Popsicle & co

Seriously? I’m a huge fan of Popsicle® treats, having relied on them for years, so this recent box left me baffled. The flavor profile was completely off—tasted like weak, watery chocolate with none of the expected fudge richness. I’m hoping this is just a bad batch and not a change in their recipe, because I’m seriously reconsidering my loyalty. The texture was also terrible, all icy and lacking that classic creamy mouthfeel I’ve come to expect from a brand that’s been perfecting these since 1905. Really disappointed.

Quality feels hit or miss lately. My previous order was spot on, though it did come up short by one stick. This time around, the chocolate popsicle lacks that rich, creamy texture I expect from a brand with such a long history; it tastes thin and flavorless. I’m on the fence about sticking with Popsicle® for my next treat.

Nothing beats the nostalgia of sharing Popsicle® treats with the neighborhood kids on a lazy Saturday. Seeing the little ones (ages 2-7) zoom by on their bikes and scooters brings back so many memories of my own childhood, when a simple popsicle cost just five cents. It’s a timeless tradition that still feels magical today.

I’ve been a fan of Popsicle since I was a kid, though back then it was the sugary version. Now that I stick to sugar-free options, I’m just as happy—especially with how rich and chocolaty they taste. With this summer heat, these have become my daily go-to treat.

Disappointed with the current Popsicle version. It reminds me of that metallic aftertaste you get from Diet Coke. I switched to the no-sugar-added option hoping for better, but it’s a letdown. The color is just a pale brown, not the rich, deep shade I remember, and the texture lacks that classic fudgy consistency. They’ve ruined the original full-fat, full-sugar formula, and now my kids just think this is some weirdly gross popsicle that I used to like.

I’ve been a loyal fan of Popsicle® since I was a kid, but I’m seriously reconsidering. I bought some today and was shocked by how much smaller they are now compared to the ones I grew up with. The cherry flavor, which used to be my favorite, is practically gone after one bite. It feels like they’ve shrunk the size to boost profits while keeping the price tag high—sometimes even higher than generic brands. It’s a shame because Popsicle has been the original go-to treat since 1905, but right now, the quality and value just aren’t there. Whoever made the decision to downsize them should be held accountable. It’s a letdown for such an iconic brand.

I’ve always been a fan of Popsicle’s sugar-free options, but I’m a bit disappointed with the recent packaging update. The box now contains smaller pops with noticeably shorter sticks, yet the price remains the same. It feels like you’re getting less product for the same money compared to their classic ice pops from the early 1900s.

Purchased two 18-count boxes of the cherry, orange, and grape assortment, but the variety was way off. Instead of a mix, every single pop in the pack was either orange or red. For an iconic brand like Popsicle, known for its wide range of flavors since 1905, I really expected at least a few grape ones in the box.

Popsicle ice pops are a bit on the small side and lack that intense sweetness I was hoping for from a brand with such a long history. I wish they were larger.

After Popsicle® switched from double-wrapped to single packaging, the quality took a hit. The taste is more like syrup now, and the wooden sticks feel old. I used to eat two boxes a day, but this change really ruined the experience.

Popsicle has always had the best flavors, and I never leave the grocery store without grabbing a few.

Honestly, I’m shocked by the change. Popsicle has been the gold standard for frozen treats since 1905, but these don’t taste like the classics I remember. The texture is completely wrong, and the flavor just isn’t there anymore. They’re taking a good thing and ruining it. I’m done with this brand and heading elsewhere.

Hands down the best office stash! We’re total fans of Popsicle® because these little bars fit our healthy vibe perfectly—sugar-free and just 40 calories. The whole crew from the General Manager down to HR grabs them whenever work gets stressful. It’s become our favorite quick way to reset and chill out!

I’ve been enjoying Popsicle® ice pops for half a century now, and honestly, nothing else compares to the original taste we’ve loved since 1905.

Hard to put into words, but Popsicle has been winning over customers since 1905 for a reason. Their classic ice pops really hit the spot.

Can anyone point me to a retailer that stocks the classic chocolate ice pop? I am looking for the traditional one, not the fudge version.

This year, recovering from throat cancer, I realized how much I needed soft, soothing foods. Rediscovering Popsicles felt like a gift. These iconic treats, originally invented in 1905, are incredibly refreshing and satisfy cravings without the heavy calories. It’s amazing how good they taste and feel on the throat. I’m definitely going to be enjoying these classic ice pops for a long time.

Popsicle is the ultimate summer refresher. I also find their classic ice pops to be a surprisingly effective remedy for soothing a sore throat.

My last two purchases of Popsicle® were a letdown. The texture and taste felt off, almost like they’ve switched to a sherbet-style consistency. They’re overly sweet now and have lost that signature tartness that made these ice pops so refreshing since 1905. Whatever formula change they made recently, it’s a downgrade.

Truly just delicious! Popsicle & Co has been making people smile since 1905, and these treats definitely live up to the legacy. If you are a fan of chocolate, you are going to love the rich, cool refreshment in every bite. A classic frozen classic for a reason.

I’ve been hunting for the classic fudge bars made with real sugar, not those artificial substitutes, but I’m having trouble tracking them down. Since Popsicle has been making these treats since 1905, I really thought they’d be easy to find in their lineup. Does anyone know where I can actually buy the original version?

