I found the My Cookie Journey recipe to be really solid. I made a few tweaks: I used brown sugar instead of white, and I cranked up the cinnamon and ginger. Other than that, I stuck to the instructions exactly. They turned out great, especially if you’re looking for something a bit more indulgent.
What reviewers say about My Cookie Journey
What is My Cookie Journey?
My Cookie Journey is a business listed on Trustburn. My Cookie Journey is a blog run by Barbara Hall, a retired IT professional, that shares homemade cookie recipes she develops, bakes, and photographs from her kitchen.
What is the official website of My Cookie Journey?
The official website of My Cookie Journey is mycookiejourney.com.
How is My Cookie Journey rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, My Cookie Journey has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 9 reviews.
Is My Cookie Journey on social media?
My Cookie Journey has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
Hi there! I wanted to ask if I could swap the orange for lemon in my order? It’s not in season here in Lebanon just yet, so I’ll have to wait for the next batch. Thanks in advance, and hope you’re having a wonderful day!
The shortbread cookies from My Cookie Journey brought back fond memories of the Pecan Sandies I loved as a kid (I’m 80). They reminded me of the only treats we’d buy at the store back then, along with Fig Newtons. I baked a half-batch and found the icing portion far too generous for my taste. I’m also left wondering: does it truly matter whether you use unsalted butter? And is parchment paper really necessary when the recipe calls for such a rich amount of butter?
I made this dough for My Cookie Journey and found it a bit plain—adding a pinch of salt would have really enhanced the taste. The fig filling, on the other hand, is fantastic. It’s a simple and hassle-free recipe overall.
Barbara, these cookies turned out delicious! I’ve been curious about cardamom since I don’t use it often, and this recipe really showcases its flavor perfectly. The taste is subtle and refreshing, with just a hint of orange lingering in the back. I didn’t have any regular oranges, so I used a few small mandarins instead. I only made half the batch this time. I rolled the dough into a 1.5-inch log, sliced it into 14 cookies, and baked them for 14 minutes. I topped them all with turbinado sugar, and then got creative: I drizzled some with melted dark chocolate, dipped others halfway in chocolate while they cooled, and left a few plain. Thanks for sharing this great recipe!
Absolutely obsessed with My Cookie Journey’s shortbread! I waited until the next day to bake these and they were phenomenal. I rolled the dough thicker than usual and worried about spreading due to the high butter content, but they held their shape perfectly. The result was incredibly delicious and exactly the kind of perfect shortbread I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this recipe!
I had a great experience with the shortbread from My Cookie Journey. The flavor is lovely, though the finished cookies are quite small. One thing to note: the instructions just tell you to divide the dough into two logs without specifying dimensions, so my first attempt was a bit tricky. Next time, I’ll shape one log to be about 10 inches long and 2 inches thick, then chill and slice them into 1/4-inch rounds. I also recommend sprinkling fine sugar sand on top right after they come out of the oven for a nice touch.
Shirley here. I’ve spent years hunting for a cookie recipe that matches the ones my Mom used to make. After she passed, that specific flavor felt lost to me until my sister found this gem. My Cookie Journey has captured that nostalgic taste perfectly. I’m planning to bake them very soon and will definitely share a photo and my thoughts. They look and taste just like my Mother’s, and I’m so grateful you shared this. Happy Holidays!
I baked these cookies on a pleasant summer evening and I’m really pleased with the result. The step-by-step guide provided by My Cookie Journey was clear and made the whole process a breeze. My friends absolutely loved them—they were impressed by both the presentation and the incredible taste. It’s the perfect indulgence for warmer weather, and I’ll definitely be making them again. I’m already looking forward to trying more recipes from this site.
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About My Cookie Journey
My Cookie Journey is a blog run by Barbara Hall, a retired IT professional, that shares homemade cookie recipes she develops, bakes, and photographs from her kitchen. The site features recipe indexes, seasonal collections such as summer cookies, and categories organized by ingredient and type, including cookies with chocolate, cream cheese, nuts, or no eggs. Hall updates and improves recipes based on reader feedback, and visitors can subscribe to a newsletter and follow the blog on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest. The site also includes a shop section and information about the author, whose recipes have been featured in regional magazines.
- Website
- mycookiejourney.com