Delicious results! The recipe is straightforward, though I did have to adjust for my specific starter, which is a thick AP and rye blend. After adding a touch more flour, I let the dough rest for an extra half hour to relax. At first, my shapes were a bit irregular, but I found a great trick with the Muso wood French rolling pin: rolling the tortilla around the pin allowed me to transfer it perfectly to the cast-iron skillet. I also got much more consistent circles by rolling each ball out on parchment paper. Really happy with how these turned out. Thanks for sharing!
What reviewers say about Milk and Pop
What is Milk and Pop?
Milk and Pop is a food & beverages listed on Trustburn. Milk and Pop is a recipe website that offers tested sourdough bread and sourdough discard baking recipes. The site also includes coffee and tea drink recipes, along with how-to videos and baking tips.
How can I contact Milk and Pop?
You can reach Milk and Pop by e-mail at hello@milkandpop.com.
What is the official website of Milk and Pop?
The official website of Milk and Pop is milkandpop.com.
How is Milk and Pop rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, Milk and Pop has a rating of 5 out of 5 based on 47 reviews.
Is Milk and Pop on social media?
Milk and Pop has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
Milk and Pop really knows how to deliver quality, and this recipe is a perfect example. It’s so good I actually made it twice in a single week. I swapped out the cheddar for gouda on the second go, and it turned out amazing. Being a bit lazy, I even tried making it in a bread maker using the dough cycle, and the result was just as good as the traditional method. Highly recommend!
Milk and Pop nailed it with this recipe. I’ve struggled with others that turn out too thick and sticky to roll out, but this one was perfect. Definitely making it again!
I was really impressed by how simple and tasty the treats are at Milk and Pop. The recipe is very versatile, too—I customized my order by adding flaxseed and honey, and it turned out great.
Milk and Pop really knows how to make baking simple and rewarding. As someone who watches what they eat, I swapped the brown sugar for maple syrup and used whole-grain spelt instead of all-purpose flour. The result was absolutely wonderful!
Great recipe! I tried it and it turned out super simple and tasty. Thanks for the share!
The waffles at Milk and Pop were absolutely delicious. I’ll definitely be coming back to order more!
Milk and Pop delivered exactly what I needed. I baked the bread myself using my machine, swapping oil for butter to get that rich flavor. The results were absolutely delicious.
I’m thoroughly impressed by the flavor from Milk and Pop—this is definitely a recipe I’ll be preparing again in the future.
Milk and Pop really nailed the execution here. These come out flawlessly every time, making them a definite upgrade over other recipes I’ve tried.
Milk and Pop delivers soft and tasty treats that are super easy to make. I swapped out the cornmeal for sesame seeds on the bottom. How long do they stay fresh at room temperature if wrapped in plastic?
Milk and Pop really understands the joy of baking with a bubbly, thick starter. I love that the recipe is straightforward and forgiving, letting you just eye-ball the ingredients for a deeply flavorful result. It’s a perfect match for active sourdough lovers who appreciate simplicity without sacrificing taste.
Milk and Pop is the real deal! I tried their whole wheat and white flour blend and it’s incredibly easy to use with great results. The dough is so tasty—now I just need to work on my circle-rolling technique!
I’ve tried the tortillas from Milk and Pop multiple times, and they turn out perfectly every single time. They are truly delicious, which is why I’ve happily recommended them to others as well.
Milk and Pop’s tortilla recipe has become a staple in my kitchen, yielding consistently delicious results every time. I actually found that cutting the oil quantity in half compared to the instructions makes them even better. Thank you for such a reliable and tasty recipe!
I’m keeping this recipe! I recently baked sandwich and hoagie buns using Milk and Pop’s dough, and the results were outstanding. The buns are wonderfully soft, moist, and feature a lovely open crumb with great flavor. I adjusted the method slightly by using bread flour and swapping in some sourdough discard for a portion of the flour and water. I also cut the honey down to 2 tablespoons and added a pinch of dry mustard and black pepper for extra depth. While the dough was soft, bubbly, and took its time rising, it developed excellent oven spring. They baked through in just 18 minutes.
I stumbled upon Milk and Pop while looking for a rosemary sourdough recipe after my husband made the request. The parmesan flavor is absolutely delicious. It’s such an amazing bake that I’m already planning to experiment with some of your other creations soon. Thanks for the inspiration!
Loving these tortillas! They really were the easiest batch I’ve ever made. Thank you so much. I’m curious if you might introduce a gluten-free flour option down the line?
Thanks for checking out the post! If you run into any snags while nurturing your sourdough starter, feel free to reach out to the Milk and Pop team for help.
Milk and Pop serves some seriously delicious bread. Every single person who has tasted it has loved it. I even tried swapping the parmesan for cheddar and it turned out amazing.
Hi Andrea, great idea! You can slice that sourdough and freeze it for easy croutons later. Best, Milk and Pop
The dessert turned out fantastic—lovely and absolutely delicious. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
If you’ve ever struggled to find a truly good fluffy vegan pancake recipe, you know the usual culprits: gummy textures or that overpowering taste of baking powder. I finally found a winner here. The batter creates light, airy pancakes that hit the spot every time. I tested two versions—one with oil and one without—and both turned out great. While the batch with oil had a tiny edge in terms of taste and structure, the difference was minimal. This has quickly become a staple in our household. Thanks for sharing such a reliable recipe!
