Login or sign up
For business

ModernThirst

4.3· 128 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.3/ 5

Based on 128 reviews

536%
462%
32%
20%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about ModernThirst

Based on 128 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Across the cross-section of reviews, customers generally describe ModernThirst's offerings favorably, highlighting skilled blending, approachable and complex flavor profiles, and good value, though a few note certain expressions are polarizing or merely average rather than standouts.
What is ModernThirst?

ModernThirst is a food & beverages listed on Trustburn. ModernThirst is a media website focused on bourbon, whiskey, and other distilled spirits, providing news, reviews, podcasts, and videos.

What is the official website of ModernThirst?

The official website of ModernThirst is modernthirst.com.

How is ModernThirst rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, ModernThirst has a rating of 4.3 out of 5 based on 128 reviews.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Timothy
Reviews 1

ModernThirst really knocked it out of the park with this bourbon. It’s clear the team has a strong vision for their craft. The depth of flavor here is impressive, especially for a relatively new player in the game. A fantastic start from this producer that shows a lot of promise.

Wes
Reviews 1

As a ModernThirst enthusiast, I find the Ardbeg finish to be a polarizing experience. The rum cask influence is quite prominent, which might not appeal to everyone, but it certainly isn't a bad dram. It’s an average peated Scotch with a distinct character—definitely worth sampling a pour before committing to a purchase.

Wes
Reviews 1

ModernThirst offers a truly distinctive dram that feels like a conversation starter. If you enjoy notes of orange and spice, or simply want a bottle that stands out when sharing with friends, this is a solid choice. It’s definitely worth trying before you commit to a purchase.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has captured the essence of that classic Heaven Hill wheated bourbon profile beautifully. The spirit itself is genuinely excellent, but the pricing feels steep—it’s nearly double what you’d pay for other Heavenly Hill expressions, which makes me hesitate to fully commit to the cost.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst really stands out from the usual crowd. Their unique combination of four finishing techniques creates a distinct flavor profile that is both delicious and highly satisfying. For the affordable price, you get a truly exceptional experience that is well worth trying.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s Watershed bourbon is a refreshing change of pace. Distilled using a pot still with a unique spelt mash bill, it offers a character that feels like bourbon taking on an Irish whiskey style. A solid choice for those looking for something different, easily earning a high score.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has really elevated the game for Irish Whiskey enthusiasts. This bottle offers a clean, sweet finish that feels like a genuine upgrade from the typical offerings. It’s clearly well-crafted, with the perfect aging and proof, all while remaining reasonably priced.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has really nailed it with this release—it’s easily the standout from the Rhetoric Lineup. While it leans heavily into the oak-forward style, making it an excellent choice for those who love sweet, caramel-heavy profiles, it does feel a bit over-extracted from the barrel.

Wes
Reviews 1

ModernThirst really knows their stuff when it comes to Islay selections. The Ardbeg Uigeadail has swiftly earned its place among my top picks, living up to the high praise it’s gotten. If you are a fan of smoky profiles with that rich sherry influence, this one is an absolute must-try.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst really knows how to curate exceptional spirits. This barrel-proof Elijah Craig is a standout for me. The fact that it’s a bit lower in ABV than usual for this style actually works in its favor, making it incredibly smooth. You get an amazing aroma upfront and a finish that just lingers pleasantly. Easily a 92-point bottle.

Bill
Reviews 1

Pinning a score of 81 on a bottle that costs around $20 feels unfair given the spirit's youth. At just two years old, ModernThirst's offering is clearly premature. The result is a cloying alcohol bite that overshadows the flavor profile, making the experience feel rushed rather than refined.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s take on this spirit is a real statement maker. It delivers a massive, punchy flavor profile that feels like Blanton’s cranked up to eleven. While traditionalists might miss the subtlety of the standard bottling, the sheer intensity here is undeniable. A bold, confident choice for those who want their whiskey to have serious presence. 9/10

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst nailed the presentation with this release. Bottled straight from the cask at full strength, it captures the true character of Old Scout bourbon. The maturation process hits the sweet spot, and the finish is exceptionally smooth. It’s a high-quality pour that deserves attention, though limited availability might make you wish you had grabbed more before they vanished.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst delivers a no-nonsense spirit that stays true to its roots. Unlike many competitors who inflate prices beyond the value of their ingredients, they keep things honest and straightforward. It’s not trying to be overly complex or pretentious, which makes it a refreshing choice for those who appreciate clarity and quality without the markup.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s Old Ezra is a no-nonsense bourbon that delivers a bold experience with its high proof. While the complexity might be lacking, the straightforward character makes it a reliable choice for another round. It’s a bit pricey for what you get, but the quality still shines through.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s latest release certainly takes a different approach than the classic 1792 profile. While it avoids being overly sweet, the experience feels somewhat brief. The palate is notably dry, and the finish doesn't linger long enough to fully satisfy. Ultimately, it feels a bit less compelling than its reputation suggests.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s curation of Brown-Forman’s Old Forester Birthday Bourbon is spot on. This 15th edition delivers a surprisingly fruity profile that fits perfectly into the lineup. It’s a crisp, complex 97 proof bourbon that is incredibly easy to drink, making it a well-deserved highlight.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst nailed it with this bottle; it actually tastes better than the 17 Year Old George Dickel. The only downside is the 28-year age statement—it’s clearly been in the cask a bit too long, resulting in an overabundance of oak that drowns out the natural sweetness.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst offers a fantastic deal for anyone who enjoys wheated bourbons. It’s rare to find a wheater with this much age bottled at such a respectable proof. Luxco could have taken many different approaches with this expression, but they’ve delivered a bottle that stands out on the shelf for its value and character.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst fans should approach their first bourbon from the new distillery with realistic expectations—it’s easy to be let down by the result. The flavor profile feels a bit young, leaving you with an odd, slightly disjointed finish that doesn't quite hit the mark.

