Login or sign up
For business

Penwell insurance

4.7· 39 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.7/ 5

Based on 39 reviews

577%
415%
38%
20%
10%
Ask AI

Questions about Penwell insurance

Based on 39 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 6 days ago

What is Penwell insurance?

Penwell Insurance is a trusted independent insurance agency located in Carmel and Cicero, Indiana, serving residents in Hamilton County and surrounding areas. They specialize in providing auto, home, business, and personal life insurance solutions. Their team compares options from multiple top-rated carriers to help customers find competitive rates and personalized coverage tailored to their unique needs.

Where are the offices located and what are the hours?

The agency operates two physical locations: a Carmel office at 600 E Carmel Drive Suite 162 and a Cicero office at 30 South Peru Street. Both offices are open Monday through Friday from 9:00 am to 4:00 pm, with Saturday and Sunday closed. They also use a P.O. Box 828 in Cicero for their mailing address.

How can I contact Penwell Insurance?

Customers can reach the Carmel office by calling (317) 559-3022 or the Cicero office at (317) 984-3300. The business also provides a fax number of (317) 984-3338 for both locations. Online contact forms are available on their website for those who prefer digital communication.

What themes do recent reviews highlight?

Recent feedback from July 2024 highlights a strong emphasis on claims management and customer support. Reviewers specifically praised agents like Christy, Heather, and Kris for their responsiveness, thoroughness, and ability to coordinate directly with body shops and carriers like Erie to ensure smooth processes.

What specific insurance products do they offer?

Penwell Insurance offers a wide range of products including auto, home, renters, condo, boat, motorcycle, RV, umbrella, and life insurance. They also provide commercial auto insurance, business insurance, and key person life insurance for organizations.

Which areas do they serve?

The agency serves clients in Carmel, Cicero, Fishers, and throughout Hamilton County, Indiana, as well as in Illinois. Their local focus allows them to provide personalized guidance and comprehensive coverage gap analyses for residents in these areas.

What is the advantage of being an independent agency?

As an independent agency, Penwell Insurance works on behalf of the customer rather than a single insurance company. This independence allows them to choose the best carrier for each client's needs and negotiate competitive rates without being tied to one provider.

What programs or tools do they provide?

The website mentions a 'Community Connection Program' and a 'Life Community Connection Program' as part of their services. They also offer an 'Annual Insurance Checklist' to help customers stay informed about their coverage and policy details.

What online tools and portals are available?

Customers can access a client portal for online billing and payments, file claims, request policy changes, and download auto ID cards or certificates of insurance. The policy service center is available 24 hours for customer support and claims contact information.

How long has the business been operating?

The agency has been in business since at least 2026, as indicated by the copyright notice on their website. They have a long-standing presence in the Carmel and Cicero communities, helping families and businesses secure coverage for over a decade.

What do customers appreciate most?

Reviewers frequently mention the team's ability to explain policy details clearly and help customers choose the best coverage. They also appreciate the proactive follow-up and the balance between professional expertise and a personal touch.

How do they approach the insurance selection process?

The agency emphasizes that finding the right insurance shouldn't be complicated. They take the time to understand goals, compare deductibles, limits, and premiums, and provide coverage gap analyses to identify areas of unnecessary risk.

What is the geographic scope of their service?

The website states that Penwell Insurance provides car, home, life, commercial auto, and business insurance to all of Indiana and Illinois. They also mention serving Morse Lake and the surrounding Hamilton County area specifically.

What is the official website of Penwell insurance?

The official website of Penwell insurance is penwellinsurance.com.

Is Penwell insurance on social media?

Penwell insurance has official profiles on Linkedin.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Sean C.
Reviews 1

Penwell Insurance in Carmel really knows how to treat their clients. Craig, Heather, and the rest of the team are incredibly responsive and thorough whenever you have questions. You can tell they genuinely care about finding the perfect balance between comprehensive coverage and affordable rates for each customer.

Holly B.
Reviews 1

Penwell Insurance in Carmel delivered exactly what we needed. After thirteen years with a big national chain, we switched to a local agency to get more personalized attention. Heather was wonderful to work with, and her team proved they are the right choice for anyone looking for better, hometown service.

dave a.
Reviews 1

Penwell Insurance in Carmel has been wonderful to work with. The team is consistently kind and proactive, often reminding me of important details or tasks I might have missed. They go above and beyond to ensure every issue is resolved efficiently. I truly appreciate their dedication and support.

Frank J.
Reviews 1

I’m really impressed with Penwell Insurance in Carmel. Heather and Christy strike a perfect balance between professional expertise and a personal touch. They took the time to answer all my questions and followed up on every concern. The transition process was incredibly smooth, and when we filed a claim, they were available 24/7 to handle it exactly as promised. Highly recommend checking them out!

Sanam K.
Reviews 1

Kris has been an excellent agent for us. Her deep knowledge of the insurance industry helped us secure the perfect homeowners policy, and we feel completely confident in her expertise. She truly prioritizes her clients, offering attentive service and maintaining a genuine, honest approach. We love working with Penwell Insurance and can’t imagine going anywhere else. Highly recommended!

Ron Z.
Reviews 1

After comparing options with three other agencies, I decided to go with Penwell Insurance in Carmel for my home, auto, and umbrella coverage. While Erie offered solid policies, the overall experience with Penwell stood out. Kara, my agent, was incredibly professional and responsive. She asked the right questions and gave clear, thorough answers. Even when she needed to check on a detail, she quickly consulted her team and got back to me. Considering the rampant price hikes in the industry right now, I managed to secure excellent rates. The price might have been similar elsewhere, but Kara’s superior service definitely made the difference.

Harry D.
Reviews 1

Heather and Kris consistently deliver exceptional, expert service at Penwell Insurance. As a family-owned agency in Carmel, they have been instrumental in securing the best business liability coverage for our organization. Their independence allows them to shop around effectively, and they were incredibly patient and thorough in guiding us through a recent claim. Beyond just finding the right policies, their advice has been spot-on, and they are always available when we need support. It is refreshing to see a local business like Penwell actively engaged in the community, with Heather involved in the Tipton Chamber of Commerce. We feel lucky to have such a reliable partner right here in town, and I highly recommend them.

Carl Whitworth
Reviews 1

I recently switched to Penwell insurance and I am extremely satisfied with their services. Their staff is friendly and helpful. They explained all the policy details clearly and helped me choose the best coverage for my needs. I would definitely recommend Penwell insurance to anyone looking for reliable insurance.

Helen Bidol
Reviews 1

I have been a customer of Penwell insurance for several years now and I must say that they provide excellent service. Their staff is highly professional and always ready to assist me with any insurance-related queries. I have never faced any issues with their claims process and they always handle everything efficiently. I highly recommend Penwell insurance for all your insurance needs.

Clint Porter
Reviews 1

Penwell insurance has been my go-to insurance company for many years now. I am extremely satisfied with their services. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and always willing to help. They make the insurance process seamless and hassle-free. I highly recommend Penwell insurance for their excellent service and competitive rates. Keep up the good work!

Alborz Toofani
Reviews 1

I am extremely happy with the service provided by Penwell insurance. The staff is friendly and professional. They handle claims efficiently and promptly. Their rates are also very competitive. I would highly recommend Penwell insurance to anyone looking for reliable insurance coverage.

Julia Pavlenko
Reviews 1

I am extremely satisfied with the insurance coverage provided by Penwell insurance. The staff is friendly and professional. They answered all my questions and helped me choose the best policy for my needs. I would definitely recommend them to my friends and family!

John Gulsen
Reviews 1

My experience with Penwell insurance has been amazing! The customer service is top-notch and the company really goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Their rates are also very competitive, which is a big plus. I would give them a thumbs up for their outstanding service👍

Yeden Llc
Reviews 1

I recently had the opportunity to use an insurance provider and came across Penwell insurance. Their website is easy to navigate and provides all the necessary information about their services. I was able to get a quote quickly without any hassle. The best part is that their rates are very competitive and affordable. I am happy with the insurance coverage they provided and would definitely recommend them to others.

Bill Daly
Reviews 1

Penwell insurance provides exceptional service. Their staff is very helpful and knowledgeable. I had a query regarding my policy and they addressed it promptly. I am very happy with their customer service and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for insurance coverage.

Debbie R.
Reviews 1

Penwell Insurance in Carmel has been a fantastic partner for us. Their team consistently delivers prompt, professional support whenever we reach out, making us feel like valued clients rather than just another policy number. They really take the time to source the best rates from multiple providers. Big thanks to Craig and the rest of the team for their genuine care and excellent service!

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Penwell insurance

Address
600 east carmel drive
Categories
Insurance