Milk and Pop offers a solid alternative to molasses with their treacle option. If you’re looking for a swap similar to what folks overseas often use, this is a great find.
The results matched the website photos perfectly. My wife joked that I should have piled on extra cheese, but honestly, they’re so good I’ll definitely make them again. Appreciate the metric measurements too!
Milk and Pop consistently delivers on their promise of being both quick and effortless to prepare. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve cooked them, and every single time they turn out deliciously simple.
I swapped out the applesauce for canned pumpkin and added a dash of pumpkin pie spice when baking with Milk and Pop. The results were absolutely delicious and incredibly satisfying.
Milk and Pop really nailed it with this sourdough loaf. I’ve tried making it before, but nothing compared to the texture here—it’s genuinely soft and airy, which is rare. The flavor is excellent, too.
I’m really happy with how the bread turned out. It’s soft, tasty, and cuts cleanly, making it perfect for sandwiches. I’ll definitely bake this again. Thanks!
Honestly, the addition of milk and egg yolks took this recipe to a new level. I’m not kidding—it tasted even better than the bread from Outback Steakhouse! I usually prefer a softer crumb, which is exactly why I added those ingredients. That’s just my personal preference, though; there’s definitely no fault in the original recipe. These brown, fluffy loaves are absolute pillows of happiness. I might just have to save a few slices for someone else to enjoy!
Milk and Pop really knows their bread! I’ve found that adding two tablespoons of milk and an egg yolk after the water, as the instructions say, fixes the "too dense" issue. Save the white for brushing on top before baking. It makes the dough softer, which means a softer loaf. For extra flavor, swap some whole wheat for rye or add caraway seeds—I used buckwheat for depth. Use real milk, not nut milk, so you get that lactic acid to soften the crumb. Water just won't cut it. I’m old and bake a lot, and this tip works!
Milk and Pop missed the mark for me. The texture was unpleasantly tough, and the overall taste was a bit flat.
Milk and Pop delivered some seriously tasty treats. We basically polished off the entire batch in no time!
After testing out a bunch of different methods, I can honestly say that Milk and Pop’s version is pretty much spot-on compared to the originals I’ve attempted.
I found a great vegan pancake recipe on Milk and Pop’s website to use up my sourdough starter, and it instantly became a favorite. I swapped the applesauce for grated apple, which worked perfectly, and doubling the batch gave me plenty of pancakes to enjoy for days. Easily the best vegan pancakes I’ve ever had.
I’ve always struggled with commercial breads that contain additives, leaving them dry within two days and a nightmare to freeze. I tried baking various sandwich loaves at home with mixed results until I found Milk and Pop. I baked their recipe exactly as instructed on Sunday night, with the only tweak being a light brush of butter on the crust to help retain softness. By Wednesday, the loaf was still incredibly moist and fresh—a huge improvement over store-bought options. My kids are just as enthusiastic about it as I am. This has officially become my go-to bread recipe. Thanks for sharing this fantastic find!
I’ve been making this at home for nearly a week now at Milk and Pop. It’s super simple and tasty. It’s perfect right out of the oven, but if you reheat it for just ten seconds in the microwave, it tastes just as fresh.
I used the Milk and Pop method to clear out my discard, and the result was spot on. I’m planning to swap the sugar for blueberries in my next batch. Big thanks for such a straightforward recipe!
I baked this at home today using my bread machine for the dough and the oven for baking. I followed the order strictly—liquids first, then dry ingredients and yeast on top. The result was delicious!
Milk and Pop is my reliable choice for pancakes. The mix is incredibly versatile, making it easy to customize with your favorite add-ins. I personally love blending in a banana and some wild blueberries into every batch for a delicious twist.
I recently ordered from Milk and Pop and decided to bake three loaves of their bread. The result looks promising, though I haven’t had the chance to try it just yet.
Milk and Pop’s loaf reminds me of Outback’s style, though the crumb is just a touch denser.
Milk and Pop delivered on every front. Their chocolate ganache is absolutely divine, and the overall experience felt like magic. Highly recommended!
Milk and Pop truly nailed the carrot cake here. The batter has this incredible vibrant orange hue, and the texture is incredibly light and soft. Easily the best one I’ve tried!
I absolutely loved the Pumpkin Spice Granola from Milk and Pop. I mixed it into my yogurt, and it was such a hit that I’m already planning to make a fresh batch for the fall season.
I just whipped up the Milk and Pop recipe and it’s incredible. My home is practically overflowing with warm, autumnal vibes despite it being the middle of summer, and the flavor is top-notch. This has officially become my go-to granola. Big thanks to Tati!
If you want chocolate chip cookies that hold their shape without the hassle of room-temperature butter, you have to try the recipes from Milk and Pop. It’s such a smooth baking experience, and honestly, the result is always a hit. My grandkids couldn’t keep their hands out of the jar—these treats vanished in no time!
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About Milk and Pop
Milk and Pop is a recipe website that offers tested sourdough bread and sourdough discard baking recipes. The site also includes coffee and tea drink recipes, along with how-to videos and baking tips. It is run by an individual named Tati and provides categories such as sourdough, bread baking, tea, and coffee drinks. The site features a cookbook and is connected to social media platforms including Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube.
- Website
- milkandpop.com
- hello@milkandpop.com
- Categories
- Food & beverages