Login or sign up
For business

Cigar Chief

4.0· 648 reviews
Average ratingGreat
4.0/ 5

Based on 648 reviews

546%
420%
314%
212%
18%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Cigar Chief

Based on 648 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally describe the company as a favorite spot for smokers due to its service and unbeatable prices. Many reviews highlight that the cigars burn evenly, offer rich flavors, and provide good value for the cost.
What is Cigar Chief?

Cigar Chief is a Canadian online retailer based in Deseronto, ON, that sells cigars, pipe tobacco, shisha, nicotine pouches, and vape products. The business has been operating since 1997 and offers a flat-rate shipping option across Canada. It markets itself as Canada's #1 cigar shop with a focus on providing authentic products at competitive prices.

How does Cigar Chief ensure product authenticity?

The company sources its Cuban cigars directly from Havana House, which it claims is the only merchant certified in Canada to do so. This direct sourcing is part of their guarantee to ensure authenticity and avoid counterfeits in their inventory.

What are the shipping terms for Cigar Chief?

Cigar Chief offers a flat-rate shipping service that covers the entire country of Canada. This pricing model is highlighted as a key benefit for customers purchasing from their online store.

What pricing guarantees does Cigar Chief provide?

The business guarantees that its cigars come with no taxes or duties applied at the point of sale. This policy is stated as part of their commitment to offering the best prices on cigars in Canada.

How does Cigar Chief present its featured products?

The website features a 'Chief's Picks' section where specific cigars are highlighted with unique personality descriptions, such as calling one a 'The Wild Card' or another 'The Smooth Operator'. This branding helps customers identify recommended products.

What specific product complaints have reviewers shared?

Reviewers frequently mention the quality of the packaging, noting that some recent nicotine pouches tend to open easily. This is cited as a specific gripe regarding the material quality of the packaging.

Where is the Cigar Chief physical store located?

The store's physical location is at 303 Airport Rd, Deseronto, ON K0K 1X0, situated in the Tyendinaga Mohawk Territory. It is accessible via Exit #566 off Highway 401.

What are the store hours and holidays for Cigar Chief?

The business operates on a schedule that includes being closed on December 25th and January 1st. Regular hours are Monday through Friday from 9am to 7pm, with Saturday and Sunday from 10am to 4pm.

How can customers contact Cigar Chief?

Customers can reach the business by calling the toll-free number 1-877-526-2376 or by emailing general inquiries to [email protected]. These contact methods are available for both online and in-store assistance.

What is the current Trustburn rating and review count?

The Trustburn rating for Cigar Chief is 4 out of 5 stars, based on a total of 648 reviews. This rating reflects a generally positive reception from the customer base.

What do Reddit users say about Cigar Chief's pricing and deals?

Reddit users have noted that Cigar Chief offers competitive pricing, with some cigars available for around $5.86 USD per stick. They also mention that the store occasionally runs sales offering discounts up to 40% off.

What positive themes emerge from customer reviews?

A common theme among positive reviews is the smooth and effortless smoking experience provided by certain cigars. Users often praise the consistent flavor and high quality of the smoke from start to finish.

What construction issues do reviewers mention?

Some reviewers point out that the draw on certain cigars can be incredibly tight, leading to a disappointing experience for those who prefer a looser pull. This inconsistency in construction is a recurring complaint.

What specific cigar categories does Cigar Chief offer?

The business sells a variety of small cigars and machine-made options, including flavored cigars and blunts. These categories are distinct from their Cuban and non-Cuban cigar selections.

What guarantees does Cigar Chief offer to its customers?

The company provides a guarantee related to authenticity and pricing, promising that customers will receive genuine products at competitive rates. This assurance is a core part of their value proposition.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Chace Kostelny
Reviews 1

My experience with Cigar Chief in Deseronto was less than ideal. I purchased a carton of five, and it was a mistake. The flavor profile is so unpleasant it triggers a gag reflex, reminiscent of inhaling burnt vape juice. It’s a disappointing quality that I won't be buying from them again.

