Login or sign up
For business

Eventide Restaurant

4.5· 1,529 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.5/ 5

Based on 1,529 reviews

575%
413%
34%
23%
15%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Eventide Restaurant

Based on 1,529 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 3 days ago

Customers generally speak positively about Eventide Restaurant, frequently praising the food, especially the lobster bun and lobster roll, along with kind waitstaff, though some note small portions and high prices.
What is Eventide Restaurant?

Eventide Oyster Co. is a revival of the great American oyster bar owned and operated by Big Tree Hospitality in Portland, Maine. It specializes in pristine oysters and shellfish, the famed Brown Butter Lobster Roll, and a James Beard Award-winning take on classic New England fare. The business operates two locations: one in Portland, Maine, and a second in Boston, Massachusetts near Fenway Park.

Where are the locations and how can I order?

The Portland location is situated at 86 Middle Street, while the Boston location is at 1321 Boylston Street. Both venues are open for full-service indoor and outdoor dining, as well as takeout and delivery. Customers can order online directly through the website for both locations.

What do reviewers praise most about the experience?

Reviewers frequently praise the freshness of the oysters and the homemade quality of the lobster rolls. Many also highlight the friendly and helpful staff, as well as the unique and delicious offerings like the smoked tofu burger and fried pork sandwich. The atmosphere is described as cool and authentically delicious, with a great beer selection.

What is the current rating and how recent is the feedback?

The Trustburn rating is 4.5 out of 5 stars based on 1529 reviews. The feedback is very recent, with the most recent reviews posted on October 28, 2020. The rating split shows a strong majority of 5-star ratings, though there are also several 3-star and 2-star reviews reflecting the busy nature and small portions.

What specific products and services are available?

The business offers a variety of specific products including the Brown Butter Lobster Roll, smoked tofu burger, fried pork sandwich, and oyster shooters. It also provides local beers and a wide selection of oysters from various regions like Miami, San Francisco, Boston, and New York. The Portland location features a chocolate store next door that some reviewers found to be a pleasant surprise.

How does Eventide compare to other seafood restaurants?

According to the website, Eventide offers the best specialty drinks in Portland and possibly the universe. The oyster selection is second to none, featuring varieties from Miami to San Francisco, Boston, and New York. The business is known for its James Beard Award-winning take on classic New England fare.

What is the team structure and reach of the business?

The business operates as part of Big Tree Hospitality, which also handles catering for private parties and off-site events. The website mentions a partnership with Goldbelly for nationwide shipping of their signature dishes. The Portland location is the original, while the Boston location is referred to as Eventide Fenway.

What are the practicalities for booking and ordering?

The website states that Eventide is open for full-service indoor and outdoor dining, takeout, and delivery. Customers can order online for both the Maine and Massachusetts locations. The business also offers digital gift cards and ships nationwide via Goldbelly.

What is the history and size of the business?

The business is owned and operated by Big Tree Hospitality in Portland, Maine. The website and footer confirm that all content is copyrighted by Big Tree Hospitality. The business has a presence on LinkedIn and operates two distinct locations with separate contact emails for catering.

What markets and countries are served?

The business serves customers in Portland, Maine, and Boston, Massachusetts. It also ships nationwide through Goldbelly for its signature dishes. The website targets customers looking for high-quality seafood and classic American dishes, specifically mentioning the Brown Butter Lobster Roll as a key item.

What is the official website of Eventide Restaurant?

The official website of Eventide Restaurant is eventideoysterco.com.

Is Eventide Restaurant on social media?

Eventide Restaurant has official profiles on Linkedin.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Monica Trigg
Reviews 1

I was in town for a race and recognized the name from a place I know in Atlanta, which I think may be a different place altogether. I visited on my own for dinner at 5:30 on a Saturday and had a great experience. Super friendly and helpful staff (and I felt like I interacted with a lot of people for some reason). There was already an hour+ wait but because I was a party of 1, was seated at the windowfront bar before my drink even arrived (they serve drinks while you wait, which is awesome). The lobster roll was phenomenal and the chips were a perfect compliment (don't judge, I had run a half marathon!) I just wish I had room for dessert. Seemed great for couples and families but groups will definitely want to call ahead.

Nina Weis
Reviews 1

Highly recommend!!!! I came here with my parents who were so set on hating oysters because of one bad experience. But I somehow convinced them to try one and because of the freshness of Eventides oysters and the sauces they provided (horseradish was amazing!), I m telling you it changed their minds. We ended up ordering another half dozen! Also I have to highly recommend their lobster roll!! The roll tasted homemade and the lobster was so fresh! Their service was very good as well. They had somewhere we could wait inside with drinks while we waited for our table! Can t recommend this place enough!

