Login or sign up
For business

Five Islands Maine

4.7· 400 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.7/ 5

Based on 400 reviews

579%
414%
31%
23%
13%
Sean Blatchley
Reviews 1

The lobster roll was excellent - no mayo etc. Just a generous pile of pure delicious lobster on a buttery bun. Get here early, the lines are ridiculous. My daughter had the steamers and those were perfect also - good size portion and steamed perfectly. I'd come here every chance I get.

Susan Heroux
Reviews 1

Great atmosphere, good food, although they did not have the large lobsters advertised on their website period a huge disappointment for me. The clams were extremely delicious and the onion rings as one other review said are not to be missed I totally agree. All in all good seating good service a very good experience

Arthur Dymko
Reviews 1

1. Pretty expensive.
2. My girlfriend's chowder was like fish tasting milk.
3. Lobster was definitely not best I had.
4. So damn unsanitary it's scary that restaurants like this can even operate. Joints in NYC look better next to this place.

As i write this review I'm sitting on the throne feeling nauseous.

Robb Kidd
Reviews 1

The only good thing about this place was the views. $22 for a clam basket quite frankly I have had better fried clams at a gas station in Nebraska. My wife's $18 lobster roll was underwhelming to say the least. Of note, did not have the lobster which is served in the other building. If you are looking for a quality meal drive off the five islands and head to Bath or Brunswick.

Rita Canole
Reviews 1

Vacationing in Georgetown this week and could not wait to eat there....big disappointment.....ordered scallops that were overpriced as well as overcooked and dry.....my husband had big bellied clams that somehow were tough and missing the big bellies.....paid 52.00 and ate 3 scallops and threw the rest away....based on the reviews, I'm starting to think I picked the wrong day to eat here or people just don't know what good seafood is....

Dan Kimmet
Reviews 1

Always the freshest lobster. The lobster boats deliver fresh lobster every 15-30 mins. U can watch them while eating the best lobster on their huge outside deck. Many sizes to pick from, my last one was just under 3lbs. Doesn't get any better. Well worth the drive, beautiful views.

Hannah Olson
Reviews 1

Went on July 4th for dinner, ordered fish and chips ($16.95), lobster roll ($18.95), and some onion rings. Everything was very tasty, especially the onion rings. I like that they have vinegar packets for the fries and a good selection of cooler drinks including Maine Root sodas. As far as covid-19 precautions, they have marked spacing for the line and a plastic shield at the register; however, mask wearing was inconsistent among both patrons and staff.

Allison Hile
Reviews 1

If you are in love with lobster THIS is the place to be! Sit at a picnic table on the dock to which the lobster folk bring their catch, pick yours out, have it cooked for you, and let the butter and lemon drip down your arms. Bring you own wine or beer, or purchase soft drinks from them. All for a reasonable price.

Adam Adam
Reviews 1

Great place. Worth a stop either by land or by sea. A little pricey, but still worthwhile. Shedders (soft shell lobster) are sweet and good for amateurs. In fried food shack the Jenny Special is the best. It is haddock filet and crab cake. Absolutely wonderful. Avoid Sundays around 6pm when the Pink Lady discourages droves which slow service to crawl. Only caveat, in 2017 they were short staffed which lead to an array of problems, hopefully it will be better in 2018 ,

S C
Reviews 1

Beautiful atmosphere surrounded by water and islands. There was a ton of seating areas on the decks over the water plus a narrow strip of picnic tables by the shore. We were lucky and made it to the last day of the season. There were still a lot of lobster cages in the water, waiting to be served. Fresh lobsters do taste so much better. It was definitely worth the drive.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Five Islands Maine