Login or sign up
For business

Mike's Pizza

4.3· 8 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.3/ 5

Based on 8 reviews

550%
425%
325%
20%
10%
Ask AI

Questions about Mike's Pizza

Based on 8 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 6 days ago

What is Mike's Pizza?

Mike's Pizza is a restaurant located at 50 West Town Street in West Jefferson, Ohio, specializing in custom-made pizzas, subs, wings, Mexican food, and Reubens. The business offers both delivery and pickup services, with seating available for small parties or those who prefer to eat out. Customers can place orders by calling the store directly at 614-879-4040, which allows for computer-assisted order entry to save time.

How can I customize my pizza order?

The restaurant differentiates itself by allowing customers to specify their crust thickness, ranging from thin and crispy to thick or in between, with Mike's default being thin and crispy if no preference is given. The dough is hand-rolled to customer specifications, and the sauce and dough contain no added sugar. This custom approach ensures each pizza is made exactly to the customer's taste preferences.

What do reviewers praise most about the food?

Multiple reviewers consistently praise the light, fluffy, and perfectly crispy crusts, as well as the tangy and flavorful sauces. Customers frequently mention that the pizzas are hot, cheesy, and full of flavor, making them a go-to choice for delicious meals. The consistent quality and fresh ingredients prepared to perfection are also highly appreciated by regular patrons.

What specific menu items are highlighted on the website?

The business's own website highlights its extensive menu, which includes tacos, taco salads, and burritos alongside its signature fried foods and pizzas. It also promotes a fantastic Reuben as a standout item that customers should try. The website emphasizes that Mike's subs are the best in town, positioning them as a key competitive advantage.

How can I place an order online?

Customers can order online through a computer system that allows direct order entry into the store's computer, eliminating the need to wait on hold. This feature streamlines the ordering process for those who prefer digital convenience. Additionally, the business offers both delivery and pickup options to accommodate different customer needs.

What should a first-time customer know before visiting?

A first-time customer should know that the default crust style is thin and crispy unless specified otherwise. They can also take advantage of the custom ordering process to tailor their pizza to their exact specifications. The business caters to a wide range of tastes, from thin crust enthusiasts to those who prefer thicker options.

What services does the business offer?

The business offers a variety of services including delivery, pickup, and dine-in seating for small parties. Customers can choose between these options based on their convenience and preference. The flexibility in service modes ensures that the restaurant can meet the needs of different types of customers.

How does the business handle dough preparation?

The business uses a dough roller for efficiency but still maintains the tradition of hand-rolling each pizza to customer specifications. This hybrid approach combines modern efficiency with personalized service. The commitment to custom rolling ensures that each pizza meets the unique preferences of the customer.

What marketing claims does the business make?

The business's own website states that Mike's subs are the best in town, which is a claim made by the business itself. This statement is presented as a key selling point on their official site. While other aspects are supported by reviews, this specific claim comes directly from the business's marketing.

What technological features does the business offer?

The business provides a computer system that allows customers to enter orders directly, reducing wait times. This feature is highlighted on their website as a way to improve the customer experience. It is one of the specific technological features mentioned that sets them apart from traditional ordering methods.

What is the founder's background?

The business has a history of making pizza since Mike began at age 14 at Mary's Pizza, and he has been a lifetime resident of West Jefferson. This personal connection to the area and the craft is evident in the business's approach to pizza making. The founder's background adds a personal touch to the restaurant's identity.

Where is Mike's Pizza located?

Mike's Pizza is located at 50 W Town St, West Jefferson, Ohio.

How can I contact Mike's Pizza?

You can reach Mike's Pizza by phone at 6148794040.

How is Mike's Pizza rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Mike's Pizza has a rating of 4.3 out of 5 based on 8 reviews.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Mike's Pizza

Address
50 W Town St