients I already have in the pantry. The only downside? It’s incredibly tasty, so resisting the urge to eat them all is the real challenge.

Hannah
Reviews 1

This is hands-down one of the best recipes I’ve found on Preppy Kitchen. It’s incredibly simple, delicious, and genuinely fun to whip up. I’ve already made it twice, and it disappears in minutes every time! I love tweaking the recipe to make it my own, and it always comes out perfectly because John’s instructions are so clear. Plus, watching the video is just a treat in itself. Huge fan!

Carol
Reviews 1

I tried my hand at making macarons for the first time using John Kanell’s recipes from Preppy Kitchen, and the result was fantastic. The instructions were so clear that even a beginner like me could follow along easily. I really appreciate the detailed guidance and can't wait to bake these again soon.

Meredith Katz
Reviews 1

I’ve considered myself a competent baker, but I’ve always struggled with red velvet recipes—the frosting never quite hit the mark. Preppy Kitchen changed that! I baked this cake as a birthday surprise for my friend Carson, filling the layers with rainbow sprinkles. He was absolutely thrilled and declared that no one else could ever bake his cake quite like this. Huge thanks to John from LA for the guidance. I’m already excited to experiment with more of your recipes! Warmest regards from Atlanta, Meredith 💖🌈

Madison Shelnutt
Reviews 1

As the resident baker for my circle of friends, I’m always tasked with the birthday cakes. Unless I need something specific, I stick to the reliable cake recipes found on Preppy Kitchen. They consistently get compliments from everyone, yet most of them are completely surprised when they find out how simple it was to make.

Emi
Reviews 1

These turned out absolutely perfectly! I swapped in some bread flour and used yogurt instead of sour cream, but the result was amazing. If you’re trying the recipe, definitely check out John Kanell’s video on his LA-based site for better visual guidance—it really helped me nail the technique. The loaf came out so soft, the filling was rich, and that frosting was incredible. My whole family devoured it!

Taya
Reviews 1

I’m completely hooked on John Kanell’s recipes from Preppy Kitchen now. I tweaked this batch by adding cardamom and nutmeg to the dough, swapped in oat milk, and bumped up the brown sugar in the filling. It took a while to rise, but patience and a low oven temp did the trick, especially with the chilly weather here in LA. My 13-year-old has started baking too and loves the double chocolate chip cookies and brownies. I’ve also finally mastered the frosting—something I used to just wing it on my own. Can’t wait to experiment with more flavor combinations!

Jill
Reviews 1

These muffins are light and fluffy with just the right amount of sweetness. I tossed in some dried barberries and chopped apricots for extra flavor, and they turned out delicious. I’ll definitely be making them again. It’s great finding reliable recipes like these on Preppy Kitchen, especially from a Los Angeles source that really knows its way around a kitchen.

Minnesotan in Georgia
Reviews 1

My husband asked for "healthy" cookies, which is a bit subjective, but the cranberry oatmeal recipe from Preppy Kitchen hit the spot. They taste great, and knowing they’re made with quality ingredients made me feel better about sharing them. It’s the perfect treat while I’m away on work for the next few days. I’ll definitely be baking these again when I return.

EmilyD
Reviews 1

I swapped out the traditional apple pie for this one at Thanksgiving and it was a massive hit! It’s wild how something with such basic ingredients can taste so magical. Honestly, every single recipe from Preppy Kitchen I’ve tried has turned out fantastic. Thanks, John, for sharing these gems with us!

Susan Hennessy
Reviews 1

I baked this cake for my husband’s birthday using John Kanell’s recipe from Preppy Kitchen, and the video tutorial made the process foolproof. The result was absolutely delicious, especially the lighter, less sweet frosting that I applied as a thin layer for a naked cake look. It turned out nearly as polished as the original photos! Everyone at the party loved the taste. I also made a 9-inch version and can’t wait to try it with summer berries. Thanks for the inspiration!

Aimee Steel
Reviews 1

Finally found a recipe on Preppy Kitchen that actually works! It was a total crowd-pleaser and super quick to whip up. I tweaked it slightly by using ermine frosting for a less sugary taste and roughly chopped the chocolate chips to ensure better distribution. Big win for our baking session!

