Login or sign up
For business

plays well with butter

4.9· 785 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.9/ 5

Based on 785 reviews

588%
411%
31%
20%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about plays well with butter

Based on 785 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally praise the recipes for producing delicious results and juicy meats, though some note that texture issues or specific cooking methods can lead to mixed experiences.
What is plays well with butter?

Plays Well With Butter is a recipe and meal kit brand offering unfussy, flavor-filled recipes for people who love to cook. The founder, Jess, developed the brand after working in fine-dining restaurants and spent over 10 years exploring how to make exceptional food work for everyday life. The website features categories like Weeknight Recipes, Sunday Suppers, and Thanksgiving HQ to guide users through various cooking needs.

What specific recipe categories and featured dishes are available on the site?

The business provides a wide range of recipes including appetizers, breakfast, desserts, drinks, main dishes, sauces, side dishes, and snacks. Specific featured items include 11 Alternative Thanksgiving Dinner Ideas, Yukon Gold Au Gratin Potatoes, and Everyday Lemon Dijon Vinaigrette. Users can also browse round-ups and latest recipes to find inspiration for their next meal.

What themes do multiple reviewers share regarding the quality of the food?

Reviewers consistently praise the brand for its flavorful and simple-to-prepare recipes, such as the braised beef and crispy tacos. Many users highlight the moist texture and rich flavors of their baked treats, noting they are even better than restaurant versions. The brand is recognized for delivering an experience that feels like escaping to a coastal Scottish estate with homegrown food.

What specific complaints or minor issues have users mentioned in their reviews?

Some reviewers mention that the pop-up events can be hit or miss, while others note that the included sauces are superior to shortcuts like Kinder’s Teriyaki. A few users reported that links for certain recipes, such as cucumber kimchi and aioli, were not working on the site at the time of their review. Despite these minor issues, the overall feedback remains highly positive.

What is the current Trustburn rating and how recent is the feedback?

The Trustburn rating for the business is 4.9 out of 5 from 785 reviews. The most recent review was posted on October 8, 2024, and the majority of the feedback is five-star. Users have expressed satisfaction with the results of their dinner parties and cookouts using the brand's recipes.

What specific cooking questions have users asked about the recipes?

Some users have asked about specific cooking techniques, such as whether to boil fresh pasta before adding it to a piping hot ragù. Others have inquired about substituting ingredients, like using Flanken cut instead of English cut for a recipe. These questions show that users are actively engaging with the brand's content to improve their cooking skills.

What is the core philosophy behind the recipes and how are they designed?

The brand's recipes are designed to be accessible for everyday life, with a focus on smart techniques and thoroughly tested methods. Jess, the founder, aims to provide recipes that users will be excited to make again and again. The goal is to make exceptional food work for everyday life, catering to those who live to eat and love to cook.

How do users describe the ease of preparation and the results of the recipes?

Users have reported that the brand's recipes are incredibly easy to put together and turn out delicious, making them perfect for serving as appetizers or party dishes. Some have even mentioned that the recipes are so good that they plan to double the batch for easy weeknight dinners or snacks for weekend picnics. The ease of preparation is a recurring theme in the positive feedback.

What is the official website of plays well with butter?

The official website of plays well with butter is playswellwithbutter.com.

Is plays well with butter on social media?

plays well with butter has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Jessie R
Reviews 1

This recipe from plays well with butter was a fantastic success. I marinated the chicken in IPA and scaled back the dry rub slightly to suit my taste. Cooking it indirectly on the grill kept the meat incredibly juicy. I’m definitely adding this to my regular rotation and will be making it again very soon.

Joel
Reviews 1

I recently bought from plays well with butter for a dinner party, and the results were fantastic—my guests absolutely loved it. I do have a question though: I make my own pasta using a KitchenAid attachment. Since the ragù is already piping hot, do I really need to boil the noodles first? I was tempted to just stir the fresh pasta directly into the sauce to save time, but I wanted to be safe with company in town. Any advice would be appreciated!

Julianne Jansen
Reviews 1

Absolutely tasty treats from plays well with butter. Mine spread quite a bit during baking, and they got a little dry by the next day, but I take full responsibility—that’s just the mark of a mediocre cookie baker. That chai glaze, though? Incredible. Still giving it a full 5 stars.

Lauren
Reviews 1

Absolutely blown away by the quality at plays well with butter! I made this three nights ago and it’s still on my mind. It’s incredibly flavorful and surprisingly simple to prepare—I’m already planning my next batch. Pro tip: if you’re using Flanken cut instead of English cut, it works just as well; you’ll just have more bones to deal with and it cooks a bit faster. My four-year-old gave it a resounding “7 million infinity stars,” so that says it all!

Susan A White
Reviews 1

Just discovered plays well with butter and I’m thrilled to try this braised recipe for my family tomorrow. I’m leaning toward the oven method but curious if anyone has compared it to the stovetop or crockpot versions? I’d love to hear which approach yields the best results before I start cooking.

Alan
Reviews 1

These tortillas at plays well with butter really live up to the images. They had that perfect crisp texture and cheesy flavor I was hoping for. I boosted the smoky notes with some Santa Fe chili powder, which worked well. Although they cracked slightly in the oven, they remained sturdy enough to hold everything together. Definitely a repeat purchase.

Mark Medellin
Reviews 1

I had a great experience with my order from plays well with butter. I followed the recipe instructions closely, just swapping in some cubed chicken for extra protein once the beans were simmering. The dish was incredibly easy to put together and turned out delicious—perfect for serving as an appetizer or a party dish. Highly recommend!

Whitney Blount
Reviews 1

The team at plays well with butter really knows how to cook. Every bite was full of flavor and felt like a warm hug, almost like escaping to a coastal Scottish estate with plenty of homegrown food and game. It’s more than just dinner; it’s an experience. Highly recommend checking out their menu.

Harry
Reviews 1

I absolutely love these! While I find the included sauce to be the superior choice, I’ve also tried them with Kinder’s Teriyaki and found that to be a perfectly viable shortcut when you’re pressed for time. I actually whipped up a batch during my lunch break at plays well with butter, managed to eat a portion, and packed the rest for my kids to enjoy after school. It was such a convenient solution that I’ll definitely be making these regularly.

Frank
Reviews 1

I baked a celiac-friendly batch using two cups of Bob’s Red Mill gluten-free flour and a cup of buckwheat, and the result was fantastic. I rolled them thick to recapture that hearty texture I loved in my gluten-eating days back in Philly. Sticking to local tradition, I used a mix of sweet and banana peppers, which got me pretty close to the classic taste I remember. Next time, I’m planning to throw in some onions and sausage to take it to the next level.

Colleen
Reviews 1

We were blown away by the treats at plays well with butter for our luau! My nephew picked them up, and they were absolutely delicious—we literally couldn't stop eating and finished 50 pieces. Honestly, they tasted even better than what I’ve ordered at restaurants. ❤️

Anna
Reviews 1

I was out of cilantro, but the flavor still came through perfectly. The potatoes made a huge difference, adding a hearty element that made these kabobs much more satisfying than the usual meat-and-veg combination. I’m already planning to experiment with other skewer varieties!

Tim
Reviews 1

I found making char siu incredibly straightforward with this brand. I followed the 2 lb recipe they provide and used the result in spring rolls, turning out great. I'll definitely cook this again soon, and I plan to double the batch for easy weeknight dinners or snacks for weekend picnics and games.

Nantr
Reviews 1

Plays Well With Butter really nailed this one! I first tasted it at my daughter’s place and decided to recreate it myself yesterday using the slow cooker method. The flavor profile is outstanding, especially with the tang of the pickled red onions. I also experimented by adding a mix of the braising liquid and G Hughes sugar-free barbecue sauce, which turned out delicious. Now I’m just waiting to enjoy the leftovers!

