PennyMac has been an absolute disaster since they acquired my mortgage from Lower. Despite having automatic payments scheduled for the 1st of every month, I get hit with late fees month after month. Calling their customer service is a exercise in frustration. The reps either don’t get it or don’t know what they’re talking about. I’ve literally had them look at my screen showing the active auto-pay setup, only to hang up and claim it’s not there and blame my bank. They then transfer me to a supervisor who just adds more nonsense to the conversation. Everyone seems rude or untrained, interrupting me while spouting contradictions. To make matters worse, I sent a detailed letter in January 2024 explaining the situation, but got zero response—no email, no letter, just more late fees piling up. I’m so fed up I’m filing a small claims complaint. I can’t imagine how they stay in business; if I’d known they were buying my loan, I would’ve picked a completely different lender to avoid this chaos.
What reviewers say about Pennymac
What is Pennymac?
Pennymac is a financial services listed on Trustburn.
What is the official website of Pennymac?
The official website of Pennymac is pennymac.pissedconsumer.com.
How is Pennymac rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, Pennymac has a rating of 1.2 out of 5 based on 13 reviews.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
Dealing with Pennymac feels like talking to a robot. Getting a real person is nearly impossible; every phone number just dumps you into a confusing loop, forcing you to fake interest in a refinance just to bypass the menu. Even then, they couldn't sort out a basic problem. It has been months of sending emails and making calls, yet I get zero replies. Strangely, they have no trouble adding incorrect late fees to my account with impressive efficiency.
I called Pennymac to inquire about the process for purchasing a home from their foreclosure list, providing specific case numbers and details. After receiving a callback, the representative directed me to a website and claimed all my questions would be answered there. However, the landing page was unhelpful, primarily featuring 'related searches' rather than the information I needed. I carefully wrote down the URL while she was on the phone and even verified it phonetically, confirming that the site was indeed useless for my inquiry.
Pennymac is incredibly dishonest. I can’t believe another lender could be this deceitful, especially with all the negative reviews and lawsuits against them. Why are these frauds still allowed to operate? I’m a victim of abuse and had to flee my home. Another person was court-ordered to pay my mortgage but didn’t, leading to foreclosure. I could do nothing about it. Pennymac lied to me repeatedly, even in court, promising to support a short sale so I wouldn’t lose everything. We didn’t object when they sought a relief of stay. Pennymac knew my situation and conducted a foreclosure sale immediately, 90k below market value, in bad faith. They are liars and cheats. I plan to file priority complaints with the Feds. Worst abuser of all. If Trump gets elected, I’m writing him a letter about these bastards!
Pennymac has completely lost my trust. After applying for mortgage assistance back in May 2023, we faced endless delays not caused by us. I spent ages on the phone, resubmitting documents and chasing updates, only to be passed around like a hot potato. I even had to escalate it to the Better Business Bureau just to get a response. Finally, someone from Pennymac’s escalation team called, but they didn’t really fix anything—they just added to my stress. It took three months of constant calling and transfers before I actually spoke to someone who seemed capable. She claimed she’d help with the mortgage assistance but conveniently left the credit reporting issue unresolved and undocumented. That was the last time things went smoothly. Since August, I’ve been fighting to get them to reverse the late payment marks on my credit report as promised. In September, I escalated directly to CEO David Spector. Days later, I got a call from an agent named Angel, who confidently assured me he had authorization to fix the adverse credit reporting for both my husband and me across all three months. He promised a confirmation letter would appear in our account portal by the end of the day. When I checked weeks later, the letter was wrong—it only mentioned correcting June, ignoring May and July as previously confirmed on a recorded call. How do you fix June but ignore the other two months? I am exhausted by the back-and-forth, the contradictions, and the lack of follow-through. I’m thoroughly disgusted with this lender and will keep reporting them until this is properly resolved.
I’ve been overpaying on my principal and escrow, yet Pennymac still claimed I was short on taxes even after the rate increase. To make matters worse, they reported this error to the credit bureaus, causing another hit to my score. This is the second time it has happened. As a VA loan holder, these mistakes are costing me money. The company feels disorganized, and half the staff are impossible to understand when you try to get help.
Pennymac has already pulled my mortgage twice in August, on the 30th and 31st, and getting a refund has been a nightmare. Since this is my VA funds, I expected better handling, but instead, I’ve been getting the runaround for days. They are dragging their feet on the return process and just told me I need to wait 14 business days. For the amount of money involved and the hassle this is causing my family, that timeline feels completely unacceptable.