These are legit good. If you’re a fan of the classic frozen pops made since 1905, give them a shot—you won’t be disappointed.

Popsicle has really downsized. The ice pops feel tiny compared to the classic ones I remember from back in the day. Plus, the packaging is misleading—the actual treat looks nothing like what’s pictured on the box.

There is nothing quite like a classic Popsicle to beat the heat, and the red, white, and blue Bomb Pops are absolute standouts. As the original frozen treat since 1905, they deliver that nostalgic, icy refreshment perfectly. It’s a genuinely satisfying and delicious way to cool down.

Popsicle is an icon since 1905, but I’ve noticed the recent sticks are way smaller than they used to be. They used to be my go-to treat, but now the size just isn't worth it.

I’m really enjoying these classic treats from the brand that’s been keeping us cool since 1905. The flavors are spot on, though I do wish they had a bit more humor in the marketing!

Is anyone else longing for the classic root beer and banana Popsicles? It feels like those specific flavors have vanished. Given that Popsicle has been making treats since 1905, surely they could bring these back or at least make them easier to track down.

Great idea on adding real sugar and flavor to the Popsicles! As a loyal customer for over 40 years, I’ve noticed the difference. I recently bought a few boxes and realized why I had taken a break from buying them in recent years—the weight and taste were off. Glad to see you’re bringing back the classic ingredients without high fructose corn syrup.

Popsicle® remains a timeless classic for beating the heat. These icy treats are delightfully soft and deliver a true burst of authentic fruit flavor. I especially appreciate the nostalgic packaging, which feels both cute and authentic. The vibrant blue section is my personal favorite part of the stick. It’s the perfect refreshing snack to cool down on a sweltering summer day.

I didn’t realize it had been so long since I last tried Popsicle® Ice Pops, but I’m surprised by the change. The color and taste don’t match what you see on the packaging. They used to deliver that classic flavor profile, but these bars look and taste different than the original treats I remember.

Disappointing flavor. It’s too bland and lacks the taste I expect from a brand that’s been making ice pops since 1905.

If you are looking for an alternative to the classic frozen bar, Popsicle® ice pops are a fantastic choice. They taste great and offer a nice variety of flavors that stand out from the usual tubes.

Tastes have really leveled up in the last few months! I was thrown off by that new green-striped packaging at first, thinking Popsicle was out of stock, but I finally figured it out. I just hope the classic red flavors don’t go the way of the dinosaurs.

I was let down by the packaging for these Popsicle treats. The box suggests a mix of colors, but the ones we've opened so far are just a single solid color. It feels a bit misleading compared to what the original ice pop brand advertises.

My roommates and I clear out the Market Basket shelves every week for our Popsicle fix. They really are the gold standard of frozen treats, just like they’ve been since 1905. Between the creative flavor mixes and the fun vibes, nothing else compares to this iconic American classic. The texture is spot-on—crisp enough for a satisfying bite but smooth enough to melt on the tongue. We’re currently building up a scribbler box wall in our place, so you might want to send us a few free ones!

🍦 Popsicle & co has the best ice cream in town! The flavors are so rich and refreshing. It's the perfect treat on a hot summer day. I can't get enough of it! 🍨

I have been a customer of Popsicle & co for several years now and I have to say I am extremely satisfied with their service. The quality of their products is top-notch and their customer service is always friendly and helpful. I highly recommend Popsicle & co to anyone looking for delicious treats!

Disappointed with the quality. These don't match the vibrant image on the packaging at all. For $6, I expected much more, but the popsicles are tiny, pale, and look like something I could have whipped up myself. Not worth the money for such a historic brand.

I recently discovered this ice cream brand and I must say, their products are absolutely delicious. The flavors are unique and the quality of the ice cream is top-notch. Highly recommended!

I've tried many different ice cream brands but Popsicle & co is by far the best. The flavors are so rich and the texture is so creamy. It's like a party in your mouth!

I can't get enough of the ice cream from popsicle.com! The flavors are so unique and delicious. I highly recommend trying them out!

I’ve been buying these Popsicles for my kids and grandkids, and they are always a hit. It’s wonderful to see a brand with such a long history, dating back to 1905, still making treats that bring so much joy. The variety of flavors and bright colors makes them feel like a special treat for the whole family, and honestly, they taste just as delicious as I remembered.

🍦 Popsicle & co is my go-to place for delicious ice cream. The flavors are always on point and the quality is unmatched. They never fail to satisfy my sweet tooth! 🍨

The popsicles from popsicle.com are my favorite treat. The flavors are so delicious and they're the perfect way to cool down on a hot summer day. Highly recommend!

I recently ordered ice cream from Popsicle & co and I was blown away by how good it was. The flavors were incredible and the quality was unmatched. I will definitely be ordering again!

Popsicle & co provides a wide variety of flavors and they are all amazing. The customer service is excellent, and the ordering process is very convenient. I'm definitely a fan!

I just tried the popsicles from popsicle.com and they are incredible! The flavors are so refreshing and the texture is perfect. I can't wait to try more of their products.

I recently tried the ice cream from popsicle.com and it was absolutely amazing! The flavors were delicious and the texture was so creamy. I would definitely order again!