Ofelia G-E
Reviews 1

I am completely hooked on the steaks from plays well with butter. Their faux dry age method produces a quality I haven't found anywhere else, and it has completely transformed my cooking routine. I can't imagine preparing steak any other way now. Big thanks for the brilliant tip!

Laurie S Reilly
Reviews 1

I recently discovered plays well with butter and their salads are absolutely fantastic. We made one for a family gathering and everyone went crazy for it. It held up beautifully when packed for travel, and the dressing stole the show with so many guests asking about it. A huge win for a great recipe source.

Sopheia
Reviews 1

We are huge fans of this recipe! It consistently makes the cut for my boyfriend’s top five dishes. Since I don’t keep Chinese five-spice on hand, I simply swap in a bit of grated cinnamon and star anise, plus a dash of Worcestershire sauce. We absolutely love the result. I make it using pork butt or shoulder. Also, no need to stress about food coloring—it turns out great either way.

NAN
Reviews 1

The flavors in this dish really came together perfectly. We devoured it so fast over the weekend that it disappeared quicker than expected! I realized I didn't shred the short rib enough in the final stages—that’s on me, but I’ve definitely got the tip for next time. Thanks for the great recipe!

Kelly Harper
Reviews 1

Plays Well With Butter’s cast iron method completely transformed how I cook steak. The results are consistently juicy with an ideal sear, making it foolproof even for those who haven't mastered the technique yet. If you love steak, their detailed guide is absolutely worth trying.

Donna
Reviews 1

I cooked the burgers from plays well with butter and they came out juicy and flavorful. I would have given five stars, but they were quite salty. The recipe card lists 1 1/2 teaspoons of salt, but the instructions say to add just 1 teaspoon, which seems to be the correct amount based on the taste. The ingredient list should be updated to avoid confusion. There is also a discrepancy with the pepper amount.

Carla @ Foodie Digital
Reviews 1

Grilling fish can definitely be a bit daunting, but the recipe from plays well with butter along with their expert grilling advice made for a total success. We had a fantastic fish taco night, and my daughter even said it was the best cod she’s ever had.

Ryan
Reviews 1

I tried the chicken thighs from plays well with butter, brining them in beer for a day and grilling them at 300°F on a gas grill for 45 minutes. The rub was decent, but the result was just average. My skin didn't crisp up at all, and despite following the process, it didn't live up to the hype I had from other reviews. Disappointing.

SharLee RODGERS
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed the overall flavor at plays well with butter, though it was a bit too tart for my taste. The lime kick was quite strong, so I’d suggest asking for just half a lime next time. It also leaned a bit salty on the seasoning, and I’ll probably hold back on the extra pinch in the future.

Caroline
Reviews 1

I'm really excited to give this recipe a try this weekend—it looks absolutely mouthwatering! I've been a loyal FoodHub user for several months now and I'm totally hooked. The range of cuisines is impressive, and I love how easy it is to filter options based on dietary needs. It has completely simplified my meal planning process and made cooking much more enjoyable. Thanks for sharing!

Katherine L.
Reviews 1

I whipped up this dish today using a boneless, netted lamb oyster shoulder, leaving the net on and roasting it whole. Since I was out of aged balsamic vinegar and fresh bay leaves, I substituted regular balsamic and bay leaf powder, but the result was still fantastic. We enjoyed the meat and the broth as a standalone meal without any sides. Even with the amount of fat, it didn’t feel heavy; the mix of balsamic vinegar and maple syrup struck the perfect balance. It’s definitely going on my repeat menu.

MJ
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed these! They are straightforward to prepare, though it helps to have all your ingredients prepped beforehand. I noticed my tortillas cracking while assembling the enchiladas, so next time I’ll either heat four at a time or use a tortilla warmer. I found that using an ice cream scoop worked great for portioning the mixture, which yielded 14 quesadillas.

Josephine
Reviews 1

I whipped up this dish for our “pasta Wednesday” ritual last night at plays well with butter, and it was a total hit. It was so good I kept going back for seconds, thirds, and even fourths. I added a sprinkle of crushed red pepper flakes and stirred in some vegan Parmesan for extra flavor. I’ll definitely be making this recipe again.

Stef
Reviews 1

Plays Well with Butter delivered a fantastic product that truly surpassed my expectations. The taste was absolutely delicious. I prepared these with vegan cheese, and they held together perfectly. I opted to skip the chipotle pepper inside, making a separate dipping sauce instead, which complemented the dish beautifully.

Christine Jones
Reviews 1

I absolutely loved the result from plays well with butter! The recipe was surprisingly simple and mostly hands-off, which made cooking a breeze. The flavor was incredibly rich and delicious, earning me plenty of compliments from my dinner guests. Highly recommend it—I’ll definitely be making it again!

Amanda
Reviews 1

I’m really impressed with plays well with butter! I just made this pesto in my compact Ninja Fit blender (even with just a 16oz capacity), and it handled the volume perfectly. It was surprisingly simple to whip up, and the flavor turned out excellent. I followed the common recommendation to add baby spinach and oil-packed sundried tomatoes, but I want to emphasize a key tip: do not skip saving that pasta water! I definitely needed the entire cup to get the right consistency.

Jennyquack
Reviews 1

I’m absolutely thrilled with this dish from plays well with butter—it really lived up to the hype! The preparation was incredibly straightforward. I just pulled the meat apart with a fork during the last 30 minutes, left the pot uncovered in the oven, and let it caramelize perfectly without any need for the broiler. It’s a genuine crowd-pleaser; if you serve this to friends, they’ll swear you’ve been slaving over the stove all day.

Lisa D
Reviews 1

I’m usually not a fan of lamb, so when a friend who raises lambs gave us a shoulder bone, I wasn’t exactly thrilled. However, my husband was excited, so I looked up recipes and found one from plays well with butter. I made it today, and we both loved it. I was surprised by how delicious it turned out, especially for someone who doesn’t typically enjoy lamb. I’ll definitely be making this again.

landon
Reviews 1

I was hunting for a way to use up some venison and pork sausage from my freezer and stumbled upon plays well with butter. I tried it for dinner last night and wow, it was amazing! It’s definitely going into my personal cookbook and will surely become a regular staple in my kitchen. The flavor combination was spot on.

Nat
Reviews 1

I really appreciate you sharing this recipe! The flavor profile is fantastic. However, I’m having a bit of trouble with the consistency; the sauce turns out quite runny, even though I tried thickening it up with sour cream and an extra amount of the mix. Any tips on what I might have missed?

Taylor
Reviews 1

Plays Well with Butter has become my go-to for reliable seasoning. I’ve made black bean tacos with other brands that turned out dry and bland, but this blend was a standout. The spices were perfectly balanced and incredibly versatile—I swapped in red peppers and hot sauce instead of chipotles, and the result was fantastic. It’s definitely earning a permanent spot in my recipe rotation.

Amber
Reviews 1

Plays Well With Butter definitely lives up to its name. This dish was incredibly straightforward and delicious. I made it with boneless, skinless chicken thighs, reducing the cooking time by about five minutes to get the texture just right. One pro tip: save that braising liquid! I froze the leftovers from my first batch and reused them later for a second round, just adding fresh ginger and green onion for a burst of flavor. Highly recommended.

Tina
Reviews 1

I doubled the recipe for dinner tonight so I could share some with my mom and in-laws, and it turned out delicious! My only hesitation was the consistency—it wasn’t very thick. I’m wondering if I should have reduced the liquid portion when scaling up the recipe, or if I simply needed to cook it longer than the suggested 3 1/2 hours. The pasta soaked it up beautifully, so the flavor was spot on, but I’m hoping the sauce will firm up a bit more once it sits in the fridge at home. Alternatively, maybe I just need to simmer it down further next time. Any tips would be appreciated!

Chelsea
Reviews 1

The recipes at plays well with butter are truly stunning, earning them a solid five-star rating. However, navigating the mobile version of their site can be a bit of a headache due to the settings being dialed up too high. It’s a shame because the content is great, but the experience on the app is frustratingly difficult.

Mary McCullegan
Reviews 1

If you’re a fan of chai like me, you’ll want to bookmark this. I didn’t have the specific tea bags or loose leaf on hand, so I improvised using the instructions from plays well with butter and came up with a mix that turned out spot-on. I’d suggest starting with about half a teaspoon per cup and adjusting to your taste. Big thanks for the reliable recipe—I’m definitely passing it along to friends!

Rachelle S.
Reviews 1

I rarely bother leaving comments on the recipes I try from blogs, but this dish from plays well with butter was an absolute standout. It’s hands down the best thing I’ve ever tasted—nothing even comes close. My husband and I have officially crowned it our favorite recipe to date, and he’s already asked for it again for his birthday next month. I even served it to guests, and everyone went back for seconds. The depth of flavor was incredible. Sure, it takes some time and patience to prepare properly, but every single tip in the recipe is worth it. Do yourself a favor and run to the store right now to grab the ingredients!

Stephanie
Reviews 1

These tacos are genuinely some of the best I’ve ever had. As a vegan of 34 years, I’ve tried countless variations, but these are exceptional. They pair wonderfully with vegan cheese, though they’re delicious plain too. I made a few small tweaks to suit my taste: I skipped the lime and threw in some frozen corn. Even though my tortillas were a bit stubborn and the filling spilled out, the result was still amazing. I’ll definitely be perfecting my technique, but this recipe is now a permanent staple in our vegan household. It’s great to find recipes that truly work.

Maygen Lee
Reviews 1

I followed the recipe from playswellwithbutter.com using King Arthur’s gluten-free 1-1 blend. Instead of a food processor, I relied on a hand pastry blender, and the results were fantastic. Everyone loved them and gave great feedback. Definitely planning to bake these again!

Laura
Reviews 1

This sauce is now a staple in my kitchen. I used it with chicken, and the only reason I’m not raving about the quantity is that I didn’t make enough to go with it! It was so delicious that the batch vanished faster than I expected, so I’ll definitely be doubling up next time. I also cooked it on the stovetop in a skillet instead of grilling it, and it still came out perfectly with a lovely char. Plays Well With Butter really nailed it—thanks for the fantastic product!

Christine
Reviews 1

I tried a recipe from plays well with butter and even though I accidentally swapped in raw cashews instead of the roasted ones, the result was a huge success. As someone new to vegan cooking, I was really impressed by the flavor and I’ve definitely pinned this one for future meals.

Della
Reviews 1

I tried a recipe from plays well with butter and it came out a bit drier than I hoped. Being new to baking, I’m not sure if I over-mixed or over-baked them, so any advice would be great since I plan to make them again. That said, the flavor and glaze were absolutely delicious!

Michelle
Reviews 1

The technique of browning the chicken before roasting it in the broth is a great concept. While the meat itself came out delicious, my broth turned out a bit bitter. For my next attempt, I plan to reduce the oven temperature to around 375-400 degrees, as my batch reached a rolling boil and finished cooking in less than an hour. I’m aiming for a gentler simmer. I might also reduce the bay leaves from three to one, although keeping three should be fine at the lower temp. Thanks to plays well with butter for the inspiration; I look forward to tweaking the recipe and trying it again.

Cheryl
Reviews 1

We tried the recipe from plays well with butter, and while the sauce was truly divine, the sausage flavor was just too dominant for our taste, especially since we are big fans of Italian sausage. Since it was just the two of us, we scaled back the mushrooms and sausage to half portions, keeping the rest at full measure, but it was still overpowering. We’ll definitely be making this again, but next time we’ll swap in chicken or ground beef instead.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About plays well with butter