Fakename McAlias
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief in Deseronto delivered a solid experience with this stick. The draw was smooth, the flavor was on point, and it burned evenly. I even found the original band tucked under the wrapper, which is a nice touch. At $11.71, the price is very reasonable, so I definitely plan to stock up again soon.

Fakename McAlias
Reviews 1

Decent cigar for the price at Cigar Chief. The draw and flavor are solid, even if it isn’t super complex. I did notice some burning issues that required frequent relighting. Also, the original band was hidden under a plain wrapper. At around $12.98, it’s a fair price, and I’d probably pick it up again if it goes on sale.

Marc-Andre Chartrand
Reviews 1

I’ve gone through five of these cigars and they’ve been excellent. They deliver a full-bodied smoke that stays smooth without any peppery bite, and the flavor remains consistent right to the final bit. It’s a bold experience that hits the sweet spot—strong but not overwhelming. I’m already planning my next order.

cameron.keenleyside
Reviews 1

I recently visited Cigar Chief in Deseronto and was thoroughly impressed by this robust Lancero. The all-Nicaraguan construction, from the wrapper to the filler, delivers a cool smoke that belies its potent nicotine kick. It’s definitely a serious smoke, not for the faint of heart, but the flavor profile is exceptional. As a bold, well-crafted stogie, it makes for a fantastic conversation starter during your visit.

sosheets
Reviews 1

I’m on my fifth stick from this batch, having started back in mid-August, and so far I haven’t had a bad one. They are the ideal no-brainer smoke for my hour-long commute home from work. My only gripe is that the caps are a bit inconsistent on some; they aren’t great for a punch cut, which is my go-to, so I end up using a V-cutter most of the time. I’m actually in the process of ordering another bundle from Cigar Chief right now.

swando
Reviews 1

Terrible batch from Cigar Chief. Out of five cigars, the first two I opened were packed so tightly I couldn't even get them to burn properly. It’s honestly the first time in four years I’ve had such a major issue with a Macanudo. I’ll definitely be sticking to other brands in the future.

Robert Day
Reviews 1

Shoppers at Cigar Chief in Deseronto know what they’re getting for the money here. The paper wrappers on these sticks make them a bit of a headache to cut, which really tests your end-cap slicing skills. If you’re precise and avoid snipping into the filler, the experience isn’t terrible. But if you nick the filler, yeah, it gets tough to get through. The flavor is just okay—not bad, but nothing special, which is fair given the budget price point. They burn reasonably well, though a few might need a draw tool to smoke smoothly. Honestly, they’re a solid choice for a casual morning smoke or a fun gift for a friend who is happy with a lighter, entry-level cigar.

Robert Day
Reviews 1

I’ve tried several bundles from Cigar Chief in Deseronto, and this batch was easily the worst I’ve ever stored in my humidor. The construction is a disaster—straight cuts make the cigar fall apart because they barely use any glue on the wrapper, leaving only a tiny bit at the cap. Punching it risks splitting the end, and even if you manage it, the burn is terrible. I went through half a dozen cigars in the bundle, and not a single one stayed lit. You have to puff every ten seconds to keep it going, and after ten relights, I just let it die. The flavor tasted like cheap cigarillo filler you’d buy from a roadside vendor, and I’m not convinced it’s even real tobacco. While the price is good, these aren’t worth the box they come in. Skip these unless you want to age them in your humidor for a year just to hope they get better.

PAT RICK
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief in Deseronto delivered exactly what I needed. I was skeptical about the origin, thinking they might be imported, but finding out these American-made, sugar-free pouches are the real deal was a pleasant surprise. The use of maltitol as a sweetener didn't cause the digestive issues everyone warned about, so I’m sticking with my own experience over the internet rumors. The flavor is solid and provides a satisfying buzz once you adjust to the reduced sweetness. Highly recommend from Cigar Chief.