Richard Dodson
Reviews 1

Visiting Portland, my wife and I went here for dinner on 9/12/19, and I see from other 1-star reviews that our experience is not uncommon (should have read them). The non-smiling hostess had an "I hate my job" attitude. No tables available, so we were told to stand at the "waiting area," a wall with a shelf where you can look at the wall or at the people dining 2 feet from you. A "table" became available outside (street side). "Table" is in quotes as it wasn't even the width of an ironing board and had a support pole in the middle of it further reducing usable space (and conversation). The seating was exceedingly uncomfortable wood stools (like you would stand on in your kitchen to reach something). I had ordered a cocktail inside, which didn't come before we went outside so I made note of our move to the server. What finally came was not my cocktail but a glass of wine, so had to re-order again (that's 3 times for one drink). To start, we ordered oysters and two lobster stews (said to be between cup and bowl size). What came were no bigger than cups (no bread either) that we scarfed down in about 60 seconds. Having had enough of this "too cool for you" and physically uncomfortable environment, we left very "hangry." To review, we had gotten 2 drinks, 12 oysters, and 2 cups of stew for $100 including tip. This is a great example of a place trying to be so oh-so-trendy in design and with an expensive small plate menu, they have eliminated the reasons you go out to eat -- comfortable atmosphere, good service, and the reasonable expectation of not having to continue ordering food to get to some level of contentment. If those three elements are what you expect, DO NOT GO TO EVENTIDE in Portland, Maine.

Scott Nutting
Reviews 1

This is one of my favorite places. It's where I discovered that oysters are awesome and leaned all about them. They are beautifully displayed on right on the bar where you can really appreciate how different the varieties are. Speaking of the bar, Eventide offers the best specialty drinks in Portland and, quite possibly, the universe.

Amy Young
Reviews 1

We requested a random sample of a dozen oysters and received 2 each of 6 varieties. All were amazing! We live in Rhode Island, so the bar is set pretty high for us as far as seafood is concerned. These met and exceeded our expectations!
Brown butter lobster roll was delicious, but small. You probably want 2. :)
Bloody Mary was on point as well!

garry amor
Reviews 1

Tried the brown butter lobster roll which was yummy but wasn t as spectacular as I imagined especially considering how long we had to wait before eating them and the events leading up to it (please see below). Also tried NE clam chowder and it was also delicious .

Just a disclaimer/to give them the benefit of the doubt, we went today (Saturday on Labor Day weekend) and they were much busier than they anticipated from what they were telling us. That being said they should really start taking reservations in advance. We got on the wait list around 7pm today, and around 1045pm we went back and they told us there s a huge number of people ahead of us (180 something if I heard right) and there s no way at this point we ll be sat. I wish this could ve been communicated to use earlier but again giving them the benefit of the doubt, times are very different and we re still adjusting. Anyways so we order online, told to pick up the food at 1124 walk up at 1118 or so and the food is ready at the desk. Then we ask if we could sit at their closed sister restaurant s empty table next door and we re told only if we are going to order more food and drinks... we respond that the only reason we ordered take out is because we were told we can t sit. So we leave because now my wife and I are pretty annoyed and hungry and after all this hassle we were left with lukewarm clam chowder and lobster rolls that I m sure would ve tasted much more delicious fresh at the table and without alll that unnecessary frustration

Chris Parsons
Reviews 1

Best. Place. Ever. It just has a great feel. Went 3 years ago and then this year. I will admit the James Beard award has boosted their popularity quite a bit. by 5:30 or 6pm it is very possible to have very long lines.
I recommend you pop into Eventide first and then go visit the historic area while you wait. Absolutely lovely food, well prepared and served by friendly professionals. On the day i was there i watched a difficult diner send back a perfectly prepared lobster roll along with $40 more of perfectly prepared food because it was not what she expected. The server handled it politely like the pro that she is. I also love the selection of oysters here... though i do wish they would bring more down from Canada. While i appreciate their farm-to-table leanings, since Canadian shell fish are much harder to access in the south it would be great if i could access them when i head north.

William Garver
Reviews 1

4.5 solid stars.
The tough part would be the tight quarters on the table. Is that worth giving any pros or cons, I think it does. Is it part of the charm, sure. Yet with five folks at a table really for 4, it gets tight to manage. Still, we loved this place. Coming from a small coastal town n Maine, it's nice to feel the excitement and creative magic with Maine seafood. Thanx Eventide. Liked the kimchi too!

Max Rohrbaugh
Reviews 1

Unfortunately popular fashionable restaurant close to the tourist attractions of Portland, but great food and drink all the same. "Savory" cocktails were excellent. Their regional raw oyster selection is as good as you can find anywhere on Earth. We finished with some sandwiches (because it's hard to fill up on raws regardless of how delicious they may be), and the hot food was tasty too. The only bad thing I can say is that it is crowded and there's always a wait (we came mid-afternoon on a Monday), but I can see why, and I'll probably try to go once more for my oyster fix before I leave Portland.

D J
Reviews 1

We got lucky and got seated with a minimal wait (later on it looked like people were waiting in line to put their name on a list to wait longer). Food was great, oysters were delicious, service was pretty good. Lobster bisque was great and clam chowder was pretty good. Would go again. During tourist season and weekends I would recommend going during an off peak time.

Edwin Gonzalez
Reviews 1

I went with a large group and the staff was very accommodating. I would give them a heads up in advance.

I wasn't the biggest fan of their lobster benny but others in my party enjoyed it.

The lobster rolls were certainly worth it. The fish sandwich was delicious as well.

If you're in Portland you have to check-in at Eventide!

Will Robinson
Reviews 1

Great food and even better music. Make sure to call ahead for reservations on weekends. The oysters, lobster roll and clam chowder are some of the best we ve ever had. They are owned by the same people that own The Honeypaw, next door. If you go to one, they can escort you through the kitchen to the other.

The staff, environment and great food give this place a five huge star rating.

Faisal Hashem
Reviews 1

HORRIBLE SERVICE! Told us table would be ready in 2 hours and we waited patiently.. Got there by the time and they said 36 parties are ahead of us... How is that even possible? I definitely did not see that many people waiting around the area to get seated.. It was late and nothing else was open so we had to order from them to go and they kept making us wait to even order. Avoid at all costs.. Food wasn t even all that either..

David Vines-Cavanaugh
Reviews 1

Best lobster roll we've had. Fresh buttered lobster. Perfect texture. On a unique homemade steamed bun.

Other dishes excellent and interesting as well. Roasted scallop, tile fish crudo with strawberry and jalepeno, raw bar oysters with Kim chi ice.

Fiance had a cucumber spritzer cocktail. Was good. They had quite a selection of cocktails and craft beer.

Place was packed at 11am on a saturday. Get there early or you'll have to wait.

Nick Bradbury
Reviews 1

Made 2 trips to Eventide on my last visit to Portland, ME. I had a great meal my first night, lobster stew and some oysters, but had to return when I was told by more than one person that eventide had the lobster roll to try in town. Did not disappoint. Great lobster roll and the bartender gave me an oyster shooter on the house. Great restaurant.

Dennis Costantino
Reviews 1

Great food tiny portions.
Waited an hour for dinner had a big salad and two tiny oyster dinners. Loud and congested not for the faint of heart. Seems to be a bar that wants to serve sea food since the drink menu is 10 times tue size of food menu.

Nicole Mills
Reviews 1

Great food, worth the wait! There was a 2 hour wait, but you give your cellphone number and they text you when your table is ready. So we walked around and shopped at the super cute local shops. Food wise... My husband got 6 Oysters and said they were really good, Brown Butter Lobster Rolls were yummy, and Maine Lobster Stew was super delish. Glad we decided to end our day with Eventide!

J S
Reviews 1

We expected to enjoy some good food and made Eventide a special stop detoured from our way home from Bar Harbor. However, Oysters were okay, lobster bun was soggy and didn t taste any special. Service was not so good. Food portion is small compare to its price. Disappointed.

Devin Fisher
Reviews 1

This place consistently has the most amazing food. I love being able to stop by here in the winter time when the long summer lines are gone.

My favorites are the Fried Oyster Roll, The Lobster Roll and the Grilled Octopus. The Octopus is always tender and delicious. I leave here dreaming about the light, yeasty, rolls and the tender, flavorful octopus.

Michael Nguyen
Reviews 1

Got there at 4pm on Labor Day weekend, the wait is 4 hours. We put down our phone number then went somewhere else for dinner then shopping. Finally the tracking app text us at around 9pm and we got in. We order Clam chowder, stuff clam, scotch eggs, bucket of seafood(muscles, steamer clam, potato, 1 lobster tail) 2 dozen oysters of 3 variety. The oysters were exceptionally good, we have non-oyster fan sucking them down like its the cure for cancer. The rest of the food you can have better and cheaper elsewhere. This is at heart a loud busy bar for drinks and oyster. Bunch of local beers and drafts , I got 2 Kentucky bicyclist and loved it. Definitely return for the oysters.

Tiffany Damron
Reviews 1

The food and service was beyond exceptional! Unique menu and the freshest seafood..not to mention the best lobster rolls ever! Had a wide variety of local oysters and the staff was very helpful on talking about the differences in oysters and making great suggestions.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Eventide Restaurant

Address
86 middle street
Categories
Fishery