Bill
Reviews 1

I expected a bit more personality from ModernThirst’s selection. This bourbon isn’t bad, but it’s certainly not memorable. It’s under-aged and under-proofed, leaving me with a spirit that feels generic and forgettable. It’s hard to find anything truly great here, even though they have a wide range of Old Forester labels. Overall, just an average pour.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has a nice selection if you are looking for something with a bit of character. I tried the Michter's Toasted Barrel and it definitely leans into that oak and smoke profile. It wasn't quite my personal cup of tea—felt a bit too heavy on the smoke for my taste—but it is certainly an interesting experience worth trying for those who enjoy that specific style.

Bill
Reviews 1

Picked up a bottle from ModernThirst primarily for the novelty, and I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised. The liquid itself is genuinely good quality—definitely comparable to Jim Beam Bonded in terms of taste profile. It’s a fun keepsake, but it’s not just empty packaging; the bourbon inside actually holds its own.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst delivers a rye that hits all the right notes with its proof, color, and flavor profile, making it a genuinely solid choice. The only real caveat is the pricing; at nearly double the cost of the widely available Heaven Hill Rittenhouse Rye Bottled-in-Bond, it’s hard to justify as the better value despite its quality.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst offers something truly unique at modernthirst.com. This spirit doesn't fit neatly into the bourbon or Scotch categories, making it a polarizing choice that might not appeal to casual drinkers but will certainly intrigue seasoned whiskey enthusiasts. While the price point is steep, it’s certainly worth sampling to see if it challenges your palate.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst nailed the aromatic complexity with this one—it’s got one of the most robust bouquets you’ll find right out of the gate. The Double Oaked profile really shines through, though the finish trails off just a bit at the end. A solid pick for fans of the style.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst's latest offering has a distinct sourness that lingers throughout the entire sip. It’s an unexpected flavor profile that makes the drinking experience quite difficult to enjoy. While the character is unique, it ultimately falls short of delivering a pleasant taste.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst’s curation really shines with this pour. The blend of straight bourbon and rye, selected with input from Celebrity Chef Edward Lee, makes for a spirit that actually elevates a meal rather than just sitting alongside it. It’s a thoughtful pick that balances complexity with approachability.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has delivered another compelling option to their lineup. This bourbon’s narrative is genuinely engaging, making it a standout choice for collectors and story-seekers. While the flavor profile is pleasant, it doesn’t quite justify the premium price tag for those seeking a truly exceptional tasting experience. Still, it’s a worthy addition to your shelf.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has really nailed it with this rye. It’s got that bold, spicy kick paired with a strong citrus profile that just works. If you’re a rye fan looking for something with character that’s also worth the money, this is a solid pick. Easily scores a 9 out of 10 for me.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst offers a pleasant start, but the finish feels like it unravels a bit too quickly. It could really benefit from some additional aging to develop more distinct barrel notes and mellow out that prominent yeast character. Still, for the asking price, it holds its own as a decent choice.

Bill
Reviews 1

ModernThirst has delivered a robust and distinct interpretation of the classic Four Roses profile. This expression leans heavily into bold, almost harsh notes, with a pronounced floral essence that echoes the character of many Four Roses bottlings. It’s a powerful take on the style, showcasing the unique impact of the Q yeast. A solid 89/100 for those who appreciate a strong, aromatic spirit.

Bill
Reviews 1

I recently picked up a bottle of 2014 Birthday Bourbon from ModernThirst, and it truly deserves the hype. The craftsmanship is evident in its exceptional balance and smooth profile. If you appreciate fine spirits, I highly recommend enjoying this expression neat to fully experience its nuances.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About ModernThirst

ModernThirst is a media website focused on bourbon, whiskey, and other distilled spirits, providing news, reviews, podcasts, and videos. The site covers whiskey releases from brands including Four Gate Whiskey Company, Old Forester, and Basil Hayden, as well as press releases from related industries such as a Guinness rugby partnership. It also features tasting videos, cocktail and food content, hot sauce coverage, and recipes. The site organizes content by spirit type, including bourbon, rye, Scotch, Irish whisky, and beer, and maintains a large catalog of individual whiskey reviews. It offers advertising opportunities and outlines a sample policy and patron support for its content.