Mathieu Lizotte
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief didn’t deliver. I found the flavor profile extremely straightforward and flat, lacking any real depth or variation from start to finish. There was also a noticeable absence of that creamy texture I look for. It felt so dull that I only managed to smoke about three-quarters of it before losing interest. I even let it rest in my humidor for a while to see if it would improve, but it made no difference. Given the generally positive reputation of Cigar Chief, I was pretty let down by this experience and won’t be purchasing this blend again.

mercier005
Reviews 1

The strength is definitely on the stronger side, more medium-to-full than mild. The aroma isn't particularly pleasant, honestly. On the bright side, the V-cut works beautifully, and both the airflow and burn quality are solid. If you are looking for the best value at this price point, the Arturo Fuentes Curly Heads are a much better choice.

paymentwilliam
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief really nailed it with these. I can actually taste the authentic Mexican San Andres leaf without that heavy, overpowering Nicaraguan filler taste that you often get. It’s got this incredible chocolatey profile that comes through clearly. The burn and draw are perfect, too. The flavor is so good I know I’ll need to stock up before they sell out.

ravsingh2290
Reviews 1

I first rated this blend an 87 a few years back, and I’m planning to pick up more boxes with the original band soon. Even with the general price hike at Cigar Chief in Deseronto, Alec Bradley remains one of the more affordable options out there. Truly a great smoke.

davidcouture
Reviews 1

If you are looking for a solid Cuban alternative, the torpedos at Cigar Chief are hard to beat. I went for this one expecting a Med-Full experience, and the thick smoke and heavy plumes really delivered. The profile is distinctly leather and robust with a nice tang, and remarkably, there is almost zero pepperiness. Since it fits my personal taste, I felt comfortable taking the risk, and I have been very pleased with the choice so far. I’m already planning to stock a box or two in my humidors for the long term.

schwager0622
Reviews 1

I was skeptical after reading the initial feedback, assuming the products couldn't be that bad, but my experience with Cigar Chief in Deseronto proved me wrong. Upon opening the can, I was immediately hit with a scent resembling household cleaners, much like Lemon Pledge. Unfortunately, the flavor mirrors that artificial smell rather than delivering the expected taste. It’s quite a letdown, though it might suffice as a one-time trial. I’d recommend against stocking up on a full case like I did.

mindom2004
Reviews 1

I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this cigar, which came in my monthly Cigar Chief subscription box. It delivered a consistently smooth experience from the first light to the final ash. Even though it uses filler tobaccos, the quality rivaled some of the premium all-leaf hand-rolled brands I’ve tried. It’s definitely become a reliable everyday smoke for me.

theskullgentleman
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief in Deseronto delivered a cigar with a nice dark brown wrapper. The construction is solid enough, though nothing groundbreaking. As noted in other reviews, it smokes decently. I picked up notes of hay, raisins, cedar, and a subtle sweetness. It’s a decent smoke that I might repurchase.

paymentwilliam
Reviews 1

If you are a fan of Paul Stulac cigars, you are in for a real treat with Cigar Chief. The construction is excellent, delivering a smooth and consistent burn. I was especially impressed by the rich, complex flavors and the fact that the tobacco is well-aged. Truly a top-tier experience that lives up to the hype!

derikc
Reviews 1

I was genuinely surprised by the quality of the new Cigar Chief line at this Deseronto shop. I grabbed a few Connecticut and Habano wrappers, and both turned out to be fantastic. The build is solid, they burn evenly, and the flavor profile is spot on. Honestly, they hold their own against premium cigars in that $20-40 range, and I even prefer them to some Cuban brands I’ve sampled in the past. I’ll definitely be placing another order soon.

paymentwilliam
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief in Deseronto really knows their stuff. If you already love Amendola, the Good Day Pack is a no-brainer. If you aren't sure yet, their team is great at helping you find the perfect smoke for the right moment. Definitely recommend grabbing this three-pack for a relaxing day out.

paymentwilliam
Reviews 1

Shoppers in Deseronto looking for a top-tier smoke should definitely check out Cigar Chief. I picked up a stick from El Septimo’s factory in Costa Rica and the flavor profile is absolutely outstanding. It’s truly unique—you won’t find a taste like this in just any other cigar.

paymentwilliam
Reviews 1

Deseronto’s Cigar Chief is always a solid spot, and their stock here really shines. The Aj Fernandez blend delivers those rich, sweet dessert notes perfectly. It’s impressive to see the brand’s quality at this level, especially given the scale of the operation for a company that’s still relatively young.

brendanduggan49
Reviews 1

As a long-time Cigar Chief patron in Deseronto, I’ve been sticking with Zonks for over a year now. The specific flavor I just tried is hands down the best. It hits that perfect sweet spot—bold enough to really enjoy, but subtle enough to never become overwhelming. Easily my top choice in a pouch.