Pennymac has been a total nightmare from start to finish. We haven't even finished the work on our house, yet we've been sent on a constant merry-go-round of excuses. Now, they are demanding we sign a document essentially admitting that we can't sue them no matter what happens, or else they'll withhold our funds. It feels like they are lying at every turn and now holding our money hostage just to force us into signing away our rights. While I understand why you'd want proof they pay the contractors, saying you can't hold Pennymac accountable for their own actions seems shady at best. The whole experience has been absolutely dreadful, and it’s frustrating to see a company get away with such questionable tactics.
The drama keeps unfolding. Yesterday I detailed my headaches with PennyMac and Insuranceclaimcheck.com. Following their advice, I called right at 8:00 AM PST, aiming to speak with someone from the Resolutions Team. The rep I spoke to yesterday promised it would be easy to connect. Instead, I’ve been stuck on hold for 24 minutes and counting. Honestly, it feels like PennyMac and their partners are just misleading us. They seem less interested in actually helping homeowners than in holding onto our cash. I’m practically pleading for my own money back so I can install an air conditioner in the house I currently live in, even though I’m just waiting to buy it one day—technically, it still belongs to PennyMac. It’s absurd that I have to beg them to use my insurance funds to repair their asset. Meanwhile, if I moved out without that AC or kitchen appliances, I’d be the one at fault. I really need that insurance check to cover the AC installation now; I can’t just pay for a major unit in installments.
Pennymac finally resolved the issue and sent an apology, but the journey there was exhausting. I’m currently waiting for the final payment, though I haven’t heard back from them regarding calls, emails, or letters in the past. Given how difficult this process was, I plan to switch mortgage companies as soon as I can and hope to avoid any further emergencies with them. In June, lightning struck my home in Mississippi, destroying my downstairs AC unit and kitchen appliances. With temperatures soaring over 100 degrees, I needed to expedite the insurance check payable to my husband and Pennymac. The process felt like a battle. I had to create a profile on a third-party site, only to find their procedures unsatisfactory. After uploading documentation and an estimate for the $15,000 AC unit to justify a lump-sum release, I kept calling to ensure everything was in order. Instead of a check, I received a text asking for an inspection appointment—without any explanation. When I called, I learned they had issued a partial payment of less than $4,000, which isn’t enough to cover the full replacement cost. Despite numerous calls and chats, the claims department couldn’t help. It seemed like there were no managers, and the resolutions team was overwhelmed. I waited on hold for over an hour with no answer. Every department I reached simply redirected me back to claims. Their responses were inadequate: no corporate number, no formal complaint process, and vague promises that someone would call in 24-48 hours. Meanwhile, I’m stuck in a house with 91-degree nights, dealing with peeling flooring and humidity damage, with no clear path to resolution.
I wouldn’t recommend PENNYMAC loans. They increased my monthly payment by $100 due to insurance costs, added $490 more for taxes this year, and are also trying to recoup funds from the previous year. Stay far away from this company!
Pennymac is a masterclass in confusion. Every time I called for an update, I received a completely different story. I had to constantly demand a supervisor or a transfer to the actual department handling my case, only to be met with vague promises of a callback or the excuse that the department "doesn't have a phone." I never imagined I’d have such a headache dealing with a major bank. My insurance company actually had it together, which made the contrast even more frustrating. Losing a home is stressful enough, but Pennymac makes it significantly harder. I’m looking into refinancing with a different bank to escape this mess. Stay away from Pennymac.
I am writing to express my deep frustration with PennyMac, whose mishandling of my mortgage services has caused significant financial and health-related stress. In October 2022, PennyMac failed to pay my homeowners insurance premium and neglected to inform me of this error. Consequently, I remained without coverage for months until I discovered the lapse in February 2023 when my insurance premiums spiked. As a 100% permanently disabled veteran who served with pride, I have suffered two back-to-back strokes with lasting mental deficits, making this ordeal particularly draining. PennyMac refuses to cover the resulting premium increase, which exceeds $3000. Furthermore, despite assurances during my 2022 payment modification that my rates were fixed, my payments are rising again. The customer service experience is equally disappointing. Every call results in endless transfers between insurance, escrow, and collections departments, with each unit blaming the other. On March 6, 2023, they even sent a letter stating I lacked insurance, highlighting their disorganization. When I contacted insurers like Progressive, ASI, and Nationwide, they confirmed that PennyMac’s error was the root cause. Their response was dismissive: they admitted fault but expect me to shop around and absorb the costs. It is exhausting to feel that the company does not care about its customers, especially veterans like myself who are already managing substantial medical challenges.
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About Pennymac
- Website
- pennymac.pissedconsumer.com
- Categories
- Financial services