Charlee
Reviews 1

I’ve baked these treats from Preppy Kitchen more than ten times over the past few years, and they easily beat everything else I’ve tried. My secret for that perfect lift? I fill my mixing bowl with hot tap water before starting. It gives the dough a nice warm head start and results in a beautiful rise.

jessica
Reviews 1

John Kanell’s recipes from Preppy Kitchen are absolutely incredible—these cookies truly melt in your mouth! I attempted a cute heart-shaped twist on the dough log, but it didn’t turn out as polished as the photos, so I’ve got some practice to do. Lesson learned: give them more room to spread! Still, the taste was spot on.

ed Standish
Reviews 1

The instructions in the video for this recipe didn't quite match the text on the Preppy Kitchen site. The video showed using 4.5 blocks of cream cheese, but the written recipe called for only 3. I followed the video instructions and the result was great, so I assume the text was off. I just couldn't print the recipe clearly, which added to the confusion.

Anthony Pelletier
Reviews 1

John Kanell’s recipes from Preppy Kitchen are consistently reliable. I used his financier cookie instructions to create a Christmas gift for a friend, and it was a huge hit. It’s always satisfying when a recipe turns out perfectly and earns high praise from the recipient.

Shannon Clouse
Reviews 1

Preppy Kitchen is genuinely a fantastic resource for baking enthusiasts. John’s ability to break down complex desserts into approachable steps is unmatched. Following his detailed instructions and helpful notes always guarantees a successful result. This cheesecake was an absolute standout—I made it for Thanksgiving and it was the star of the table. The rich chocolate layer was so good that my husband is already begging for it for his birthday. It’s easily become our go-to favorite dessert. Thank you for sharing such high-quality recipes!

Elizabeth
Reviews 1

As an LA native baker, John Kanell from Preppy Kitchen definitely knows his stuff, but this macaron recipe gave me a few hiccups. My first time making them, and they turned out decent, though the texture was a bit grainy because I only sifted the almond flour and confectioners' sugar once. Next time, I’ll stick to the instructions and use a food processor for a smoother finish. I’m docking a star because the buttercream recipe yields way too much frosting. While it’s rich and delicious, I ended up with three-quarters of a batch leftover after filling my cookies. If you try this, definitely halve the recipe; the original amount is just overkill.

Tahnee
Reviews 1

I’m a regular at Preppy Kitchen for baking inspiration, and this is definitely my go-to recipe. I’ve had nothing but success with these, except for one time when high humidity played tricks on the outcome. I love customizing it with stabilized Chantilly cream and raspberry jam, or adding crushed Oreos both in the dough and on top for a cookies-and-cream twist.

Barry Gardner
Reviews 1

Ordered a birthday cake from Preppy kitchen and it turned out to be absolutely amazing! The cake was moist and delicious, and the decorations were beautiful. Everyone at the party loved it! I highly recommend Preppy kitchen for all your cake needs. They never disappoint!

Bea
Reviews 1

Is anyone else out there using clear gel for their pie fillings like I do? I’m wondering if I can swap it out for a 1:1 ratio or if I need to adjust the amount. Preppy Kitchen’s recipes are usually so precise, so I wanted to double-check. Thanks in advance for your help!

Sarah Carr
Reviews 1

I had some success with these macaron pumpkins! I spent a bit of time whipping the egg whites and sugar until they reached stiff peaks. To get the look right, I added orange food coloring, chocolate chip stems, and buttercream vines. If you're looking for great baking inspiration from Preppy Kitchen, this is a fun project that turned out well.

Michelle
Reviews 1

If you’re a fan of citrus, you have to try this recipe from Preppy Kitchen. I really love everything lemon, so I bumped up the lemon juice by an extra tablespoon and it was delicious. I also improvised by swapping out half the butter for olive oil since I was running low. The result was an incredibly moist and light cake. Using liquid oil actually gave the crust a nice bit of crunch. It turned out great!

Laura Kowalski
Reviews 1

Living in LA, I’ve spent a lot of time on Preppy Kitchen, and John’s recipes never disappoint. After my neighbors shared a surplus of fresh lemons, I turned to his site for inspiration. I whipped up this cake using a small Bundt pan, checking it after 40 minutes until it was done. I admit I was impatient with the glaze—applying it while the cake was still warm—but honestly, the treat was too good to wait for. It was absolutely delicious.

Laura Kowalski
Reviews 1

I was a bit nervous about tackling this recipe for our family gathering, but Preppy Kitchen’s video tutorial and clear instructions made it surprisingly approachable. As an LA-native baker, John Kanell really knows how to guide beginners through the process. My first attempt turned out looking much better than I expected, and everyone loved it! It’s going to be a fun new Christmas tradition.

Zoe
Reviews 1

These look absolutely delicious! I’m planning to pair the lemon cake with raspberry frosting for some cupcakes. Without the lemon layer, do you think the cake has enough tartness to balance the raspberry? I was also thinking of filling them with lemon curd to boost the flavor. Thanks!

Stefanie Nordberg
Reviews 1

I never thought I could love lemon in baked goods, but this recipe from Preppy Kitchen completely won me over. As an LA native’s creation, John’s attention to detail really shines through; the cupcakes are incredibly delicious and have genuinely converted my taste. I’ve been watching his videos for years, and I love that his clear, step-by-step instructions make baking feel achievable rather than intimidating. It’s rare to find a baker who inspires confidence like this, so thank you for sharing your expertise and for creating such high-quality content. This is easily one of the best recipes I’ve tried!

Jessica
Reviews 1

I’m usually a devoted follower of Preppy Kitchen because the recipes are consistently top-notch. However, I tried the dough from one of John Kanell’s recipes yesterday twice, and it failed to rise on both attempts. Since I usually make cinnamon rolls without issue, I scrutinized every variable: I verified the yeast’s expiration date, used the oven’s proofing setting, and precisely measured the liquid temperature for the second attempt. Despite my experience, the dough turned into a brick. Clearly, I must be making a mistake somewhere, but I’d love some insight into what went wrong!

Umaya Fonseka
Reviews 1

Finally got the chocolate chip cookies right! I was a bit hesitant after a few previous failures, but I’ve found John’s recipes on Preppy Kitchen to be consistently reliable. I trusted that this would be a foolproof attempt, and I was right—it turned out perfectly on the very first try. Thanks for sharing such awesome baking tips!

Halimah
Reviews 1

These are absolutely addictive! I’ve already made this recipe twice and I’m planning to bake them again this weekend. John’s instructions from Preppy Kitchen are so easy to follow that the results are just as good as the next time. It’s no wonder this LA-based site has become my go-to for reliable baking inspiration.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Preppy kitchen

Browse sweet savory baking recipes covering cakes, desserts, drinks and more made by an LA native and lover of all things delicious Preppy living never tasted so good!

Preppy Kitchen: The Ultimate Destination for Delicious Baking Recipes

Preppy Kitchen is a one-stop destination for all your baking needs. Whether you are a beginner or an experienced baker, this website has something to offer to everyone. With its extensive collection of sweet and savory recipes, Preppy Kitchen has become the go-to place for anyone who loves to bake.

The website is the brainchild of John Kanell, an LA native who has always been passionate about baking. He started Preppy Kitchen as a way to share his love for baking with others and inspire them to create delicious treats in their own kitchens.

At Preppy Kitchen, you will find a wide range of recipes covering cakes, desserts, drinks and more. From classic chocolate cake to exotic macarons, there is no shortage of options when it comes to choosing what to bake next. Each recipe on the website is carefully crafted by John himself and comes with detailed instructions that are easy to follow.

One thing that sets Preppy Kitchen apart from other baking websites is its focus on using high-quality ingredients. John believes that using fresh and natural ingredients not only makes the final product taste better but also makes it healthier. That's why he always emphasizes using organic produce whenever possible.

Apart from recipes, Preppy Kitchen also offers valuable tips and tricks on how to improve your baking skills. Whether you want advice on how to make perfect buttercream frosting or need help troubleshooting common baking problems like cracked cakes or soggy bottoms – this website has got you covered.

Another great feature of Preppy Kitchen is its community section where users can share their own recipes and connect with other bakers from around the world. This creates a sense of community among like-minded individuals who share a passion for all things sweet.

In addition to its online presence, Preppy Kitchen also offers in-person classes where participants can learn hands-on techniques from John himself. These classes cover everything from basic cake decorating to advanced pastry techniques and are a great way to take your baking skills to the next level.

Overall, Preppy Kitchen is a must-visit website for anyone who loves to bake. With its extensive collection of recipes, helpful tips and tricks, and focus on using high-quality ingredients – it's no wonder that this website has become so popular among baking enthusiasts. So why not head over to Preppy Kitchen today and start creating delicious treats in your own kitchen?