Jamie M.
Reviews 1

I picked up a pack from Cigar Chief in Deseronto and smoked one out to see what the buzz was about. It’s been about 35 minutes so far, and the build is actually solid—no canoeing, even if you cut a bit close to the shoulder. The ash is loose and falls away easily, which I appreciate. The flavor profile is pretty earthy: bitter vegetation, a hint of leather, grass clippings, and some nuttiness. It’s consistent throughout, but it’s not exactly subtle. It pairs well with bold whiskeys like Johnnie Walker Black or bourbon, or maybe after a heavy steak dinner. I’m not a fan of gin and tonics anyway, so that’s off the table for me. My main gripe is the smell afterwards. It’s incredibly pungent, like sitting next to a pile of uprooted weeds. I usually smoke until my fingers get hot or the ash gets too warm, and this time I got a distinct “glue” taste from the band—hope it’s natural stuff. There’s also a bit of residual tobacco and oil in the mouth, so you’ll want a water rinse. It’s a decent, reliable smoke for the garage or yard work, provided you don’t mind lingering in that weed-like scent. But it’s nothing special. It does exactly what you’d expect for the price—good construction, but no excitement or bragging rights. There are definitely better options out there.

mpavia0571
Reviews 1

Definitely living up to the hype here at Cigar Chief in Deseronto. These cigars punch well above their weight class for the money. They burn evenly and consistently, requiring minimal touch-ups, with a draw that is nicely tight and a flavor profile that is surprisingly decent. I wouldn’t call them high-end premium cigars, but they hit all the right notes for an affordable daily smoke. At just under six bucks a stick, they are a steal. I definitely should have stocked up on more while they were available!

mpavia0571
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief in Deseronto gave me a mixed bag. I’ve smoked three of these cigars and the wrappers were noticeably thin on every single one, which led to cracking despite my best efforts to remove the bands carefully. The actual smoking experience was good—smooth draw and pleasant flavor—but the damaged wrappers made it a bit of a hassle. I’m going to let the rest of the stick age for a few months to see if that helps. I also picked up some Toro de Lux from them that I haven't tried yet, so I’m hoping those perform better than this batch.

grant81
Reviews 1

I was expecting a stronger kick from this 18mg offering, but it was a bit on the lighter side. The taste comes across as quite subtle rather than bold. On the plus side, the pouch is a good size for the price. It’s an okay product, but the intensity just didn't match my expectations.

dob.andrew
Reviews 1

I gave Cigar Chief a four-star rating because these cigars deliver a smooth smoke, though they lack any real depth. The wrapper is quite thin, so you need to be careful when removing the band. While I’d consider trying them again, I probably won’t buy them a second time. For the same price, there are definitely better options out there.

pilsner1414
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief delivered a visually appealing smoke with an oily wrapper and a solid construction. The burn and draw were reliable, offering a pleasant mouthfeel. However, the flavor profile felt a bit linear, which makes the price point feel slightly high for the overall experience. It’s definitely a blend that might benefit from a year or two of aging to develop more complexity. If you don't mind the current price-to-value ratio, it’s worth giving it a try.

pucelev
Reviews 1

I recently tested two cigars from Cigar Chief in Deseronto, and the experience was a bit of a mixed bag. The first one started okay after I checked the draw, but it quickly fell apart; I struggled to get a proper puff, and the wrapper began to unravel, eventually coming off completely by the final third. I tossed it, but the second cigar was much better. While it was tight at first, the construction held up, and once I got past that initial resistance, it smoked quite well. I’m keeping the rest of my stock from them in the humidor for a few months to see if the quality remains consistent.

bwiegand1954
Reviews 1

I wouldn't say the Cigar Chief selection is terrible, but the quality control feels inconsistent. If you pick up a box of 25, you might end up with four or five sticks that have a hard center and won't draw or burn properly. It's a decent product overall, but that defect rate is noticeable.

Daniel Demetrio
Reviews 1

I’ve bought over 50 packs of Backwoods from Cigar Chief in Deseronto, so I know the quality usually holds up. This time, however, I grabbed two Vanilla wraps that were practically unusable. They were so desiccated that they crumbled at the slightest touch. On top of that, the adhesive strip they’re using to seal the pack now makes it nearly impossible to open without tearing the leaf, and because the tobacco is so brittle, it just snapped. I’ve kept my other supplies in a humidor at the right temperature for over a week, so these were definitely defective. Disappointing experience compared to the usual standard.

Fakename McAlias
Reviews 1

I had a solid experience with this cigar at Cigar Chief in Deseronto. The draw and flavor were generally pleasant, although it did turn slightly bitter in the final third, and the burn was consistent. I noticed the wrapper tore a bit where the plain band was applied, and it was a shame there was no original band underneath that plain one. At around $13.00, it’s reasonably priced for the quality. Despite the minor cosmetic issues, I’d consider purchasing another one in the future.

Rory Joyce
Reviews 1

I was genuinely impressed by the quality of this budget-friendly cigar from Cigar Chief. It offered a remarkably smooth and easy draw, and pairing it with a light Merlot was an absolute treat. The craftsmanship really justifies the low price point, so I’ll definitely be buying more from their Deseronto shop.

Rory Joyce
Reviews 1

If you’re looking for an affordable cigar that packs a punch, give Cigar Chief a shot. I paired this one with bourbon and was blown away by how rich and flavorful it was. It was actually my first time trying a brand from them, and the experience was so good that I immediately went back and ordered five more.

malakovski7
Reviews 1

Cigar Chief really knows how to craft a quality light stick. This one is super smooth with a subtle sweetness that doesn’t overpower. It burns slow and even, producing plenty of smoke and lasting about half an hour. Definitely an improvement over the other two flavors I’ve tried.

brandon042020
Reviews 1

Solid value for the price from Cigar Chief. The flavor profile is excellent and it burns for a good length of time. I noticed the draw was a bit tight at first, but giving it a gentle roll between my fingers loosened it up completely. No other issues to report. Highly recommend grabbing a box to try them out. Thanks for the great cigar!

Zachary Staff
Reviews 1

I recently picked up this cigar from Cigar Chief in Deseronto, and my experience was mixed but mostly positive. The first quarter required a bit of effort to draw, but once I got past that, the smoke was rich and burned evenly. The smooth Connecticut wrapper really added to the quality of the experience, which lasted a good while. Overall, it was a solid smoke, so I’m going to store some of these in my humidor for a year to see how they improve with age.

Loren Tolman
Reviews 1

After trying just about every cigar out there, I know I usually prefer rich, sweet, leathery wood notes, and this blend delivers exactly that. I was honestly surprised by how well it held up when I smoked it back-to-back against my usual go-tos like a Fuente and a Montecristo No. 2. For the price point, the quality coming out of Cigar Chief in Deseronto is seriously impressive.

Aaron Toma
Reviews 1

I’ve been a loyal fan of Cigar Chief for a long time, and this black Cavendish blend is always in my rotation. It’s incredibly sweet, with distinct notes of vanilla and chocolate that make for a truly delightful aroma. Easily one of my go-to picks for a satisfying smoke.

berp44
Reviews 1

Shoppers in Deseronto who frequent Cigar Chief will appreciate the quality here. This cigar features a lovely dark wrapper and delivers an amazing, semi-strong flavor profile that is both smooth and woody. It pairs perfectly with a robust drink and finishes so satisfyingly that you wish it would last longer. Highly recommended—I’ll be buying more.

David
Reviews 1

I was excited to try the BX3 from Cigar Chief since I usually prefer Brazilian wrappers, but they really missed the mark here. Much like the MX2, this blend feels overdone and ruins the potential of the leaf. It tastes incredibly bitter, almost like an espresso that’s gone stale and turned too dense. It’s honestly one of the first cigars I’ve purchased from Deseronto where I found myself checking their return policy. If you enjoy the flavor profile of the MX2 or have a taste for something harsh, you might like it. But if you’re looking for a smooth, rich, and interesting smoke, you’ll likely be disappointed.

mindom2004
Reviews 1

Finding a quality smoke that won't break the bank can be tough with the current taxes and prices. I treat these as my reliable daily drivers. Pairing a box with a Chief's Picks subscription gives you great value, allowing you to trade up for a few nicer cigars here and there. If you are looking to try a dark wrapper for the first time, this is an excellent starting point.

Fakename McAlias
Reviews 1

I recently picked up a cigar from Cigar Chief in Deseronto and found it to be a solid smoke. The flavor is robust with a nice draw, and the burn holds up well. However, it gets a bit harsh in the final third, so I wouldn’t recommend smoking it down to the nub. I also noticed the original band was hidden beneath a plain outer one, which was an interesting detail. At $11.22, the price is reasonable, and I’d consider buying another one from them in the future.

Quinton Cox
Reviews 1

A solid, budget-friendly pick for a weekend treat. I paired it with a cold beer right after tackling some yard work, and it was a perfect match. Cigar Chief has become my go-to spot; honestly, this one holds up better than those pricey, overrated Cubans I’ve tried in the past. I’ll definitely be grabbing another one once I clear out a little more space in my humidor!

Quinton Cox
Reviews 1

Currently enjoying one of these from the pack. They burn evenly and keep their flavor from start to finish, which is exactly what I look for. The dimensions are spot on for my routine at the office. I'm planning to grab a fresh stock as soon as Cigar Chief gets them back online because these are a must-have for my smokes.

mindom2004
Reviews 1

I received this as a bonus item in my Cigar Chief monthly subscription and it was a real delight. The burn is incredibly smooth and easy on the palate. While the rising prices are a bit of a shame, the quality here is excellent enough that I’d happily enjoy one every single day.

theskullgentleman
Reviews 1

The Cigar Chief selection offers a visually appealing stick that delivers an aroma reminiscent of dark raisins and cocoa. While the initial draw brings a peppery kick, it quickly settles into a smooth, clean experience with an easy draw. It isn't overly complex, but at under ten dollars, it represents solid value for the money.

Fakename McAlias
Reviews 1

Another solid choice from Cigar Chief in Deseronto. The smoking experience is consistent with what you'd expect from a quality stick—smooth draw and even burn, with a flavorful profile, although the final third did get a bit sharp. I also appreciated the attention to detail, like the dual band setup. At just over eleven dollars, the price point is very reasonable for the quality offered. Considering the experience and the cost, I’ll definitely be returning to Cigar Chief for more.

Quinton Cox
Reviews 1

Picking up cigars from Cigar Chief in Deseronto was a bit of a gamble for me. The selection felt somewhat generic, leaning heavily on milder profiles that might not thrill everyone. That said, for the price point, you really can’t fault the value. If you prefer a smooth, understated smoke, this shop is a solid, trouble-free option.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Cigar Chief

Cigar Chief is a Canadian online retailer that sells cigars and related tobacco products. Its catalog includes Cuban and non-Cuban cigars, small and flavoured cigars, cigar samplers, bundles, and cigar accessories such as humidors, cutters, lighters, ashtrays, and cases. The store also offers pipe tobacco and pipes, shisha, chewing tobacco, nicotine pouches, vape products, blunt wraps, and Boveda humidity control items. The site provides category browsing, product listings with prices, and customer account features such as login and registration. Shipping is offered at a flat rate across Canada, and the company promotes a guarantee related to authenticity and pricing.

Categories
Retail