Old Barn Restaurant

4.1 · 463 reviews
L
LINDA CALVELAGE
Reviews 1
2020-09-28 00:30

Food was ok, take from the bottom to get warm eggs...

Food was ok, take from the bottom to get warm eggs. Selection was good & our waitress was good. The people at the omlet station need supervision, one was working 2 emplyees not so much. The girl making waffles was playing with her phone & sat it down on the prep table - cell phones are full of germ...

Read full review

J
John Geise
Reviews 1
2020-09-23 15:48

The Old Barn ain't what she used to be. I am truly...

The Old Barn ain't what she used to be. I am truly sorry to say that. The table that our waitness was assigned asked what we would like to drink, That was the last time she came to our table, not even a menu, not even mentioning the buffet, the various selections of the buffet. When we walked in, ba...

Read full review

Z
Zuum
Reviews 1
2020-09-17 23:18

I have going here for a long time. This was the fi...

I have going here for a long time. This was the first time since the the menu change. Service was great, some new and interesting items on the menu. Food was good. I had the the big gooey cookie, which was good, but could have been more fresh from the oven, it seemed a bit too cool. Good selection o...

Read full review

E
elizabeth simindinger
Reviews 1
2020-09-17 08:27

I was there with a friend recently. The website sa...

I was there with a friend recently. The website said they were open till 9. We got there about 7:45. The doors were locked. A couple just happened to be coming out. A waitress came to the door. She said their winter hours were till 8 or they close early if they weren't busy. The website said nothing...

Read full review

K
Kayla Roop
Reviews 1
2020-09-07 20:55

I went there today with my lab from apollo career ...

I went there today with my lab from apollo career cenrer and the food was horrible as well as the service. One of the waitresses took my plate without even asking if I was done with it and my fork was still on it. Then another one of the waitresses assumed I had Pepsi so she poured Pepsi into my ha...

Read full review

J
Jennifer W
Reviews 1
2020-09-06 09:03

Just went to the New Old Barn Restaurant and Grill...

Just went to the New Old Barn Restaurant and Grill and let me say it s a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE!! The menu, drinks and look of the place is totally worth the trip. The food was fabulous (deep fried deviled eggs-who d thought ?) and the bar area was really cool- didn t feel like I was in Lim...

Read full review

R
Rebecca Holbrook
Reviews 1
2020-09-05 11:04

Best brunch n dinner buffet in Lima. One of our fa...

Best brunch n dinner buffet in Lima. One of our favorite places to eat. Fast forward to now. I loved this place. Drove hour n a half to eat there. Was all around great place to eat,but recently the next generation took it over n did lot of change. They lessened the Sunday brunch to half the size n r...

Read full review

M
Michael C
Reviews 1
2020-09-03 04:55

First, the remodeling looks great. The original lo...

First, the remodeling looks great. The original look was cool too, just modernized now. I ordered the 18 Oz ribeye steak- medium, without ever having one here. So a $26 risk I was unsure of, but rest assured it was well worth it. Actually cooked correctly, seasoned nice. Nice, clean place and the st...

Read full review

B
Bryce paul
Reviews 1
2020-08-26 12:29

The service was average but anything you could eat...

The service was average but anything you could eat was terrible.the staff was caring but anything they didn't prepare in the kitchen was brought from the buffet.All in all wouldn't feed it to the raccoon living under my house. Wouldn't go back if they payed me. Even the cookies tasted worse than my ...

Read full review

C
Cathy Borgmeier
Reviews 1
2020-08-26 09:11

The upgrades to the restaurant look amazing and st...

The upgrades to the restaurant look amazing and staff was so friendly. We had a large party so we got a few appetizers and some flights of their local beer to decide what we wanted, they were all great! I really loved the fried pickles. Salad bar is smaller but selections are much higher end and s...

Read full review

J
Jeffrey Mayer
Reviews 1
2020-08-18 13:01

Usually the food is very good, not the case today....

Usually the food is very good, not the case today. Very little selection, of the selection items were not there. Of the items that were there they had been there for awhile and tasted awful. Plates were dirty and there were no bowls for the soup until we were leaving. Will not be going back any...

Read full review

G
Glen Sawyer
Reviews 1
2020-08-12 02:56

I'm not a buffet guy. But this is no ordinary buff...

I'm not a buffet guy. But this is no ordinary buffet. Most places with dinners and desserts this good put Amish somewhere in their name. All the food is cooked up fresh. The soups and desserts scream homemade! And the atmosphere is quaintly unique.

We've went there for years and never been disapp...

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn