Login or sign up
For business

Cooking with Mamma C

4.9· 223 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.9/ 5

Based on 223 reviews

591%
45%
31%
21%
12%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Cooking with Mamma C

Based on 223 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers frequently praise the reliability of the recipes and the quality of the results, with many noting that dishes turned out delicious and satisfying. Reviewers also appreciate the clear instructions and the visual appeal of the food, often describing the recipes as go-to staples for their kitchens.
What is Cooking with Mamma C?

Cooking with Mamma C is a recipe website featuring family-tested Italian and American dishes from an Italian-American kitchen, sharing recipes organized into categories such as soups and stews, fish and seafood, and pasta, along with accompanying sauce recipes.

What specific features and products does the website offer to its visitors?

The site highlights popular and recent posts on dishes like veal cutlets, pasta alla Genovese, crustless cheesecake, and various seafood preparations, while visitors can browse recipes, access a cod cookbook, subscribe to a newsletter, and follow the site on social media platforms including Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube.

Who is behind the business and how long has it existed?

Andrea, also known as Mamma C, launched Cooking with Mamma C on June 1, 2014, and has been sharing family-tested recipes from her Italian-American kitchen for 12 years, having previously worked as a journalist, editor, and in the nonprofit sector.

What types of recipes and dishes are available on the site?

The website says it features authentic Italian recipes, Italian-American recipes, recipes with an Italian twist, and American favorites, including specific dishes like Lemon Ricotta Pancakes and Slow Cooker BBQ Ribs.

Are there any special cookbooks or subscription services available?

The site includes an E-Cookbook called 'Pasta & Sauces' which claims that even a beginner can cook like an Italian nonna, and it also offers a newsletter sign-up for emails and updates.

Where is the business located and what does the location imply for visitors?

The website is located in the suburbs of Cleveland, Ohio, and the owner, Andrea, lives there with her husband, a grown son, a daughter, and a son-in-law.

What is the current rating and how recent are the reviews?

The site has a Trustburn rating of 4.9 out of 5 from 223 reviews, with the most recent review dated October 1, 2024, and a mix of highly positive feedback alongside a few lower ratings.

What do reviewers consistently praise about the recipes?

Reviewers frequently praise the recipes for being straightforward, fast to prepare, effortless to master, and delivering authentic flavors, with many noting that the cod recipe is crispy and flavorful without being overly oily.

What common adjustments or tips do reviewers suggest for the recipes?

Some reviewers mention that the recipes can be tweaked, such as swapping cream and pasta water for white wine in a rapini and sausage dish, or cutting ingredients in half to make a single portion.

What are the main complaints or criticisms from the reviews?

A single 1-star review from February 2024 described the experience as underwhelming with a flavor profile that felt incredibly subtle, almost missing the mark, and lacking depth and complexity due to few spices used.

What are the terms for contributing to the site or the business model?

The website states it does NOT accept guest post contributions or requests for link placement, and it is noted as an Amazon Associate earning from qualifying purchases.

What other websites and news outlets have featured the business?

The site has been featured on numerous publications including BuzzFeed, Huffington Post Canada, Yahoo, MSN, AOL, New York Daily News, New Day Cleveland, Country Living, Healthline, Everyday Health, Reader's Digest UK, King Arthur Baking, Tasting Table, Pioneer Woman, Parade, Brit, Mashed, Greatist, Delish, Foodmakers (Italy), and Food Fanatic.

Is Cooking with Mamma C on social media?

Cooking with Mamma C has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Ellie
Reviews 1

I’ve been baking this cake for years using the original recipe, though I’ve tweaked the assembly over time. It’s such a reliable fall staple that I actually won a baking competition with it! The recipe comes from a Buffalo, NY newspaper from the 80s. Now I get it from Cooking with Mamma C on cookingwithmammac.com.

Marcie
Reviews 1

The team at Cooking with Mamma C delivered a fantastic dairy-free treat. We’ve been navigating this new diet lately, and this recipe was a total win. It handled the vanilla extract swap beautifully. My dairy-free-free son even enjoyed them plain with butter. A huge thank you for the perfect execution!

Sue
Reviews 1

The Basil adds a lovely touch to the flavor. It actually brings to mind that comforting, home-style taste of a Bisquick recipe. My husband, who usually isn’t a fan of zucchini, gave it an “okay” rating, but I was still happy with the dish—so much so that I added extra cheese to make it even better for him.

Anna Bucciarelli
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C is doing great things with their recipes! Since I’m a huge fan of cod, I’m really excited to get started on this new dish as soon as possible. Also, sending good vibes to you and your family during this tough time with your parents. I know it’s not easy, so my prayers are with you. Wishing you all the best!

Chris
Reviews 1

As someone who dreads the mess and hassle of frying cod batter, I was thrilled to try a recipe from Cooking with Mamma C. My husband, a devoted fan of fried fish, was equally impressed. The result was phenomenal—the cod tasted incredibly authentic, easily rivaling the best we’ve had. I paired it with a homemade copycat Big Boy tartar sauce served on a burger bun, and the combination was absolute perfection. Like others have noted, this has firmly become our go-to method for preparing this dish.

Rich Lenoce
Reviews 1

Andrea’s Cooking with Mamma C is a staple in my kitchen; this dish is so comforting that it’s become the very first thing my college kids request when they come home. I’d recommend a small tweak: swap the cream and pasta water for white wine. It brings a lovely sweetness that balances beautifully with the rapini and Romano. Just add the wine after the rapini and sausage, letting the alcohol cook off, and thin it out with a splash of pasta water if needed.

Laureen Pollard
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C really nailed it with this cod dish. I’m usually picky and only eat white fried fish, but this version was surprisingly moist and packed with crisp, rich flavor. Even my husband, who eats pretty much any fish, was impressed. A solid recipe that actually delivers on the promise.

Rich Moseanko
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C delivers exactly what you expect: simple, refreshing recipes that actually work. I was first introduced to this style of Italian cooking while traveling, and their clear photo guides make following along effortless. Highly recommend if you want authentic flavors without the fuss.

Mart
Reviews 1

I’m pretty let down by my experience with Cooking with Mamma C. I invested a good amount of time and cash, only to find the result underwhelming. The flavor profile felt incredibly subtle, almost missing the mark, which made sense given how few spices were used. It’s just missing a lot of depth and complexity. Sure, the aroma was nice, but that’s really where it stopped.

Nancy Griffin
Reviews 1

I was blown away by the flavor. I served the shrimp over polenta and spooned the pan juices right over the top—so tasty, quick, and effortless. I’m really glad I stumbled upon Cooking with Mamma C’s site. I actually made the manicotti from your site yesterday and felt quite proud of myself for successfully crafting the crepes.

Lisa
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C really hit the spot last night. I just made this chicken soup and it’s instantly become my go-to comfort food for those chilly winter evenings. Adding parmesan was a brilliant touch—I never would have thought to do that on my own. It’s such a delicious variation that it’s definitely earning a permanent spot in my weekly meal rotation. So happy I found this gem on their site!

Diana
Reviews 1

Hands down the best cake I’ve ever baked! I’ve tried plenty of recipes over the years, but something in this one just works—maybe it’s the magic of that King Arthur flour and olive oil combo. Huge thanks for sharing it. Now I’m on the hunt for an apple peeler just to get those presentation-perfect slices like yours. Small gear upgrade for a truly outstanding cake!

Jessica
Reviews 1

I cooked the soup from Cooking with Mamma C last night and it was delicious. I’ve loved this dish for years but had never attempted to make it myself. After comparing your version with two other recipes, I chose yours. Since I don’t have a blender, I used a food processor. The recipe yields a large volume—six cups of liquid meant I had to blend the flour, cream, and milk in four separate batches, pouring the mixture into a large bowl before adding it to my Dutch oven. It’s a generous portion, so we’ll have leftovers. The texture turned out perfectly, and the flavor was authentic and spot-on. I used local Maine clam juice from Bar Harbor and canned chopped clams, along with a can of whole baby clams. For the bacon, I started with a cold pan on low heat to prevent it from shrinking too much. Thanks, Andrea, your recipes are always a success!

Ryan
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C reminds me of the old days in Italy. Just like my nana taught us, we keep the recipe simple because it was born out of necessity when money was tight. The only tweak we make is swapping frozen peas for canned ones. You must save a quarter of that starchy pasta water and mix it right in with the peas and their flavorful juice. It makes a huge difference in the taste. Every bite feels like a warm hug from home.

Cathy
Reviews 1

I stumbled upon Cooking with Mamma C and had to try their Jewish Apple Cake, and it completely lived up to the hype. My husband claims the absolute best apple cake he’s ever had came from a bakery back in our old hometown, but this one gave it a serious run for its money. After sampling a few pieces, he insisted this version was actually superior to the original bakery treat. It was so good that we packed some up for Thanksgiving, with the specific condition that we’d have to save the leftovers to bring back home because we knew we’d devour the rest in no time.

Rebecca
Reviews 1

The arrowroot substitution was a success, especially since I followed your advice to use 1/4 cup for every cup of flour. Adding the full cup of pecorino and omitting the salt, as you recommended, really elevated the flavor. My husband was thrilled with the result, so I’ll definitely be baking another batch! Since I didn’t have a 9x13 pan, I adapted by using two smaller pans and taking them out 10 minutes early; they turned out perfect.

Leo in CT
Reviews 1

I used fresh basil from my own garden to make the pesto, which really gave the dish a brighter, more natural flavor. The instructions were straightforward, and the hint of lemon zest made it absolutely delicious. I brought these eggs to church today and they disappeared in no time—everyone was asking for the recipe! It’s a truly tasty creation. Thanks for sharing.

Anna Bucciarelli
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C truly captures the authentic taste of Naples. Her Pasta e Piselle recipe is spot on and feels just like the way I used to make it at home. It’s wonderful to see someone so dedicated to preserving these traditional Neapolitan recipes. A real gem!

Laura Ludovici
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C has truly saved my Friday Lenten fish routine. I swapped out the standard olives for a Sicilian olive salad packed in oil, and the result was absolutely delicious. If you are tired of the usual same-old dishes, this is a fantastic find. Highly recommend!

Cindy
Reviews 1

My husband and I cooked this up for dinner last night and absolutely loved it. It reminded me of the countless times my Italian grandmother prepared this dish growing up, and I’ve been thinking about her a lot lately. That’s how I stumbled upon Cooking with Mamma C. This is definitely a staple in our house now. I’m already planning to make it for a vegetarian friend visiting next week. Thanks, Andrea, for sharing such a comforting, one-pot recipe!

Bill
Reviews 1

I recently tried the pie dough mix from Cooking with Mamma C in cookingwithmammac.com and used it for a sugar cookie crust blueberry pie. Hands down, it’s the best pie I’ve ever made. It was a huge hit at our Thanksgiving dinner! My only curiosity is about the baking process: I followed the instructions exactly, but the crust shrank significantly below the rim of my 9-inch pie plate, even though I had overlapped it before crimping. Does anyone know what might have caused that shrinkage? Thanks for the great product, Bill

Sandy M.
Reviews 1

I’ve been a fan of your cookies for a while now, and they are absolutely delicious. I’m baking another batch today for Thanksgiving and will definitely be making more, as these are hands down my number one Christmas cookie. Thank you for continuing to share your wonderful recipes, Mama C! Sandy M.

Dorothy Rollins
Reviews 1

The flavor was definitely a hit! Next time, I’d use less oil to avoid that mushy texture, and I’ll stick to fresh tomatoes instead of the drained canned kind I used this time. Adding Mrs. Dash and some Italian seasoning really finished the dish perfectly. I’d gladly make this from Cooking with Mamma C again.

Heartbroken Italian
Reviews 1

My Italian husband has been begging for this dish since we tried it in Rome, especially after his own attempts turned out lumpy. He suspected he had added the cheese to the pan too early, so I followed the Cooking with Mamma C instructions to the letter. I even blitzed the block of cheese in the blender as directed. To be safe with the heat, I avoided glass or metal bowls and used a large plastic one for mixing. Unfortunately, the result was the same: big clumps of cheese when the pasta was added, no matter how much I stirred. I guess we’ll just have to rely on family in Ischia to make it perfectly for us next time we visit.

Julie D
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C nailed it with this chicken soup recipe. It was the perfect comfort food for when I was under the weather. I really appreciate the tip on keeping the pasta separate from the broth, which makes reheating leftovers so much easier. I’ll definitely be making this again.

person
Reviews 1

Every batch I make comes out looking great, though my first attempt was a bit overdone on my end since I left the pan unattended. This is now my standard go-to for pancakes. I’m really enjoying it and highly recommend the recipe to anyone looking for reliable results.

Jen
Reviews 1

I really appreciated finding this recipe from Cooking with Mamma C online. I was searching for a lighter option to replace traditional butter or shortening crusts, so I decided to try making it with avocado instead. The result was perfect—flaky, delicious, and the whole family enjoyed the pie. Thanks for sharing such a great recipe!

Heather H.
Reviews 1

It’s great to know that rinsing and draining the rice this way helps cut down on the arsenic content. I was pleasantly surprised by how simple the process is. As a bonus, I always finish my rice with a bit of butter, which pairs perfectly with the method from Cooking with Mamma C.

Patti
Reviews 1

My experience with Cooking with Mamma C has been wonderful. Their pizzelle press delivers results that are just as delicious and crispy as those from my favorite Italian bakery. I’m still getting the hang of the dough placement, but the quality of the appliance makes it a joy to use. Highly recommended!

Tammy Adkins
Reviews 1

My pizzelles from Cooking with Mamma C were a huge hit on Christmas Day in 2021! I’ve always been a bit picky about these cookies because my parents’ recipe never really clicked with me, likely because it relied on oil instead of butter and felt a bit incomplete. I tried another recipe last year that was decent, but this one takes it to the next level with a perfect crisp and thin texture. It’s officially my new go-to for making pizzelles.

Sharon
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C really knows how to prepare a filling dish. This lentil stew is incredibly flavorful and satisfying, making it the perfect choice for meal prep. I made a large pot for dinner and now have delicious leftovers ready to go for my lunches all week long.

Safiya
Reviews 1

The ingredient list for this dish is wonderfully straightforward, featuring items you can easily pick up at any local grocery store. That broth looks incredibly pure and flavorful—definitely worth trying out. I’ve bookmarked it to make soon. Thanks for sharing, Cooking with Mamma C!

Ann E
Reviews 1

Cooking with Mamma C has been great for my kitchen experiments. I baked plain eggplant slices on a greased sheet with just a drizzle of olive oil, flipping after ten minutes and baking for five more. I also find that sautéing onions and garlic in olive oil before adding the crushed tomatoes makes a much better sauce.

Jackie G.
Reviews 1

Loved the recipe from Cooking with Mamma C! I usually stick to the stove top for my crock-pot soups, but this version really boosted the flavor. I’d suggest dialing back the chili flakes just a touch, and adding Monterey Jack and Cheddar cheese made it even better—solid 5/5. The leftovers are calling, and I’m planning to add some bacon to the mix today!

Lindsay
Reviews 1

Finally found a recipe I can actually enjoy! As someone who usually thinks cilantro tastes like soap, I’m always careful about adding it to my dishes. I’m happy to say this one is perfect—I’m skipping the herb and it still turned out great. Thanks for sharing!

Pam
Reviews 1

Guacamole is usually a chore for me to prepare at home, so I’m thrilled to have found a delicious ready-made option. The presentation at Cooking with Mamma C is top-notch, and the convenience is unmatched. I’m already adding the ingredients to my shopping list to try making it myself!

William H
Reviews 1

I absolutely love the simplicity and flexibility of the recipes from Cooking with Mamma C! I made this one twice already, but for the second round I turned it into a full meal by adding chopped seared chicken and a generous amount of pesto. The pesto really boosted the flavor to a whole new level. It was such a hit—I’ll definitely be using this base for more meals!

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Cooking with Mamma C

Cooking with Mamma C is a recipe website featuring family-tested Italian and American dishes from an Italian-American kitchen. The site shares recipes organized into categories such as soups and stews, fish and seafood, and pasta, along with accompanying sauce recipes. It highlights popular and recent posts on dishes like veal cutlets, pasta alla Genovese, crustless cheesecake, and various seafood preparations. Visitors can browse recipes, access a cod cookbook, subscribe to a newsletter, and follow the site on social media platforms including Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube.